Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

I guess this is the first time he wrote an article for any Pakistani newspaper!

To the world, she was an icon. To me, she was my mother. On the fourth anniversary of that dark day, indelible in the history of Pakistan, when our greatest leader and our best hope was ripped from our lives and our future, I am flooded with emotion. She accomplished so much, but I am most focused on what she might have accomplished had she lived. Like a Pakistan that the Quaid-i-Azam could have lived longer to shape, like the dream she never lived to write, we can never know what might have been.

**What we do know is that there are 86,000 more schools because of Shaheed Benazir Bhutto. That, under her government foreign investment quadrupled; energy production doubled; exports boomed. Under her government, 100,000 female health workers fanned out across the country, bringing health care, nutrition, pre and postnatal care, to millions of our poorest citizens. It was under her government that women were admitted as judges to the nation’s courts, that women’s police departments were established to help women who suffered from domestic violence and a women’s bank was established to give micro loans to women to start small businesses. It was under Shaheed Benazir Bhutto’s leadership that cell phones, fibre optics and international media were introduced, and the Pakistani software industry blossomed. And it was on her very first day as prime minister, that all political prisoners were freed, unions legalised and the press uncensored. It was an amazing record of accomplishment, made even more remarkable by the constraint of aborted tenures, by constant pressure from a hostile establishment and presidents with the power to sack elected governments.
She never had a free and fair election. She was always under siege. She would say: “We were in government but not in power.” Yet she delivered so much.

And we can only dream of what might have been had she lived. One thing I am certain of — three-quarters of a billion Muslim women all around the world would have felt empowered, would have rejected limits on their opportunity to learn, to earn, to grow and to lead. Almost two billion Muslims around the world would have seen a modern face of Islam belying the caricature of our great religion in the West and the demagoguery of the jihadists within our own ranks.
**
**Modern, moderate, tolerant, pluralistic and, above all, democratic Islam, would have had not just a face, but a voice, a true leader not afraid to challenge dictators, oppressors, bigots or terrorists. That is what we lost on December 27, 2007. That day the country was on fire. It was ready to rip apart at the seams. With my father’s slogan, “Pakistan Khappay”, Pakistan was saved from certain disintegration.
With the slogan, “Democracy is the best revenge”, we chose my mother’s vision of peaceful resolution over violent retribution. We could have demanded a revolution. However, my mother taught me to believe in evolution, not revolution. When she landed in Lahore in 1986, the millions of people who greeted her could have been ordered to storm the dictator’s palace and take Pakistan back by force.

**Yet the PPP has always been careful to distinguish between the army as an institution and the dictator who abuses his position. We have always believed in a strong military under the control of an elected government. Similarly, following the judicial murder of my grandfather, we chose to condemn the verdict and those behind it, but never ransacked the Supreme Court.

We have always supported an independent judiciary and would never let the abuses of individual judges in the past sabotage our mission of establishing a free, impartial and independent judiciary. This is why we knew in 2007 that we had to distinguish between Musharraf and the army as an institution. A strong military is needed in order to protect our territorial borders and defeat the internal cancer of Islamist extremism. The politicisation of this institution under dictatorship engages it in arenas where it has no place and, as a result, weakens its ability to perform its primary function.

Today, we stand by the same principles: in reconciliation and not violent revolution. The evolution of a transition to democracy has already borne fruit. Under the military dictatorship, when our brave soldiers were martyred by terrorists, they were buried in secrecy in the dead of night. It is only once the elected government gave ownership to the fight against extremists and made it Pakistan’s war that we can bury our soldiers with honour and proudly announce their martyrdom for their country. It is only under a democratic government that Pakistan finally stood up to demand respect from the United States and to do what the dictator with all his military might could not — evacuate the Shamsi airbase. We have onerous challenges before us, but to face those, we need to secure our foundation. The democratic government, through the National Finance Commission Award and Eighteenth Amendment, gives the smaller provinces a stake in their country and a stake in their own resources, which under dictatorship were exploited by the centre, creating resentment against the federation. Yet even this is not enough. The push for economic and energy reform must go forward, as must our promise to build a Pakistan where education is the path to empowerment.

