I remember from my childhood about reading a lesson in our text books, where a lady used to throw stones or trash can't remember the exact at Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H whenever he used to pass by her house. One day Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H passed by her house and she didn't throw anything at him. Prophet Mohammad inquired about her and found out that she was sick. He then went for ayadat. She liked this gesture of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H so much that she accepted islam.
These were the teaching and sunnah of Prophet Mohammad. I don't know where does all these exterme punishments come from. Why didn't Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H ordered any punishment for her? Islam is not a religon that was spread at the point of sword.
The story is slightly different ... really she was throwing garbage on him to try and get a reaction from him (SAW). After a while she got tired and stopped throwing garbage on him (SAW) because her attempts of getting him angry were not successful. He stopped by her house to find out why she stopped, perhaps she had been taken ill. When he (SAW) told her this she realised that such a man with so much tolerance and love for people who show him intolerance must be good and true to his cause, seeing in him (SAW) signs of prophethood, she accepted Islam.
Leave those who claim that they are knowledgeable (Ulemas);...
yeah right, listen to you, lolz...
whole islamic world has had ijma'a on this issue of blasphemy for centuries, that punishment of this, is only death... and here we have new 21st century aalim who knows every thing better than the whole islamic world.
the issue is not punishment, the issue is definition of blasphemy, and how the law is implement and the assurance that it doesn't get misused
whole islamic world has had ijma'a on this issue of blasphemy for centuries, that punishment of this, is only death... and here we have new 21st century aalim who knows every thing better than the whole islamic world.
the issue is not punishment, the issue is definition of blasphemy, and how the law is implement and the assurance that it doesn't get misused
I quoted Quran and life of Prophet (SAW) and you are refuting that by saying that according to you ... ‘ijma’ believe something different.
Even though you are wrong regarding believe of Ijma (and I can prove that), but let say you were telling truth ... still, to refute what I wrote, you cannot quote ‘ijma’ because if there is something in Quran there is no place for Ijma, plus (that is in addition) if something can be proven by Sunnah, there is no place for ijma (if you do not believe what I wrote referring that as Sunnah and want to, I can give prove of Sunnah events too).
So, to refute what I wrote, you have to prove that Quran I quoted above is incorrect. Further, claim that what I wrote regarding Prophet (SAW) practice (Sunnah) is untrue.
If not then reply to my next question, and that is: If you are Muslim than what is so hard for you to accept what is there in Quran and follow something of Sunnah that is indisputed?
when, something is not clear by quran or hadeeth, then the obvious thing is to see how sahaba have dealt with that particular situation.
Excuse me. Quran does not mention anything about following sahaba. It asks to follow the prophet.
Besides, sahaba used to quarrel and argue a lot among themselves. Actually two of them fought each other and caused thousands of other sahabas to be killed (Ali and Muawiyah).
Things are not as simple as you would like to believe.
Khoji stop talking bu;****** about sahabas after prophets they are the most honourable people ever walked on the face of the earth and by the way Death of blashmey is in proved by the Quran and in life of PROPHET SAW many blashmers were killed so it 200 % clear by sunnah
Texan in Madina many blashmers were killed and in Fatah e Makkah only 4 people were killed 2 of them were for blashmey and you know where they were trying to hide when they were killed in the back of the GALAF (Cloth) around Kaba that is only day when killing in city of Makkah was allowed
**urdu meN kahaavat hai k "bhaiNs ke aage been bajaave, bhaiNs khaRii paguraaye" ... matlab ... "apni apni Daphli, apnaa apnaa raag"
ham ko deen kaa ilm nahiiN hotaa aur ham baHs karne baiTh jaate haiN...dunyaavii 'ilm ke liye to ham barsoN lagaate haiN to bhi kisi ek mauzoo' par hii guftugu farmaa sakte haiN magar jab deen kaa masla khaRaa hotaa hai to bhale hii ham ne ek saal bhii deen kii ta'leem na Haasil kii ho magar bolte aise haiN jaise PhD kar rakkhii ho...isii liye to kahte haiN k:
neem Hakeem Khatra e jaan
yaa
neem mullaa Khatra e iimaan
wallaho 'aalam bissawaab. Allah ham sab ko deen kii ta'leem aur uskii fahm o zakaa 'ataa farmaaye...aameen**
first Death for blashmery is in the Quran it says that jo koi bhi ALLAH aur us kay rasool SAW ko aiza (hurts it can be through any means) ALLAH aur us kay Rasool SAW ki lanat hoo un pay and after some ayats it says aur jin logo pay ALLAH ki lanat hay jahan milay un ko pakar lia jay aur qatal kar dia jay. aur Haan agar koi cheez suunat say sabit hoo that also the part of ISlam completely aur Hazrat MUHAMMAD SAW ki zindagi may kafi gustakho ko qatal kia gaya hay aur khalil Molvio ko jahil kehnay say pehlay khud apna ilm daikh loo kahi khud hi jahilo kay baap na sabit hoo jana
In his own life The Holy Prophet(PBUH) preach forgiveness and he forgive all enemies at Fatah Makkah. These r the peoplr convicted of blashmey, bust prophet forgive them
first Death for blashmery is in the Quran it says that jo koi bhi ALLAH aur us kay rasool SAW ko aiza (hurts it can be through any means) ALLAH aur us kay Rasool SAW ki lanat hoo un pay and after some ayats it says aur jin logo pay ALLAH ki lanat hay jahan milay un ko pakar lia jay aur qatal kar dia jay. aur Haan agar koi cheez suunat say sabit hoo that also the part of ISlam completely aur Hazrat MUHAMMAD SAW ki zindagi may kafi gustakho ko qatal kia gaya hay aur khalil Molvio ko jahil kehnay say pehlay khud apna ilm daikh loo kahi khud hi jahilo kay baap na sabit hoo jana
baar baary ek hi baat ... oh bhai Surah aur Ayat number to bata do.
1)If we read the quran, it is against oppression, suppression and persecuation. This shows that freedom for thought and expression is the stance of islam.
2)The quran contains hundreds of verses wherein are criticised beliefs and people who hold them and do wrong on that basis.
This is another point that proves that freedom of thought and expression is real islam.
3)If we read the quran allah expresses his severe anger against those who take other gods beside allah and also against those who take jesus as son of god yet he does not order his messenger to go ahead and kill them.
4)Allah order muslims to proptect places of worship of nonmuslims, why do that if they are supposed to be killed because they blasphem against allah 22/40?
5)Allah tells us clearly that jews abused his prophets and even killed them yet he does not tell his messenger to go ahead and finish them off.
6)The prophet himself is abused and insulted on various occasions yet he forgave the people.
All these very strong evidences tell us mawlanas are absolutely wrong to say that blasphemy law is islamic.
Blashmery