Brelvi and Deobandi fiqh (Do we need them?)

[diwana]

@cricketplaya

Again we’re going in circles

Allah has said in Quran, go to the people of knowledge. I see no harm in going to the people of knowledge, Allah knows best for us. That is why it is advised, throughout history to have a teacher. For anything in this world, you need a teacher. You want to become a physicist, you can read all the books in this world and still not be able to grasp the knowledge. You need a teacher. That is why we have the 4 madhabs (in reality they are 1 since they all follow the 2 sources), now Prophet SAW is not here to tell us. Where do we go? Do we start reading and interpreting ourselves or do we go to the people of knowledge? Again, there is no harm in learning, all scholars throughout history have promoted learning but we should differentiate between learning and deriving rulings. The latter only leads people astray.

(Well, you answered here then as long as hareem has no problem, let me answer)

I think you are the one going in circle. My point of view has been very straightforward from the first post in this thread.

TLK asked the question above I think…And I asked the same after you posted the verse.

Who are those people of knowledge?

How will you ever decide who are those people of knowledge?

Obviously there has to be a reason for you to choose one or the other. So, based on what?

Can you answer the questions I post rather than making general statements?

Why would you follow just one imam or madhab made AFTER the time of the prophet SAW.

You still have to search on your own and that is what a better way to follow religion.

You again avoided the responsibility issue here. Aalim is not going to be responsible and will not be there if the questions will be asked…sorry no cheating or conference call will be allowed..