Birds of Peace met with Bombs

This just sort of blows me away. Thailand has had some horrible incidents over the past few weeks, but the gesture of flying over Muslim areas with birds of peace is an inspiring thing. Obviously the government is trying to calm feelings, and I cannot think of a more telling gesture to send a signal to that the governement wants to defuse hostilities. Can you imagine Israel doing the same? The response has been more violence however.

Origami peace gesture met with violence in Thailand

Airdrop of paper ‘birds of peace’ is followed by bombings, shootings, and arson attacks.

By Matthew Clark | csmonitor.com

A creative peace offering has been met with renewed violence in the troubled south of Thailand.
Hours after 50 Thai army planes dropped some 100 million Japanese-style origami cranes over the predominantly Muslim region Sunday, suspected Muslim militants shot dead a former prosecutor in Pattani province, reports The BBC.

On Monday morning four Thai troops were wounded when a bomb was detonated remotely by a mobile phone at a rest-stop for patrolling soldiers in Narathiwat province, reports The Associated Press. Hours later, writes AP, another bomb exploded nearby seriously injuring an assistant district chief as he parked his car.

BBC reports that the paper bird drop was arranged to coincide with the 77th birthday of Thailand’s king.

…ordinary Thais across the country wrote messages on paper birds they had folded.
As the birds fell to their targets in the provinces of Narathiwat, Yala, and Pattani, school children rushed out to collect them and seek the notes inside. Some students constructed giant nets stretched across school yards to capture the paper cranes.

One bird folded and signed by Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra offered a scholarship if found by a child, or a job for an adult. The cranes could also be exchanged for food as The Bangkok Post reports.
Twenty cranes can be exchanged for one egg, 50 cranes for 1kg of sugar or rice. All cranes collected would be given to authorities who will boil them and mix with lime to build a monument to peace.
Thaksin said the effort had achieved an “enormous, positive psychological effect” toward peace, reports AP.
But southern leaders have criticized it as a gimmick, according to the BBC.

Critics said the campaign … would not solve the complex problems that have caused the violence in the south, where more than 500 people have been killed this year. …
Our correspondent says the Muslim majority in the south appeared bemused by the idea of the aerial onslaught of paper cranes. But, while reluctant to reject any goodwill, they said a political solution would have more meaning.

On October 25, more than 80 Muslims died after security forces broke up a protest at Tak Bai in Narathiwat province. Most died of suffocation or were crushed in army trucks, which prompted fresh criticism of the Thai military’s heavy-handedness and sparked increased violence.

The Bangkok Post reports that “relatives of those killed in the Tak Bai tragedy have belittled the release of millions of paper cranes, saying it won’t make their loved ones come back to life or end unrest in the deep South.”

“Other critics, including political columnists and Muslim officials, described the scheme as an insult because residents would be forced to pick up tons of garbage after the air drops,” reports The Asia Times Online.

Another worry was that some birds may contain offensive messages, reports the Times.

The millions of paper birds collected made it impossible to check if any had offensive messages written on them that would “add more fuel to the fire” if read by Muslims on the ground, warned Niran Pithakwatchara, chairman of the Senate committee on social development and human security.
This warning may have come true, according to Agence France-Presse
…some southerners reportedly discovered a series of ugly messages that some fellow Thais had written on the birds. Mae-eya Bula, a 15-year-old in Narathiwat, told the Bangkok Post she collected a paper bird that said “I want to kill militants”.
Other residents found birds with messages including “Stop killing Thai people” and “All bandits must die,” the daily added.

http://www.csmonitor.com/2004/1206/dailyUpdate.html

Where were the Thai birds of peace when Thailand's army was assaulting the Sultanate of Pattani in the 19th century?

Thailand created a war when they attacked the Sultanate of Pattani, they used raw force of arms to subdue and annex it. There has always been resistance in the former Sultanate against the status imposed on it through force of forms, and the bomb today is simply the latest manifestation.

Peace works only to Thailand's advantage, because peace will not restore the complete sovereignty to Pattani that the Thai people stole from it.

It has taken over 100 years, but Pattani's people are finally gaining the strength to restore their own sovereignty and restore their nation.

Just as Thailand used force to steal the independence of Pattani, it is only just and fair that force shall be used to restore the independence of Pattani!

I pray for them to have victory in their struggle to reclaim their freedom, their sovereignty, their independence from those who stole it.

On a slightly more coherent note, the status quo throughout the Third world of the mid-20th century was nothing other than what had been created through the legacy of colonialism.

Through force of arms, Muslim peoples long rules by their own kind found themselves defeated by foreign peoples, with different languages, cultures and religion to their own.

The status quo was inadvertantly created with the subjugation of many Muslim people, too weak politically and military at the time to do anything about it. These peoples very often ended up disadvantaged in their own lands.

The reason for much of the conflict in the world today is the struggle by those Muslims peoples to switch back to the situation before the status quo was established, to the position when they were not in a position of such weakness.

Examples:

1) Palestine - colonial legacy through the establishment of Israel in UK-administered Palestine. The local arabs suddenly found a powerful Jewish state dropped on their heads on lands where no Jewish state and relatively few Jews had lived for over a thousand years.

2) Thailand - Thai armies surpressed a sovereign Muslim country and annexed it when it was weak. 130 years later, the inhabitants of that land believe they have been treated unfairly by Thailand and want their land to quickly cede from Thailand. Modern guerilla urban warfare provides the tools for a militarily strongly diadvantaged force to apply significant pressure on the occupying military - pressure that was impossible until the past few decades.

3) Phillipines - Spain conquered and annexed a Muslim island nation, Mindanao, through force of arms. The locals resisted, tried to restore sovereignty. The USA took over the Phillipines, the locals resisted the USA and tried to restore sovereignty. Today, the Muslims are still trying to restore the soveriegnty taken from them.

4) Chechnya - Muslim province that was seized by Russia and forcefully annexed into the Russian federation. Local Muslims trying to forcefully cede from Russian federation.

5) Nigeria (mark my words, the next trouble spot) - British colonial authorities forcibly annex and merge Muslim and Animist (later Christian) states - it's asking for trouble.


A status quo in the world has been forcibly imposed, that left many Muslim people severely disadvantaged, and much of the conflict in the world today is the people trying to restore what was taken away.

It's like if you have a set of weighing scales. Push down one side, and there will be a force acting trying to push that side back up. The side that was pushed down was the Muslim world, crushed during its economic decline of 1700 onwards. The world is now seeing the reaction to that crushing in the past.

The status quo is always acceptable to all but those who are left disadvantaged.