Blind Justice vs Logical Justice

We always hear the phrase that justice is blind, but that is not really the case, is it? If justice were to be blind, then no defense arguments would ever be needed in a court of law. If one person murdered another, then the punishment, based on blindness, would drop down like a guillotine on the murderer, regardless of why the person committed the murder…irrespective of whether it was self-defense, accidental, or to save one’s honor.

Currently, our supreme court seems to be bobbing back and forth between blind justice and logical justice, and they have unwittingly (or perhaps under certain political influence) made certain decisions that are oddly timed. The case against Gilani was decided on April 26th, and the SC should have mentioned this in their sentence, that if the defendant does not appeal, and allows this verdict to stand, he will be disqualified as MNA and PM. Instead, the SC allowed the appeal deadline to pass, without any mention of disqualification, and came up with their verdict only when the opposition filed another case against the Speaker’s reference, that ruled against disqualifying the PM.

This intentional delay puts a huge spotlight on the way the SC has maneuvered itself lately. The funny thing is, that the SC was pushing Gilani to write a letter against Zardari…and now, while Gilani [the petty thief] has been thrown out on a technicality, the main culprit, Zardari[the mega thief], still occupies the presidency. And whats more, the SC has asked the same mega thief to call for a new petty thief’s election. WTF?

I sincerely hope that the SC does not start the same drama with the new PM all over again, where they ask him to write to the Swiss courts. I suspect, that even if the SC does not start this drama, PML-N will, as this exercise is just meant to humiliate the PPP, a party that happens to have a very thick skin, with very little brain. PPP could have shut the SC up a long time ago, by simply writing a letter to the Swiss courts, who would have promptly denied prosecution on grounds that the President of any country has immunity. Instead, both sides decided to be stupidly stubborn, and now we are at a crossroads.

Gilani should have resigned after the April 26 judgement. The SC court must now keep itself from repeating the same cycle with the new PM, as we are just a maximum of 8 months away from general elections. Through this drama, noone seems to give a crap to what the public is going through, whether that is endless loadshedding, or skyrocketing prices.

PML-N could have stopped this drama a long time ago by resigning from the assembly and forcing general elections. Instead, all they did was throw punches in the air, since they wanted to keep their Punjab govt. These parties (PPP and PML-N) lack democracy within their own structure. I dont know how they can root for national democracy under such circumstances when they dont even allow a non-Bhutto or a non-Sharif to make it to the top.

Re: Blind Justice vs Logical Justice

Its not case of "Blind Justice vs Logical Justice", but case of SC driven by vendetta against PPP & its strings are pulled by the GHQ. The country is facing enormous problems & the SC is after petty cases...in process prolonging instability that country can ill afford.

Re: Blind Justice vs Logical Justice

We have seen less and less of the GHQ lately, and I dont think there is any love lost between GHQ and the judiciary anyway, so it is unlikely that the SC would act upon GHQ's instructions. PPP's demise was largely its own doing....however, the SC does seem to have a political tilt to its decisions, which is not the wisest thing to do.

Re: Blind Justice vs Logical Justice

^^^ Nothing that matter happens in Pakistan w/o nod or a wink from GHQ. That is why PTI/IK never criticize generals. Btw, I agree with the part that PPP has largely itself to blame, but I guess it is not easy to govern when your every decision is questioned by the court.

Re: Blind Justice vs Logical Justice

I so hope they do push it again. It would be great to see the current government rock on its heels for a few more months.

Re: Blind Justice vs Logical Justice

This is what I asked couple of time here that what happen if Gilani resign or disqualified and NEW PM refused to write letter to swiss authorities He refused and everyone knows that. So again court case same drama, these crows just waisted nation money/taxes time on so called case which bring nothing good. what is the postive gain of this judical act? The Op is right the actual criminal is still sitting in his office. The politicians we bring in our heads to chose them whatever majority want, These Boots and MIBs should remain in their terortires. Ye khamkawa ham pe muslat ho rahe hain.

Re: Blind Justice vs Logical Justice

One positive or perhaps not so positive point of this whole affair... sometimes its right to test the judicial and other gateways and if access to the peoples rights is denied or subverted then there is no other option.