Had we chosen the path of revolution over evolution on that fateful December 27, both the army and the Peoples Party would have been weakened. That would have left the only other armed group, the terrorists, with the opportunity to exploit the situation and seize control of our country. We must remain committed to the evolution of a democratic Pakistan and reject the calls for confrontation between institutions. My mother died fighting for a Peaceful, Prosperous and Progressive Pakistan. **I will never give up on my mother’s Pakistan. I will never give up on the woman who sacrificed herself so Pakistan could be free. Her dreams are now my dreams — that is my promise to you; that is my promise to her.
**

living his entire life outside Pakistan I dont think he can actually relate or feel the pain of a common Pakistani
though,its nice to hear those words from him …I hope he actually does follows his mothers footsteps and tries to make a difference in the society!
I do believe, had she been alive, perhaps our state wouldnt have been in sucha horrible situation
she was certainly not incompetent and a coward like Zardari and Gilani! …

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

Thank you for posting.
Shaheed Benazir Bhutto was a pride of Pakistan but I will love to see Billawal away from politics .
He is not safe here .
We don't find any leader safe here if he is not from ........

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

...

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

I would like to know the references to the numbers he claims.

No wonder PPP formed govt 3 times :wink:

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

I agree with Captain1, it would be great if we could get some facts and figures on:

**1) What we do know is that there are 86,000 more schools because of Shaheed Benazir Bhutto. {How was this figure reached and many were ghost schools out of this figure?}

  1. That, under her government foreign investment quadrupled {reference?}

  2. energy production doubled ( I’ll agree to this although I dont support use of IPP’s for the purpose)

  3. exports boomed (Need proof for this)

  4. Under her government, 100,000 female health workers fanned out across the country, bringing health care, nutrition, pre and postnatal care, to millions of our poorest citizens. (Agreed to most of this)

reading Bilawal’s article it seems that Pakistan had become an ideal state/economic hub under Benazir’s regime, although people should have been shying from investment owing to Mr 10% and the reversals of policies that Nawaz Sharif and Benazir undertook in those 10 years.

**

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

Benazir’s economic successes (if anyone has any proof of the economy doing better in BB’s time please post that):

Economic issues

Benazir was an economist by profession. Therefore during her terms, Benazir Bhutto had no Minister to lead the Ministry of Treasury. Benazir Bhutto herself appointed as Treasure Minister, taking the charge of economic and financial affairs on her hand. Benazir sought to improve the country’s economy which was declining as the time was passing.[69] Benazir disagreed with her father’s nationalization and socialist economics.[69] Soon after the collapse of Soviet Union, Benazir attempted to privatize major industries that were nationalized in 1970s.[69] However, Benazir and Ghulam Ishaq Khan soon suffered a currency crises when the government failed to arrest the 30% fall in the value of the Pakistan Rupee from Rs. 21 to Rs. 30 to currency compare and contrast to US$.[69] Soon economic progress became her top priority but her investment and industrialization programs faced major setbacks due to conceptions formed by investors based upon her People’s Party nationalization program in 1970s.[69] By the 1990s, Khan and Benazir Bhutto’s government had also ultimately lost the currency war with the Indian currency and Indian Rupee beat the value of Pakistan rupee for the first time in 1970s.[69] Benazir Bhutto’s denationalization program also suffered from many political setbacks, as many of her government members were either directly or indirectly involved with the government corruption in major government-owned industries, and her appointed government members allegedly sabotaged her efforts to privatized the industries.[69]

