Cadillac and Jaguar

Two cars I am currently considering are CTS from Cadillac and the new XF from Jag.

I fully understand both the historic reliability issues with Jags as well their uncertain future with Tata of India, but the car absolutely blows. I need some real good reasons not to consider it any more. Its fairly exclusive, and the supercharged 4.2L V8 gets 400+ hp with an interior that is simply stunning. Front exterior is a disappointment after the gorgeous C-XF Concept shown last year, but anyway…

Re: CTS, its a nice car and will be a change from the usual E-class or 5-series or Infinitis of the world. I think Cadillac has good reliability ratings too. Exterior styling is distinct and interior is pretty nice. Don’t like the way they price the darn thing with an options list that is longer than GS Forums list.

By the way, yes I know that fully loaded, price delta between these two is about $20k.

Both cars are ordinary in their mpg ratings, so that likely won’t be a factor. Plus there is no hurry as I probably can wait the whole summer to make the switch. If there is a comparable car coming in the near future, do share.

2009 Jaguar XF

Rear

Tail light

Interior

Shifter

2008 Cadillac CTS

Front:

Rear:

Interior

Shifter

Jags are a Nag…:frowning:

Cadi’s are like a sleek race horse…:slight_smile:

Hey gramps,

Havent driven the Jaguar, but the new Caddilac’s rear seats might be tight and uncomfortable depending on who’s sitting back there. Children might be ok with it, but adults will definately be uncomfortable. I found the trunk to be small too, but that might be because I was shoving luggage. Front seating/cockpit was exceptional compared to recent Caddys. I’m sure the techie in you will be happy.

Winding Road has a review of the two, back to back, in their current May issue: see it online.

if you are saying that it absolutely blows. Is that in itself not a good enough reason to not consider it?

Re: Cadillac and Jaguar

Why not go for the Merc CLS 55 or 63?
Also consider the CLK63/C63

Re: Cadillac and Jaguar

^ As a rule, I don't even consider 2 door coupes. Not practical for me. C-63 may be a tempting, but I am not too much into speed. Comfort and styling are more important. C-class is way too small, especially rear seats.

X2.... :D Dunno man, I have never been attracted towards Jags before, but this XF is pretty darn good looking. Aston at Jag price, methinks. Same design clues on the rear.

Re: Cadillac and Jaguar

Although, the way gas prices are going, I may just drop everything else, and quietly get an Altima Hybrid... Today, the premium here is at $4.39. It may cross five bucks sooner than we expect.

Re: Cadillac and Jaguar

*Jaguar all the way
*

The CLS55/63 are four door 'coupes'.. though they are categorized as saloons, still look like coupes.