blog in defence of complete Ahlebayt

[Abdullah786]

Re: blog in defence of complete Ahlebayt

@Das_Reich

Ummel Momineen Aisha could be mistaken too esp about taking the sadqah part? she has been wrong and corrected before by God in Quran and Prophet in hadith
Afterall wasnt Fatima wrong in her judgement ?
I would rather take the words of an old companion whose word is defended in the Quran ! and who is not reprimamded in the Quran

well if you read quran you will find that even prophet(Saw) made a wrong decision..

Anyways your comparision is pathetic. because hz zaid(ra) himself says in the narration that he had forgotten certain things due to old age..:I have forgotten some of the things which I remembered in connection with Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him)… Secondly hz ayesha(ra)'s verdict will be given preference because, she used to live along with prophet(Saw) so she experienced the shariah rulings and teachings better than other companions..

Secondly she was a teacher of many companions..

But the most important thing is that a person who resides with prophet(Saw) knows better rulings regarding their own family than outsider.. this is common sense, unless someone want to act in ignorant manner…And a person who lives along with prophet(Saw) knows better that what is forbidden for her and what is not forbidden for her instead of an outsider knowing that what is forbidden for her and what is not.