**Overall, the living standard for people in Pakistan declined as inflation and unemployment grew at an exponential rate particularly as UN sanctions began to bite .[69] During her first and second term, the difference between rich and poor visibly increased and the middle class in particular were the ones who suffered from the major economic inequality.[69] According to a calculation completed by the Federal Bureau of Statistics, the rich were statistically were improved and the poor were declined in terms of living standards.[69] Benazir attributed this economic inequality to be a result of ongoing and continuous illegal Bengali immigration.[69] Benazir Bhutto ordered a crackdown on and deportation of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants.[70] Her action strained and created tensions in Bangladesh–Pakistan relations, with Khaleda Zia, who was in power in Dhaka during the time. **He refused to accept the deportees and reportedly sent two planeloads back to Pakistan. Religious parties also criticized Bhutto and dubbed the crackdown as anti-Islamic.[70]

This operation backlashed and had devastating effects on Pakistan’s economy.[70] Ghulam Ishaq Khan who saw this as a major economic failure despite Khan’s permission was required by Benazir Bhutto for the approval of her economic policies.[69] Khan blamed Benazir for this extensive economic slowdown and her policy that failed to stop the illegal immigration.[69] Khan attributed Benazir Bhutto’s government members corruption in government-owned industries as the major sink hole in Pakistan’s economy that failed to compete with neighboring India’s economy.[69]

This is the article highlighting the time when Nawaz Sharif took over from Benazir in 1996. If her time period was of such economic success this wouldn’t have been the situation:

**By the 1996, the national economy has came under the intense situation and deadlock, and a economic failure was soon near.[25]](Nawaz Sharif - Wikipedia) The continuous and large-scale of government corruption made by either Benazir Bhutto and her appointed government ministers had deteriorated the country’s economy at the extreme level.
**](Nawaz Sharif - Wikipedia)

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

Awesome , I like the way he wrote this piece that only a jackass will read it and believe it too :jhanda:

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

Frankly this sounds more like a political manifesto than an "ode to my mom". Whoever told him to write this drivel was a bloody idiot. This is all political and does not speak to his mother's death and her memory. Frankly if it were me i would have focused more on the emotional and personality than on facts and figures. What it reads like is like someone wants to prove his mom was great. Instead of acknowledging it.

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

yeah right and pigs use to fly!!!

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

So you dont want him in politics because you worry his safety and NOT because he doesnt understand politics or plight of Pakistani people who would be supposed to be working for (if he ever got to an important political position)

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

Looks like someone wrote for him.
While he was out about having fun.

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

Agreed to CM. Bilawal Zardari lacks emotions for his mom. Nothing new in this article. We've heard many better versions of this from Faisal Raza Abidi :)

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

agreed

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

YOU THINK?

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.


why would living outside pakistan prevent him from feeling the pain of a common pakistani?

in fact, as an outsider he is probably more aware of and disturbed by the common man's suffering than the typical middle class pakistani or politician who is generally desensitized.

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

He's never disturbed for people of Pakistan. If he was disturbed, he should have spent on flood affected people atleast 1% - 2 % of his treasury his father and forefather's have collected for him. Bhutto family got what is the real destination of human beings (a few yards at Gadhi Khuda Bux), but they still not learned the lesson which even uneducated W-11 driver knows well i.e. Qabar main tijori nahin hoti aur kafan main jaib nahin hoti (Everyone has to left all the properties in this world).

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

ummmm... hired the same guy who writes for Zardari? The writing style is the same :P

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

PUNJAB

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

You must be speaking for yourselves only. Oh, and I disagree with Shaheed part, too, but I agree that dynastical politics must end if Pakistan is ever going to become a functioning state. Therefore, Billawal should stay away for his own good & for good of the country.

Re: Bilawal article on BB fourth death anniversary.

That is true. He would probably be more disturbed living outside of Pakistan than our politicians, middle-class, or army officers. It is very hard getting used to the scenes of poverty when you live out of the country. The politicians, the army officers, the middle class dont feel the shame living their comfortable lifestyles and rubbing it in the face of the poor.