Re: blog in defence of complete Ahlebayt
what a fine way to degrage the mother of believers.. whose defence was dont in quran, whose virtues are countless… who used to be the teacher of many companions.. etc and whose narrations are taken to prove that ahle kisa are ahlebayt…
She said this but still see how pathetic people are to reject this narration from her: Here is that narration from Musannaf ibn abi shaybah (chapter Laa tahillu al-sadqa ala bani hashim)
ابن أبي مليكة أن خالد بن سعيد بعث إلى عائشة ببقرة من الصدقة فردتها وقالت إنا آل محمد صلى الله عليه وسلم لا تحل لنا الصدقة
Narrated with sahi sanad From Ibn Abu Malika [narrated] that: Khaled Ibn Saeed sent a cow from the Sadaqah to Aisha, so she sent it back and said: We are the Aal (the family) of Muhammad(saw) the sadaqah is not permissible for us.
And mind you we believe that companions can make mistakes, they were not infallible.. So yes hz zaid(ra) made a mistake giving his view but how on earth does this degrade the status of hz zaid(ra)… the claim is really sick..
Ummel Momineen Aisha could be mistaken too esp about taking the sadqah part? she has been wrong and corrected before by God in Quran and Prophet in hadith
Afterall wasnt Fatima wrong in her judgement ?
I would rather take the words of an old companion whose word is defended in the Quran ! and who is not reprimamded in the Quran