Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

Saw this interesting piece on Yahoo news on the change in progress in society in the tribal regions

PESHAWAR, Pakistan (AFP) - Zuhra Nafees drinks in the sights and sounds of Peshawar’s riotous marketplace with newfound enthusiasm. A year ago the grate of a burqa separated her from the outside world

Now the late twentysomething is clad only in the traditional Muslim chador, the long cloth that covers her body from head to toe but leaves her face completely unobscured.

“As our men are no longer stressing that we wear the burqa, so we have now abandoned it,” said Zuhra, who belongs to the Mohmand tribe and lives in the semi-lawless tribal areas in Pakistan’s North West Frontier Province.

Women in her family used to wear the so-called shuttlecock burqa, named for its resemblance to the cone of feathers used in badminton, “but now many wear the chador for covering their bodies in public places,” she said.

Burqa-wearing was common for centuries in the ultraconservative ethnic Pashtun heartland that straddles the border between Pakistan and Afghanistan (news - web sites).

It gained international notoriety when the fundamentalist Islamic Taliban came to power in Kabul in neghbouring Afghanistan. The Taliban punished women for not wearing the burqa and it became a symbol of religious intolerance and sexual oppression.

When the regime was toppled in late 2001 it was partly billed as a victory for Afghan women, who could finally cast off the restrictive garments and show their faces to the world.

Now with the spread of education and exposure to the media, observers have also detected a sharp decline in the numbers of Pakistanis choosing to wear it in the last few years.

“This area is experiencing great change in many Pashtun traditions and abandoning the traditional burqa is no exception,” said Shahida Parveen, a female journalist.

Young, educated women are at the forefront of the revolution, she said, backed by the relaxing of attitudes among male Pashtuns regarding purdah, or wearing the veil.

It reflects the gradual increase in professional and personal freedoms that women are winning in Pakistan’s tribal regions.

Saleswomen can now be seen in some large stores, while females have taken posts in banking, IT and businesses like carpets and gems.

In politics, a number of local government seats are reserved for women and a majority of those come from an alliance of strict Islamic parties. The provincial president of the largest Pashtun political party is also a woman.

The area is not giving up its strongly-held social and Islamic traditions without a fight. Older women in particular still remain hidden from view beneath burqas of many colours.

The practice has always been largely confined to the middle classes in Pashtun society, who consider it a mark of social status, according to Slama Shaheen, director of the Pashtun Academy at the University of Peshawar.

“Pashtuns were very simple and women in rural areas often worked alongside their men in fields so it was very difficult for them to wear the burqa,” she said.

Despite this, burqas are now more popular in the countryside than in towns and cities, as rural regions are less exposed to westernizing influences, says Shaheen.

“Due to education and the role of the media, a cultural change has been witnessed even among the conservative sections of Pashtuns,” she adds.

Few have seen the effect as much as the people who make and sell the all-enshrouding garments.

“The young girls do not wear the burqa anymore. They all prefer the chador,” says Salim Shah, who has sold the headgear for the last 15 years at the Kochi Bazaar in Peshawar.

He said Afghan refugees were his major customers as they remained more faithful to the old ways compared to people in Pakistan’s northwest.

Ironically the burqa’s last bastion is rapidly becoming Afghanistan, where it has lost some of its stigma as an instrument of Taliban repression.

It has regained currency “as a traditional rather than a religious form of veil,” said Yaqoob Sharafat, director of the Afghan Islamic Press news agency, which is based in Peshawar.

“In the past, women in the elite and religious families wore burqas as they were considered as a sign of pride and dignity.”

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

lol i dont get it. refusing to wear burqah is "progress" for muslim women? i know so many parday wali khawateen who are engineers, doctors, heck even engineers! what the women in all the tribal areas need is real education and health care. why dont these so called revolutionary women who are backing them up provide basic facilities first and than worry about who is wearing what. burqah or chadar should be a choice for women regardless of where they are living.

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

^ agree... liberation has got little to do with what a woman is wearing and more to do with education, knowledge and actual freedom....

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

^ you missed the point, in some of these areas women having the ability to make the choice between burqa or chaddor is a sign of progress.

again, not whether it is a burqa or a chaddor or something els, but the ability to make a choice.

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

^ i didnt read the article .. woops

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

I don't think as many women as the article would have you believe actually wore burka in NWFP anyway, certainly not in peshwar anyway.

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

Interesting. I believe that they should be free to make their choices.

I just hope they dont then shed the chador to prove that it (also) isnt some sort of a sign of oppression. I dont beleive that women's clothing should have anything to do with ideas about inequality or such. They should be free to make their choices in life...a chador or burka should not put them in the "oppressed womens" category.

