Can we comment on Islam and not pray?

In my view no…

What I mean is, you will see many people in everyday life that have an opinion about Islam…Islam should be this, Islam should be that, Madrassahs should be this, Masjids hould be that e.t.c, but don’t pray…They have definite opinions about Mullahs and moulvis, but don;t pray Salat…Do they have a right to speak about Islam, in my view absolutely not…In my opinion, these ‘mod-Muslims’ are all wind and no movement…

The reason I thought about writing this is because I used to live with these couple of roommates…During a friendly get-together with a couple of other friends, the topic turned to Islam, and my room mate who never prayed (Except Jumaah), was the loudest of those condemning the Mullahs, condemning this and wanting change in that…

After the gathering, as we and my roommates were sitting down, I told him flat to his face that he can’t comment on anything about Islam…He doesn’t deserve the right to comment if he doesn’t practice it himself…Needless to say, he was upset but I got my point across and he got the message (Hopefully for the better)…Now you decide whether I was wrong or right…

Salat or Namaz, as it is called in Pakistan, is the strictest, most unchallengable and unbending tenet of Islam…I believe if I am mistaken there are three conditions for not having to pray:

  1. You are insane
  2. You are in a coma
  3. You are dead…

If you don’t fulfill these three conditions, you must pray…Come hell or high water, you must pray…There are no ifs, ands or buts about it, you have to pray…If you can’t pray standing, pray sitting, if you can’t pray sitting, pray lying down, but by jove, you MUST pray…Islam is unmoving, irreconciliable and absolutely uncompromising about this tenet…You have to pray…If you call yourself a Muslim, your soul and spirit must touch the floor five times a day…

So how about someone, who fails to faithfully carry out this unquestionable tenet, have the right to speak about Islam? How can he have the gall to speak about bringing change to Islam? How can he preach Islam when he himself is not practicing it? How can a non-practicing Muslim be a Muslim? How can he give Dawah, or speak to non-Muslims about the beauty of Islam when the person himself is unhappy about prostrating before his Lord? How can he muster the strength to smile and preach Islam to non-Muslims when he doesn’t follow what Islam is uncompromising about?..It’s like shivering in the snow and saying it’s really good to be warm…

If he still does speak about changes in Islam, and calls other Muslims names like Mullahs and Moulvis on the basis of his own limited understanding, then in my view he is nothing more than a hypocrite…And it is people like these who are the most vocal critics of Islam, other Muslims and their behaviours…

It is said, that to be a good salesman, you must first fall in love with the product yourself…This way your love for the product itself will bring life to your sales pitch…Otherwise if you yourself don’t like the product, how do you expect to convince others of its beauty and usefulness? If you don’t practice this pillar Islam, what kind of a Muslim are you?

Salat or Namaz, is a test…It is ripping yourself away from whatever you are doing and standing before your Lord 5 times day…No one promised it would be an exhilirating experience, but it is what your Lord, your Allah commands you to do…Whether you do it with a heavy heart, you do it with a miserable heart or you do it with a joyous heart, do, you must…You must stand before your Lord 5 times a day, and there is no compromise about it…You will be called about your prayers…There will be no lawyers for you to fight your case…Allah :swt: has laid down the command and you are responsible for carrying it out…Failure to do so would have very painful consequences for a long time…No joke…Pain means no pain like ever exprerienced by any person on Earth…Don’t you take this as a joke…

Once you become you used to Salat, you won’t be happy without it…Salat is like a drug once you become addicted to it…You won’t be able to sleep unless you have your fix…

Someone told a couple of weeks ago, that during the time of the Prophet :saw:, the person who missed the Fajr prayer, his Namaz-e-Janaza was not performed…

In another instance it was a British Jew general who once said, that as long as Muslims have the strength to wake up every morning to pray their morning prayers, nothing can overcome them…

How hard it is to leave a warm and cozy bed and go to the Mosque to pray everyday, without fail…What a sacrifice the Muslim must make every morning to leave his bed and go to the Masjid…How strong of willpower and faith this exercise would make a person…

May Allah :swt: make us Muslims tread His path to the best of our abilities and may Allah :swt: guide us all…Ameen, Summa Ameen…

Re: Can we comment on Islam and not pray?

Assalam Aleekum

030.031
YUSUFALI: Turn ye back in repentance to Him, and fear Him: establish regular prayers, and be not ye among those who join gods with Allah,-
PICKTHAL: Turning unto Him (only); and be careful of your duty unto Him and establish worship, and be not of those who ascribe partners (unto Him);
SHAKIR: Turning to Him, and be careful of (your duty to) Him and keep up prayer and be not of the polytheists
31. (And remain always) turning in repentance to Him and have Taqwa of Him; and perform the Salah and be not of idolators.)

Be of those who single out Allah, devoting their worship sincerely for Him alone, not anyone or anything other than Him. Ibn Jarir recorded that Yazid bin Abi Maryam said: "Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, passed by Muadh bin Jabal and asked, What is the foundation of this Ummah' Muadh said, Three things, and they are the things that will bring salvation: Al-Ikhlas (doing a deed for Allah alone), which is the Fitrah with which Allah created mankind; Salah, which is the thing that tells a believer apart from a disbeliever; and obedience, which is protection.' Umar said: `You have spoken the truth.

