[quote]
Originally posted by PakistaniAbroad:
Allah's Book is Complete. I am not one to take it lightly. Allah didn't reveal it to us to just discard it and go after Mullahs.
[/quote]
Brother, there is a very basic flaw in this statement. The Qur'an is undoubtedly our first source, and, if you know law, is the enactment. In order to follow the law, we are given rules of procedure which must be followed in order to meet the requirements of the law. The sunnah is precisely that.
When one does not understand the law, one has to resort to lawyers who are well-versed in law. The Ulema are the lawyers. Who you go to is a matter of choice. If you do not associate with them and try to understand everything, I sincerely believe you are doing yourself injustice.
Qur'an is not an easy thing to interpret. The difference between the four schools exist mainly due to differences of interpretation. And, there are some dissents within the schools on certain topics because of difference in interpretation.
Ignoring these facts is not correct thinking. It is certainly not freedom of mind; it is deception to oneself to even consider that one understands better than Rasool Allah (by ignoring sunnah), better than the sahaba (by discarding their narrations), better than the ulema (by discarding teh ijma and ijtehad).
My sincere advice to you is to sit down and think. Are you correct on the basis of arguments I have submitted?
**
[quote]
What's said in the Book is the FINAL word. NONE can change it. None can abrogate it. There can be no addition.
There can be no judge other than Allah. NO Mufti can give any fatwa unless it's in the Book.**
[/quote]
Agree with your statements totally. Nobody disputes that. The text was complete when Allah said today I have completed your deen. No abrogation or addition can take place and all fatawas are based on ijtehad which draws on the Qur'an as the first source of Islamic Jurisprudence. Sunnah is then he second source.
**
[quote]
On the Day of Judgement, Prophet will be a witness and what will Allah question us about? ONLY the Book. No Sunnah, No Hadith, No Ulema, No Fatwa. Just THE BOOK**
[/quote]
We will be questioned on the way we lived this life. Not on what you state. The way we live this life is according to instructions contained in the Qur'an and explained in the sunnah. Fatawa and ulema are means of interpretation. They are not original sources of text. I believe you are very confused here.
**
[quote]
The Book explains clearly everything and is a guidance and mercy? What part of Allah's verses do we not understand??**
[/quote]
There are countless ayat that have been interpreted or implemented by the sunnah. There is no way you can perform salat, perform hajj, pay zakat, etc., if you just rely on the Qur'an. These things have been pointed out to you in the past by brothers and sisters, but we keep coming back to square one.
Rabbeshrah lee sadree; wa yassirlee amree; yafqahoo qaulee.
[This message has been edited by FactFinder (edited December 05, 2001).]