Cairo to synchronise azaan

Cairo is to synchronise the call to prayer across the city’s 4,500 mosques using computers, putting an end to out of tune and out of time muezzin. This weekend, the government begins its project to synchronise the five daily calls to prayer to a central computerised feed.

“Our goals are to accurately set the time of prayer so that it is called at the same time from each mosque, and to control the quality of the voices,” said Sheikh Salem Abdel-Galil, an official behind the proposal.

It is proving unpopular with the muezzins – the human voices of the call – who fear losing their jobs, as well as traditionalists for whom the clashing sounds of the chants are part of the city’s charm.

Do you agree with this? Also, is it islamically ok to make the call of prayer through a computer? :S

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

We need that in Pakistan too, or at-least a computer to lower moazzan'a voice a bit.

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

There's nothing wrong with it, azaan is azaan. I'd prefer muazzins though..

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

^ Come to any mohalla of Pakistan and you will repent saying that.

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

Lol I know man. My aunt lives right next to a masjid. THAT got annoying.

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

My nani ma's house is right infront of a masjid and its only annoying on Fridays because they give all those long speeches for aaaages and u can't even hear anyone on the phone lol... But I prefer muazzins, no doubt about it...

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

There can be two azaans. One could be the synchronized one, as being suggested. And then second inside the mosque without loudspeakers.
Everybody should be ok with it. Traditionalists and modernists. Moazzins won't lose their jobs either.

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

bad bad bad idea
me don't like

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

Aren’t you and uncle ever disturbed by loud maulvis at Fajar time?

I guess you two are too old and are fast asleep so you don’t hear anything :hehe:

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

Scar, don't make assumptions :--p

well, as Muslims, i don't think it's nice if we say we're "disturbed" by Azan... i don't know, just sounds wrong...

i never felt disturbed by Azan, always loved the sound of Azan

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

Scarface isn't that the purpose of azaan? To wake us up? To call us to pray?

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

I'll prefer moaazan , but if they can use technology to achieve better results , then I won't mind that either .

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

If you don't take it as an offense, then I would say NO. This is not the purpose of Azaan.

The purpose of Azaan is only to let you know it's time for namaz.

As an example, see what happens in Saudia. I never heard azaan while I was in Saudi Arabia. People there believe if you have so many other ways to know the time for namaz, why would you want to hear azaan then? Azaan is given in Saudia, but only to fulfil the tradition and in a very low volume.
People there even used to laugh at the idea of loud azaan.

Again, no offense. I might be wrong.

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

Like adding sound effects? :D

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

^ Its azan , not Atif Aslam singing for you . :smack:

Let me tell you in much clearer words . . . beeta you can use technology to reduce noise in sound , enhance the voice quality and so on . Ayi samajh ma ?

Re: Cairo to synchronise azaan

This NEWS isnt any new:
One voice for Cairo’s call to prayer

As dawn breaks over the twin stone towers of Bab Zuwaila, the evocative Islamic call to prayer echoes across Cairo as it has since the massive, fortified gate was built in the 11th Century.
Back then, the muezzin would close his eyes, raise his voice to the heavens and sing out the Adhan, the ritual reminder made to all faithful Muslims five times a day.
From mosques a few streets away, the call would be repeated across the old walled city until hundreds of minarets were united in a mighty, man-made chorus.

Today, technology has taken over in the form of amplifiers, microphones and speakers.
All too often, the call to prayer is broadcast to a less-than-divine accompaniment of crackle, hiss and feedback.
A preparatory clearing of the throat, swilling of saliva or clicking of the jaw can be unblushingly transmitted at top volume.
Increasingly Cairenes complain that the call to prayer has become less a pleasant reminder than a raucous aural assault on the senses.
Now the government is poised to unify the Adhan by broadcasting the voice of a single muezzin five times a day to all of the capital’s 4,000 mosques.

Follow more on:

Although nice to discuss.

In UAE they have synchronized the Adhan for some Years. It can be a good thing BUT they should say it on Speakers rather than letting it only within Mosque area as it is specially for people who are outside of the Mosques.


Further more for those who say that it sometimes is not bearable or cant hear other person or etc, would they like this trend then, will they feel comfortable my having Adhan like a song?

**Istanbul’s tuneless muezzins get voice training **

It is meant to be a beautiful, melodic and spiritual start to the day.
But the morning calls to prayer by some of Istanbul’s muezzins and imams have had locals plugging their ears rather than reaching for their prayer books.
The problem is such that following a flood of complaints by locals, special classes for the tuneless culprits have been set up.
Imam Mehmet Tas, one of the school’s first pupils, said he was already feeling the benefits.
“I have so much more self-confidence now in my abilities to do all five calls to prayer in their correct tempos,” he said.

  The improvement scheme was put together by Mustafa Cagrici, the  city's head of religious affairs, who is determined to make sure all of  the city's 3,000 mosques produce a beautiful call-to-prayer each  morning. 

"For some reason, these imams were hired even though their voices are not good, they just can’t sing!

  "We're doing our best to help our imams and muezzins to improve their singing." 

He says that since lessons started, complaints have dropped from hundreds a month to just dozens, an improvement that can be credited to the singing teacher, Seyfettin Tomakin.
“I personally find a badly sung azan [call to prayer] very disturbing,” he said.
"The azan is music, beautiful music that brings people to God, that’s why it’s so important to sing it well.
“Sure, there are some people who find it harder than others, that’s why some come here for a year. But my job is to find their voice to enable them to sing.”
Sadly, for some, no amount of teaching will ever be enough.
“There are some people who can’t improve - no matter how much training you give them,” said Mr Cagrici.
“So we connect their mosque, by radio, to a central mosque where there’s an imam who can sing.”

Source:

BBC News - Istanbul's tuneless muezzins get voice training