There is a principle & that is “things are allowed and permitted unless there is evidence to the contrary.”
There is no evidence to say that a menstruating woman is not allowed to recite Qur’aan.
Shaykh al-Islaam Ibn Taymiyyah said: “There is no clear, saheeh text to indicate that a menstruating woman
is forbidden to recite the Qur’aan"
2ndly, if if the menstruating women were not allowed to read the Qur'aan, then wouldn’t we have tons of narrations from the wives of the Prophet sallAllaahu alayhi wasallam? They spent ages with the Qur'aan so they would have told us if we were supposed to keep away from the Qu'aan during this time.
Ok , so I have a question ... I normally read Quran from a website ... during the special days I carry on reading from my computer , coz I am not really touching the Quran .... as far as I am aware , there is no evidence stating that women cant even read Quran during the special days ..
I remember when I was younger and parents sent me to Islamic School to learn Quran , some of the bari baji's who couldnt take days off during special days , they would sit and carry on reading the quran , without touching it .... however the concept of not even reading it , I saw for the first time in Pakistan !
Khair the question is, do any dynamics change for us ladies if we read Quran using laptops rather then holding the actual Quran itself ...
as far as I am aware , there is no evidence stating that women cant even read Quran during the special days ..
.
Why do you think Namaz is not allowed during special days? Its because you have to read Quran in it (and mind it that you are doing it without touching, even then its not allowed).
For teaching purposes, its allowed but you have to teach it/repeat it - in small segments.
No TLK , I think its because namaz cant be done without wudoo … where as for actually reciting the Quran or reading it as zikr , doesnt need wudoo as a necessity …
I read a few things some time back .. Al-Bukhari records the following from Aisha,
“I was menstruating when I reached Makkah, so I neither performed the circumambulation of the Kaaba nor the going between mounts Safa and Marwa. I informed the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) about it and he said, 'Perform all the ceremonies of the Pilgrimage like the other pilgrims, but do not circumambulate the Kaabah until you become pure from your menses.”’
It is well-known that the pilgrims make remembrance of Allah (dhikr) and read the Quran while performing the pilgrimage. The Prophet (peace be upon him), it seems, did not object to Aisha doing any of those acts. In fact, he explicitly told her to perform all the acts that the pilgrims performed save the circumambulation of the Kaabah. This implies that it is permissible for the menstruating woman to do all of the other acts that are customary for the pilgrimage.
Why do you think Namaz is not allowed during special days? Its because you have to read Quran in it (and mind it that you are doing it without touching, even then its not allowed).
For teaching purposes, its allowed but you have to teach it/repeat it - in small segments.
where do you get this information from? Can I have sources from scholars please and evidence from Islam which states why a menstarating woman can't pray?? Somone can turn around at you and say no because you have to be in the state of wudu and you can't keep wudu in that state. We will never know what the reason is and its dangerous TLK for you to be giving these answers without any evidence.
where do you get this information from? Can I have sources from scholars please and evidence from Islam which states why a menstarating woman can't pray?? Somone can turn around at you and say no because you have to be in the state of wudu and you can't keep wudu in that state. We will never know what the reason is and its dangerous TLK for you to be giving these answers without any evidence.
Peace amzsonikuri,
Have you read these two books (1) The book of Menstruation (Kitab Al-Haid) of Sahih Muslim and (2) Menstrual Periods from Sahih Al Bukari. If yes than you'll find many hadiths about it where prays are forbidden during special days. However, touching/reading of Qur'an during these special days didn't mentioned directly and scholars i.e. Schools of Thoughts have different opinions.
In periods I think women need more protection since she is "naa-paak" The negative things i.e. Jinn Balas tend to get more attracted so I guess one is to read surahs for protection whenever they know they might get harmed so how can they not be allowed to read anything from the quran? Plus Na-paaki haatho mein toh nahi aati. You can wash your hands, take a bath even in period just like how you are supposed to do after your days are over so I dont see why there is a problem? - Maybe its for the women who are unhygenic and stay even more yukhy while they are on their period, I have heard a few girls dont take a shower etc so maybe they shouldn't touch the Quraan at all!
The reason namaz is forgiven is because wudhoo is a requirement for salah...which cannot be fulflled.
Peace Ma Mooli,
I disagree b'coz in case if water is not available, a person can do 'Tayyamum' to perform his/her 'Salah'.
In periods I think women need more protection since she is "naa-paak" The negative things i.e. Jinn Balas tend to get more attracted so I guess one is to read surahs for protection whenever they know they might get harmed so how can they not be allowed to read anything from the quran? Plus Na-paaki haatho mein toh nahi aati. You can wash your hands, take a bath even in period just like how you are supposed to do after your days are over so I dont see why there is a problem? - Maybe its for the women who are unhygenic and stay even more yukhy while they are on their period, I have heard a few girls dont take a shower etc so maybe they shouldn't touch the Quraan at all!