Re: Bida’a…
Sheraz, we’re sort of jumping into a debate between barailvi sunnies (Ahmad G i believe) and deobandi/salafies…shia abhi tak zadd main nahi aye, why jinx a good thing ![]()
Jaan Leva thank you for your civil reply. I disagree with you about whether the question of whether one “worshipping” graves takes a Muslim out of the fold of Islam. That is a very serious allegation and you should know about the many sahih ahadith about how those who cast fatwas of kufr should be careful, one states to the extent that in doing so atleast one of the two is a Kafir. Whether one is merely visiting a grave through potentially misguided ideas of intercession or actually regarding it worthy of worship is a matter of what they believe, and you cannot claim to know what they believe better than them. Given that their stated niyat is not to worship a grave, they are not attributing partners to Allah and are at worst misguided, not Kafirs.
fg :k: . Lajawab I await your response.