Blasphemy, Islam and Pakistan

[Sa1eem]

Re: Blasphemy, Islam and Pakistan

@vroom

Salam Alaikum

The Prophet SallAllahu Alaihi wa Ahlihi wa Sallam took 3 approaches with regards to those who were disrespectful towards Him SallAllahu Alaihi wa Ahlihi wa Sallam

1. Forgave them
2. Gave the punishment of the Blasphemer, for the sake of Allah Subhanahu wa Ta’ala
3. Delayed the punishment

I do not know so much about other cases of Blasphemy, but one thing is clear. What you have written is actually incorrect

Islam was sent down in stages, many early commands were abrogated so not every ayah can be used as a legislative ayah. There is other ayahs that are not used for legislation. I will have a look at the ayahs you have posted but it will take time.

Do you know that you made statement that ‘what I wrote is incorrect’, when what I wrote is with reference from Quran, and that means, you are saying that what is written in Quran is incorrect. I understand that you are defending your denial of Quran by saying that some ayahs are abrogated. Regardless, even if any ayah is abrogated or not, a Muslim cannot say and should not say that what is written there is incorrect.

Anyhow, what ayahs I quoted, nothing in them is abrogated. Actually, I have not gone in details, but there are many things in Islamic history as well as in Quran that confirms what I wrote is correct.

Nevertheless, it is blasphemous and great sin that a Muslim would reject verses of Quran and that also just on personal whim.

You wrote:

The Prophet SallAllahu Alaihi wa Ahlihi wa Sallam took 3 approaches with regards to those who were disrespectful towards Him SallAllahu Alaihi wa Ahlihi wa Sallam

1. Forgave them
2. Gave the punishment of the Blasphemer, for the sake of Allah Subhanahu wa Ta’ala
3. Delayed the punishment

Above statement is blasphemous too and great sin to say that Prophet (SAW) used to discriminate in his approaches when giving justice to people. It does not suit a Prophet of Allah to discriminate in his approaches of giving justice, when dealing with people guilty of same crime, as that is considered as unjust.

Imagine, If I am judge and I have to deal with 3 people who has committed same crime, and I dealt with them differently.

To one I forgave.
To second I punished.
To third I delayed punishment.

Then who would call me or consider me just?

Do you know that there is hadith that says,Allah has destroyed people just because they used to discriminate when giving justice, punishing weak and forgiving strong and influential in their society.So, with that hadith, how can anyone accuse Prophet (SAW) that Prophet (SAW)used to treat people differently for same crime (blasphemy), discriminating when giving justice … forgive some, punish some, and delay punishment to some?

Fact is that, Prophet (SAW) always treated people who were guilty of blasphemy in same way, that is staying patient and ignoring them. If anyone says or think that Prophet (SAW) treated people guilty of blasphemy in different ways, than they are not only wrong, but are wrongly accusing Prophet (SAW) of being unjust (a it is unjust in to treat people guilty of same crime, differently). Such accusation is big sin and Muslim with such thinking should change their thinking.