Re: Bid^a - (Innovation) 2 types, Good and Evil As Scholars stated.
Asalaamu Alaikum
Brother Ahmad G! where hav u been? iv been waitin along time for u.
Alhamdullilah u r now here.
in response to your message. i can tell you that Mawlid is not a good bidah i hav sed many tiomes there is NO such thing as a GOOD bidah! The Prophet(saw) said " every innovation is misguidance" so where do the good 1s come frm?
also innovations r in the field of worship since when r the letters or dots in the Qur'aan becoming acts of worship.
i suggest u read the seerah of The Prophet(saw) because when you do u will see that the Prophet(saw) himself prayed the Taraweeh in a group. so how can sumthin the Prophet(saw) did become an innovation?
you say that imaam as shafi(rh) spoke to abt good bidah. could you please prvide references as i believe u hav intepreted what he said wrongly. jus like you intepreted the so called "whoever starts of a good bidah" hadith. i will ask you nicely to write out the full hadith n the context cos u r misleading people.
i will b awaiting you reply. i also challenge you to an open discussion on the issue of bidah, "wahhabism", Ibn taymiyyah, Athropomorphism and others! i hav read many of yr threads and SUBHAN-ALLAH you have accused many of kufr!