If all other routes have been exhausted then you have all the right in the World for a Revolution for it becomes not an option but a neccssity.

Re: Blind Justice vs Logical Justice

This is where the buck stops.

The current attitude by 'biased SC' is PPP's own downfall.. RPP corruption, abysmal governance levels, blatant and shameless nepotism shown in key appointments all over the country.. NONE of it was SC's fault. So forgive the parhi likhi awam as well as tilted SC if they doubt every move by Zardari led PPP.

This coalition had a golden chance to change fortunes of this country. Friendly opposition, non-intrusive army, a reconciliation atmosphere, coalition partners willing to bend over.. .. but they blew this chance big time and resorted to corrupt practices of highest degree as if there is no tomorrow.

Even if SC is biased, they are biased for a reason.

Re: Blind Justice vs Logical Justice

Bhai saab, if PPP government had performed on economic fronts.. GHQ/Judiciary/Opposition would not threaten them the way they are now. This government is the most pathetic performer as far as the economic interest of our country are concerned.. mainly due to corruption of the people in power. These guys have looted the state dry.. have not installed any audit/accountability process to facilitate their loot. They take votes from the poor people to safe guard their livelihood/economic interest.. and these very people are suffering the most due to incompetency and corruption. Just to give you some highlights of the past 4 odd years:

1) Government is subsidizing gas to some 1,000 odd captive plant owners of large scale industry. This richest segment of our country is getting a direct subsidy of US 5.2 billion (488 billion rupees). The uninterrupted electricity to these captive power owners costs less than Rs 5/ per unit while a tailor running his shop is paying Rs. 15 for two hours of electricity he gets after 22 hours of load shedding..

2) Fertilizer factory owners are getting a subsidy of around 500 billion rupees in the form of cheap gas while the poor farmer is getting fertilizer at international import substitution prices. The owners of fertilizer factories are some of the richest people in Pakistan.. and rumors are some fertilizer factories had been paying up to 2 billion rupees per annum to the deposed Prime Minister Gillani.

3) State Enterprises are losing up to 400 billion rupees per annum. Just PIA losses have increased from 20 billion rupees per annum to 120 billion rupees per annum in past 4 years. Steel Mills, Railways and other State Enterprises are run by personal cronies have have looted them dry costing the tax payers a fortune.

4) Diesel which used to be subsidized and was selling for Rs 38/ per liter in 2007 (Cost was around Rs 45 in 2007) is now selling for 104 rupees including about Rs. 35/ tax per liter. Mind you diesel directly affects a common man as it is the main logistical cost for almost every consumable commodity and is the single largest input for agriculture today.. In the past 4 years majority of the subsidies have benefitted the top 1,000 people in the country which were paid by taxes from 180 million people.

5) While the country is suffering from un precedented power shortages up to 22 hours per day rendering millions as jobless.. the allocation of gas for power generation through IPPs (which was the highest declared priority of the present government) has come down from 47% to 27%. The same gas at dirt low prices is diverted to Captive/CNG/Fertilizer sector to make these rich people extra ordinary rich at the expense of a common tailor-small industrialist-work shop owner-carpenter etc etc who are the biggest employer in this country. It is estimated that appox. 5 million people have lost their jobs due to these engineered power shortages.

6) RPP scam has costed the country around 500 billion rupees. Presently we are taking less than 50 MWs of electricity from these RPPs at an average rate of Rs 70/ per unit from these IPPs..

I can continue this list with at least 50 points which are coming in my mind at this moment only. These few points are to illustrate how this government was anti people. The bottom line is a common person does not understand the nitty gritty of organized judicial system. They just understand that due to the mismanagement of the economy by this so called elected government.. their lives have become miserable.

They don't mind if GHQ or Judiciary helps them get rid of this "calamity" which has hit them in the name of "democracy".. I really wonder what would have happened to this unfortunate country if these people were given a freer license to loot..!!!

Re: Blind Justice vs Logical Justice

^ well said, the government should take a hint that no one has mourned Gillani's departure. The poor guy wanted to become a shaheed, but he couldnt become one.