Bond between Allah and Banda.

[Theorist]

Re: Bond between Allah and Banda.

@psyah

Let’s unravel that post of yours to see if Sayyiduna Ali (AS) was correct:

Here you have confessed to being a doubter - Read the four points about doubt.

Expecting God to move to you instead of you trying to find God. c) Deviation from the truth.

a) Hankering after the whims - Theorist basically said she “didn’t want religion”

a) Absurd reason - This research of Islam if done inappropriately can lead to confusion and distrust of scripture.

Prime example of a) Absurd reason … Looking for a connection with God does not logically lead to everything being useless - and even if it is useless in the sense of emotionally/faith-wise useless - it does not make them false and it does not make them without wisdom that can help us in this life even if we had no faith.

This is more a) absurd reason - Religious accounts are a mixture of literal and metaphoric, exact and by analogy - even a religious person never takes all the words literally unless he/she knows they are meant as so. Then the human hierarchy argument is bad logic too … Islam for example says all humans are equal - it is ideas such as evolution that promotes hierarchy based on food chain, survival of the fittest …

a) absurd reason - This should be a separate topic … but the confusion being made here is of duty and responsibility being confused for rights.

a) absurd reason and c) deviation from the truth - Presumption made that God wants us to fight amongst ourselves when we are all His Creation. Well a dog and a cat are both His Creation too and yet they fight like cat and dog. No God does not want us to fight like cat and dog … this is not even true. Rather the premise for fight is often argumentation and we are told to avoid argumentation even.

d) dissension and c) hesitation -

Seriously? It seems absurd to you because you can’t possibly see it from my perspective. It makes perfect sense to me. You already have this preconceived notion that Islam is the ULTIMATE truth no matter what. I don’t. If you pursue something with a set mindset, your eyes and brain will only want to acknowledge what you are reading and understanding as the truth. Have you ever approached a scientific experiment with such a mindset? Don’t you begin as a doubter and the results of your experiment either prove or disprove your hypothesis?

Then tell me why can’t I have similar approach to religion? You said evolution can’t be proven, hence, creationism is the truth. Has creationism been tested? Can I say creationism can’t be proven, hence, evolution is the truth?

My point is we are both guilty of having a certain mindset - you can’t just blame me! The question is why you believe and I don’t.