Re: Charity for publicity
Copy cat 
Pakistan Mai yeh bhi hota hai? 
And I thought YouTube was only shut for 5 days?
Re: Charity for publicity
ahh well as long as they are giving charity..its all good.
Whtever their reason , its resulting in aid to the poor so its all good.
Observed many Pakistani politicians distributing aid goods and getting photo session. It seems if media refuses to give coverage to their distribution ceremony, they won't bother to distribute anything.
There was a time (and may be it still continues), when newspaper pages were full of pictures of Mrs Minister or Mrs industrialist giving sewing machine to poor ladies.
Is this with our society that want to publicize charity (in other words they do charity for publicity) or other cultures are also affected with these stunts?
Re: Charity for publicity
^ so it's ok to show off?
Re: Charity for publicity
off topic but some western philanthropist are way ahead in charity and donating....buffet,gates,rockfeller
Abskolutely.
Re: Charity for publicity
yes...publicity of charity is good if it inspire others for charity
Someone is in full form today. Hitting shots all around the wicket.
Abskolutely x 2
Re: Charity for publicity
what? kiskii copy kii maiN ne? 
yeh to har Musalmaan jaantaa hai k sadaaqaat denaa seGha e raaz meN rakkhnaa afzal hai.
Re: Charity for publicity
^ so it's ok to show off?
If the choice is to show off and give charity vs. Not show off and not give then answer is yes.
Re: Charity for publicity
what? kiskii copy kii maiN ne? :D yeh to har Musalmaan jaantaa hai k sadaaqaat denaa seGha e raaz meN rakkhnaa afzal hai.
Meri copy Ki, Maine bhii yehi likha.
Re: Charity for publicity
If the choice is to show off and give charity vs. Not show off and not give then answer is yes.
My question has a explanation .But you won't understand it.
Re: Charity for publicity
Meri copy Ki, Maine bhii yehi likha.
tumhaarii koii post merii post se pahle hai kia? thii bhii to maiN ne to dekhii bhii nahiiN! :D
Re: Charity for publicity
My question has a explanation .But you won't understand it.
People with open minds try to understand all points of view. Try me.
Re: Charity for publicity
Muqaw bhai you must have heard, sadqa is tarah chupa ke do ke aik hath se do to doosre ko pata na chale,
So IMO Charity too should be giving secretly,regardless of what it is, takay lene ko sharminda na houna pare.
chhupaa ke denaa afzal hai magar khule aam koii de to buraa bhii nahiiN aur sawaab meN bhii kamii nahiiN hogii par masnoon Islamii tareeqa yehii hai k ek haath de dusre haath ko Khabar na ho. :)
Re: Charity for publicity
Pehley apki thee
In Islam,and even in Bible,it’s said that when you do a good deed don’t show off,If you do you won’t get a reward For it.
Re: Charity for publicity
to phir maiN copy catter kaise ho gayaa? 
Re: Charity for publicity
Kin with 2z I guessed you would state that. Since you had quoted a verse in Hindi earlier stating same along with Khaan.
OK you may not get reward. But other person still benefits hai ki nahin? I agree ideally one should not show off. But given choice between not helping vs helping AND showing off I would humbly chhose latter.
But I get ur point. May you continue to be a good Muslim and help others anonymously, Inshallah!
Re: Charity for publicity
I know what you mean,its same like someone is giving charity from haram Ki kamaii,they won't get reward for it but other person will get benefit ,
Depends on someones niyaat.we really can't judge someone,sometimes it's hard to judge our self,like why I did that? For me? For Allah SWT or for showing off?
Kin with 2z I guessed you would state that. Since you had quoted a verse in Hindi earlier stating same along with Khaan.
OK you may not get reward. But other person still benefits hai ki nahin? I agree ideally one should not show off. But given choice between not helping vs helping AND showing off I would humbly chhose latter.
But I get ur point. May you continue to be a good Muslim and help others anonymously, Inshallah!
Re: Charity for publicity
I know what you mean,its same like someone is giving charity from haram Ki kamaii,they won't get reward for it but other person will get benefit , Depends on someones niyaat.we really can't judge someone,sometimes it's hard to judge our self,like why I did that? For me? For Allah SWT or for showing off?
Well said. Self analysis is good. We all have doubts abt our real intentions.
Good night :)
Re: Charity for publicity
ji
Yeh tou kaafi Ziada light daal di hay
Re: Charity for publicity
Well said. Self analysis is good. We all have doubts abt our real intentions.
Good night :)
Yes but only some of us can recognize .
Good night :)
Re: Charity for publicity
Yeh tou kaafi Ziada light daal di hay
Ji