Wrong, You don't even have to be a muslim to comment on Islam. There have been and are several scholars who have read and did extensive research on Islam and have all the right to comment on Islam.
Same goes for any other religion.
Consider this; how come muslims keep commenting on other religions like commenting on hinduism and christianity etc. Should they become staunch hindu or christian first.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by analyze it: *
Wrong, You don't even have to be a muslim to comment on Islam. There have been and are several scholars who have read and did extensive research on Islam and have all the right to comment on Islam.
Same goes for any other religion.
Conside this; how come muslims keep commenting on other religions like commenting on hinduism and christianity etc. Should they become staunch hindu or christian first.
[/QUOTE]

You can comment all you like...It's your prerogative...The comments I am referring to are critical comments...Name one Muslim scholar except Ahmed Deedat who does that...Even then Mr. Deedat only points out what is in the Bible itself, he doesn't criticise the Christian faith...

You should analyze things in what context they were said before you jump to conclusions Mr. Analysis...

Agreed LAjawab....good point

Lajawab

I see your point but i think anyone can comment on islam. Most of the comments on islam from non muslims and sometime muslims usually making fun of islam or calling anyone with sincere belief in islam a fanatic or mad mullah. This is nothing let them keep barking muhammad(saw) got called lot worse and was physically attacked for his belief too.

The person you gave as example who says islam should be changed then you need to argue on what basis is he calling for change, because it is most likly they don;t know what is islamic solution for that problem, because they not even living in an islamic state they cannot see how islam will solve that problem.

As for nimaz yes it is a fard but islam covers all aspect of life including dealing with people socially, economically, politically and the rest.

So islam as a whole will give solution praying on its own will not it is the basis or the foundation from where you build.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Madhanee: *
The way I understand Lajo’s post is that Mullahs should not issue Fatwas if they themselves have no experience with the act that is being Fatwad upon. Now there are about a Million Fatwas against drinking alcohol (or watching Movies), is Lajo implicating all the Mullas as drunkard jackasses who watch juicy movies all the time? I agree.
[/QUOTE]

that was a very wrong understanding....
and showed out the level of understanding u possess....

to issue a fatwa against comittign any act is not done by one involved in it, but one who abstains from it....

easy to say hard to do! many things!:)

,,,,,,,

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Madhanee: *

to issue a fatwa against comittign any act is not done by one involved in it, but one who abstains from it....<<<

Armughal, so you agree with me then, those abstaining from prayers can issue Fatwas about Islam. Thank you for agreeing with me. Jazakallah.
[/QUOTE]

Madhanee...It's true ignorance is bliss because the person afflicted with it seems to think he is all that, but to the onlooker he looks little more than a jackass rolling in his own dung...Read my post one more time...

For Muslims, Namaz is Fard...Meaning it HAS to be done...There can be no Fatwa about it as it is clearly stated...Drinking and decadence are Haraam, meaning they are NOT to be done as that too is clearly stated...

If you still have a problem with translating this, let me know...I can put it in simpler English...

Lajawab, my answer would be yes, we can comment on Islam even if we dont pray. I have a lot of reasons for this answer but in all honesty I dont want to list them, because then I'd have to write out this whole thing and these days I'm being laconic.

Lajawab

I see your intent of the question, and have to sa that let people comment.

if there is a connection between their lack of praying and the knowledge of what they are talking about then you can weigh their opinion less. but at the same time they may have some good points..and even if that is not the case, the fact that they feel that they can talk about these topics without being ridiculed, provides you an opportunity to correct them on their misconceptions or help educate them.

Just as a side note..if we apply the same to haqooq-al-ibad i.e. rights of the people, then majority of our political leaders would not be able to comment on religion as well since their groups (if not themselves) have violated the rights of others at one point or another..just something to think about :)

Just a rememberance of what I once wrote…May Allah :swt: give me strength, Ameen…

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by armughal: *

that was a very wrong understanding....
and showed out the level of understanding u possess....

to issue a fatwa against comittign any act is not done by one involved in it, but one who abstains from it....
[/QUOTE]

NO man on this planet can issue, this so called, Fatwa. Every human is free to choose and act the way he/she pleases as long as the action does not leave any nagative affect on other human beings. Man is free to criticise any religion or religious book and even God. If God wanted us NOT to question things, He wouldn't have created us with the ability to qestion.
No religion in this world is Perfect. there is enough room in every religion for critisim and every human is free to do that.

Mr. Lajawab,

You would get an award from Allah for offering all your prayers but dont take take your frustration about how come you "do it" but "they" dont by completely excluding them from their right of reforms.

But again I have seen people who criticise thing just for the sake of it and not actually DO something positive abt it. So, those people have little right to comment on any such thing.

AND I would like to tell you (either you like it or not) that you seem to be one of those people. I mean you seem to be criticising those who do not pray and seem to very conveniently declare that they have no right, whatsoever, to comment on anything Islamic instead of trying to help / advise them politely to offer their prayers. I must say you sound shallow!!!

People can make comments all they want. You can't stop that, nor should you try (zabaan tau nahi khench saktay na). What you can do, obviously, is to IGNORE comments/opinions of those whom you feel are unworthy. Baat khatam. Now smile :)

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Lajawab: *
It's true ignorance is bliss because the person afflicted with it seems to think he is all that, but to the onlooker he looks little more than a jackass rolling in his own dung...
[/QUOTE]

Here I agree with you cz that's what you make yourself look like by this thread of yours :)

[QUOTE]
For Muslims, Namaz is Fard...Meaning it HAS to be done...There can be no Fatwa about it as it is clearly stated...Drinking and decadence are Haraam, meaning they are NOT to be done as that too is clearly stated....
[/QUOTE]

Fard............. towards Allah. I HAS to be done for Allah!!! YOUR job is to politely advise those people to start offering that Fard. NOT to criticise them so rudely and declare that they have no right to do anything Islamic BECAUSE they do not pray.

so true :k:

about your post - I think people should be able to comment on Islam whether they pray or not because the people who do pray - you don’t know their true intent. Some people pray just to show off to others that they are praying.