Brass Tacks - Clarification of Swat Deal

"Special Broadcast !!!

Clarifying misperception about Swat deal

Peace cannot be achieved through violence; it can only be attained through understanding. ~Ralph Waldo Emerson
A lot of uproar is going on in and outside Pakistan against the peace deal and promulgation of Nizam-e-Adal 2009 Regulations in Swat. Internationally, forces hostile to Pakistan are using this as surrender and back off by government where as at national level some commentators are declaring it ineptness of Pakistan army and intelligence agencies. Most of these uproars are result of misunderstanding and misconception about both peace deal of 16th Feb. and NAR-2009.
To understand facts only way out is to understand the peace deal and Nizam-e-Adal Regulations 2009 so that concerns expressed at national and international level can be addressed.

Below are 14 points which provide basis for the truce between TTP Swat and Government.

  1. Sharia law would be implemented in Swat and Malakand.
  2. Security forces will gradually withdraw from the region.
  3. The government and the Taliban would exchange prisoners.
  4. Militants would recognize the writ of the government and cooperate with security forces.
  5. Taliban would halt attacks on barber and music shops.
  6. Ban on display of weapons by militants in public.
  7. Taliban would lay down heavy weapons.
  8. Taliban would close down training camps.
  9. Taliban would denounce suicide attacks.
  10. A ban would be placed on raising private militias.
  11. Taliban will cooperate with the government to vaccinate children against diseases like polio.
  12. Fazlullah’s madrassa, the Imam Dheri would be turned into an Islamic university.
  13. Only licensed FM radio stations would be allowed to operate in the region.
  14. Taliban would allow women to “perform their duties at the workplace without any fear.”

As far as Nizam-e-Adal 2009 is concerned it is being portrayed as a cruel justice system that would be run by Taliban. This is real dilemma that no one in media in Pakistan is ready to take a good deep look at the Nizam Adal Regulation 2009 Draft and see who things will be implemented and who will be incharge.

More sadly, information department of government in Islamabad is not ready to reply to foreign apprehensions about these regulations. All these concerns and apprehensions are result of misunderstanding and lack of awareness due to inept information machinery of Pakistan. Private media is also playing a criminal role as it is not telling masses what Nizam-e-Adal Regulations 2009 is.

Many misconceptions are being spread to get vested interests served by both Local and international actors.

Main focus of this propaganda is to tell people that Nizam-e-Adal will transform Swat into Pre 9/11 Afghanistan as Qazis (Judges) will be appointed by Taliban only. Only way to address all these apprehensions is to spread the truth about Nizam-e-Adal 2009 Some excerpt from Draft is given below to clarify some misconceptions.

Definition of Shariah (Section 2 of Draft titled as “Definitions”)
(n) “Sharia’h”, means the injunctions of Islam as laid down in Quran Majeed and Sunnah-e-Nabavi (Sallallaho Alaihe Wasallam), Ijma and Qias.
Explanation.—In the application of this clause to the personal law of any

Muslim sect, the expression “Quran Majeed and Sunnah-e-Nabavi (Sallallaho alaihe wasallam)” shall mean the Quran Majeed and Sunnah-e-Nabavi (Sallallaho alaihe wasallam) as interpreted by that sect; and
Appointment of Qazi (Section 5, titled as “Courts,Judicial Officiers and their powers and functions”)

(1) Any person to be appointed as Illaqa Qazi shall be a person who is a duly appointed judicial officer in the North-West Frontier Province. Preference shall be given to those judicial officers who have completed Shariah course of four months duration from a recognized institution.

The misperception is being spread about appointment of qazis
(judges) under Nizam-e-Adl in Malakand.

The impression is being created by some vested elements that militants will appoint these judges whereas it is nothing of the sort.

All the Qazis (judges) would be appointed by government and not Sufi Muhammad or Fazlullah

The qazis will be appointed at tehsil and district level whereas they will be under district shariat appellate court i.e Peshawar High Court shariat bench.

The Peshawar High Court Shariat benches are already working through the province and there is nothing new in this case as well.

Then there will be Dar-ul-Qaza (final appellate court) i.e Federal shariat court bench a higher body that would be hearing the final appeals.

The Federal Shariat court benches are also already functional therefore it is neither a new idea nor outside government jurisdiction.

Dar-ul-Qaza (final appellate court) will be constituted by NWFP governor and the judges to all the Islamic courts will be appointed in consultation with the government besides there will be no compromise on their qualification as all the judges to be appointed will be highly qualified and would work within the rules and regulations

So it is clear from above two examples that Taliban will not be running this judicial system but a proper government supported and backed system with authority. Much of other misconceptions can be addressed once if Draft of NAR2009 made available on all kinds of media both inside and outside Pakistan.

Wassalam
Zaid Hamid"

Pakistan: Clarifying misperception about Swat deal Pak Alert Press

So why are seculars like Dawn and Geo and NGOs crying??? More dollars coming their way???

Re: Brass Tacks - Clarification of Swat Deal

[note] You need to read forum rules. Post link to the article ASAP. [/note]

Re: Brass Tacks - Clarification of Swat Deal

It seems like this “Hindu Zionist” needs to get out more and see what is happening on ground … This Nizam e Adal was part of the peace accord between TSNM and NWFP government … one party has been expressing their opinions …

Deadline to set up Darul Qaza in Malakand ends today - GEO.tv

He said Ulema would be the Qazis (judges) of the Darul Qaza and only they would have administrative control over the Malakand judiciary.

Earlier, Sufi Muhammad said those who called the Supreme Court and high courts “Sharai” were rebels against Islam.

Meanwhile

Buner courts closed - GEO.tv

PESHAWAR: Thousands of under trial cases goes into pending due to closure of courts in district Buner.

The courts have been shut down after April 23 deadline given by Tehrik Nifaz Shariat-e-Muhammadi (TNSM) chief Sufi Muhammad for the establishment of Darul Qaza and appointment of Qazi. The people of Bunar appealed the government to take immediate notice of the situation.

Re: Brass Tacks - Clarification of Swat Deal

What really amazes me about Zaid Hamid is his theories sometimes go overboard...but what he clarifies does look good. The reality on ground may truly be different... So why oppose something passed by the Parliament? Oppose whats on ground...

Parliament is a representative of the people... so why is everyone worried..?

Re: Brass Tacks - Clarification of Swat Deal

Because it was done as result of violence (part of nation was hostage?)

Re: Brass Tacks - Clarification of Swat Deal

Absolutilty spot on, Very good Zaid Hamid but please do your videos in English some western Pakistani don’t understand Urdu.

That’s the reason the west is so upset. Look what Britain have got for us…

BBC NEWS | World | South Asia | Can Sufi Islam counter the Taleban?

A solution to tackle Taliban. I guess they need an experiment in Britain first.

Re: Brass Tacks - Clarification of Swat Deal

If you really believe that Taliban would abide by all these sharaayit then good luck to you.

Re: Brass Tacks - Clarification of Swat Deal

No room for Westernised Ideology.

Re: Brass Tacks - Clarification of Swat Deal

Taliban have kept their word enough times, they dont need to tolerate anything anymore.

are you by any chance bitter_reality?

They kept their word when they invaded buner? When they kidnapped army and policemen or killed the others?

It is in fact part of jihadi ideology that it is ok to lie and kill in order to promote the cause. That is why one must assume that any jihadi supporters is lying from the onset until proven otherwise.