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

Well I hail from the great and ancient Attock, Chach area in particular which is near the border with NWFP and not at all far from Peshawar, the women in our regions have never worn Burkha, some have tried the Afghan-shuttlecock and the Indian-two piece but the kids made a laughing stock out of them so they gave up.

The women belonging to proper landlord tribes, both Punjabi (Hindko dialect speaking) and Pukhtoon have always worn a chador but this is not this skimpy type of chador, these small type of chadors are usually worn by women who belong to non-tribal families, we call them Kubhaar, Musali, Chooray.

The Afghan Farsiban and Afghan Pukhtoon immigrant women in our village generally just wear their normal clothes but these are covering, look gypsyish but cool.

Women from the landlord tribes usually wear a chador which covers from head to toe and usually pull it over like ghoonghat if there’s men in the street.

Look at that, how beautifull is that? You feel love for them in your heart not in your pants.
[thumb=H]56y525548_4915564.JPG[/thumb]
[thumb=H]untitled25548_4915564.JPG[/thumb]

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

lol what can u see in that pic to get a feeling in ur pants??? both women look so ugly in that drape-all dress.. this is one of the worst exploitations in muslim societies.. if men cant control their urges why shud women suffer the heat in such tents?? i wud say tie ur **** with metal wire when u go out so that even if u see a naked woman u wont feel like an animal.. if modesty shud be stressed upon so much why dont men do the same?? why flaunt their talibanesque beards with AK in tow? why not cover their legs when they play a game of football?? why play in shorts?? wont women get feelings when they watch such things?? talk abt heights of MCPness…

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

[quote]
lol what can u see in that pic to get a feeling in ur pants???
[/quote]

good then it serves it's purpose.

[quote]
both women look so ugly in that drape-all dress..
[/quote]

Fine that's your opnion, I think they radiate a motherly/sisterly sort of aura.

In my village when Paki pukthun/punjabi boys play cricket or Afghan Farsiban/pukhtun play football (soccer) they do cover, general shalwar kamix or tracky pants not shorts.

Real men are jealous by nature, even the high caste Hindu Brahmin women use to wear this dress, it's only an outer covering, underneath amongst the family and women only, our women also dress nicely.

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

I guess I managed to be misunderstood. The “progress” that I was referring to can be found in the bold part below.

The progress is in the change of attitude from women being merely the property of their husbands and forced to wear what the husbands want, to them instead being allowed to choose what garment to wear to preserve their modesty.

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

very tangential sort of reply.. u still dont address my point: why shud women suffer in such mobile tandoor ovens if men cant control their urges or cant grow up?? how bout castrating such men?? wudnt that be a viable option too?? wud u ask ur neighbor to seal his money in a iron case and bury it just becos u feel tempted to steal it??

what a bizarre line of reasoning!!! muslim societies need to get out of the male-centric mindset first if real progress is to happen

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

hmm...

for purdah purposes burqah and chadar both serve the same purpose... (talking abt the really big chadar here that comes atleast uptil ur knees)

a lot of women wear a face veil with the chadar as well...

so modesty wise i dont think there is a tradeoff if the women are abandoning burqah for a proper chadar

waise i have seen many many women wear burqa/chadar even with niqab...even in the cities it has become really common...most girls from middle class who commute in public transport or walk in public etc i have seen wear burqa/chadar/niqab here...

i wear chadar myself if i'm out in crowded public places and i dont think it is suffocating or anything...if i'm alone and walking in public i feel a hundred times safer if my head is covered and i know the chadar is around me...its just a psychological thing i guess...

plus think abt it...u r walking down the street and there is some weirdo who intends to tease girls passing by...if u r wearing fitted clothes, heels, makeup with a trendy hairdo....versus...if u r wearing a chadar... for him it prolly doesn't matter and he would tease any female form he sees...but for myself i wouldnt want any weirdo on the street to see me dressed up id rather he sees me in a chaadar and doesn't know anything abt how i look..

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

chador is mainly a means to keep a girl within the hood…whether of religion or of family or tribe etc…thats its main purpose…i dont say it only, even the Quran says it…“so that u be recoginixzed from amongst the iman-walas/walis”…its not exploitation, but a privliege…but not everyone gets the point…:snooty:

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

huh if women think its fine to koi gal nahin… but remember that just becos u are stopping men from ogling u doesnt mean society gets ridden of such evils… in iran (where chador density is higher and prudishness is of the highest order), incest is on an all-time high (cf. www.persianliberals.tk).. now wud u like to be in such a situation or be ogled by some aira-ghaira nathulal on the streets???

Re: Chador replacing Burqa in NWFP tribal regions

Ranjhan, your an Attockwal too? I agree with that assesment. Attock is in between regarding this matter..Not as conservative as Sarhad but definately more so than Punjab.