Bhutto's party guilty of 'blatant fraud', claims niece Fatima Bhutto

Could this be true? Or is she just upset that PPP won?


Larkhana, 18 Feb. (AKI) - By Josephine McKenna - The party of assassinated opposition leader Benazir Bhutto, the Pakistan People’s Party, was guilty of widespread election fraud and vote-rigging, according to her estranged niece, Fatima Bhutto.

In an exclusive interview with Adnkronos International (AKI) from Larkhana in Sindh province, Bhutto said she and her supporters had spent 12 hours travelling across the province on Monday and had seen “blatant fraud” by the PPP in the parliamentary elections.

“It is quite overwhelming,” Bhutto told AKI. “What we have witnessed on the ground has been a complete fraud.”

Bhutto claimed some voters had used fake identification cards, duplicate cards and illegal cards with no photos to cast their ballots.

She said some voter lists were incomplete and there were also allegations of intimidation by polling agents who favoured the PPP.

Bhutto, a journalist and author, is not aligned with a political party but supports the breakaway party founded by her mother, Ghinwa Bhutto, the widow of Murtaza, Benazir’s brother. Murtaza was killed in a police shoot-out in Karachi in 1996, when Benazir was prime minister.

Fatima Bhutto said on Monday she had received more than 50 complaints from people who claimed to have witnessed voting irregularities in Sindh province, considered a stronghold for Bhutto’s PPP, now led by her widower, Asif Ali Zardari.

“I witnessed rigging with my own eyes,” Bhutto told AKI. “They were allowing people, who were not registered, to vote.”

Pakistani election officials said at least 14 people were killed and nearly 100 injured in violent incidents during the election which reportedly recorded a low voter turnout.

While polling has ended the results of the ballot for a new national assembly and four provincial assemblies was not clear late on Monday.

Bhutto said independent election observers had absolutely no impact on the election and she would be talking to lawyers about filing an official complaint with Pakistan’s electoral commission.

“I have been part of four election campaigns since 1993, and I have never seen anything like this,” Bhutto said.

She said it was too early to determine the election outcome.

Although President Pervez Musharraf was not contesting the election, it was widely seen as a referendum on his eight years in power and expected to determine his political future.

The election commission said turnout was about 15 percent early on Monday.

http://www.adnkronos.com/AKI/English/Politics/?id=1.0.1888860808

Re: Bhutto’s party guilty of ‘blatant fraud’, claims niece

Sounds quite paradoxical. Her very much hon’ble mother was so monitoring the election process. And who can rig under supervision of such a huge lady as she is :blush:
On a serious note, i believe its a cry over the spilt milk.

Re: Bhutto's party guilty of 'blatant fraud', claims niece

There is no denying that small time vote rigging happens all the time in all elections in all third world countries (even developed countries, I presume). Someone will always have instances of people who voted without proper identification, voter lists not being complete etc etc.

These random "vote riggings" do not make elections as fraud. The victory margin for most PPP victories in interior Sindh was in multiple thousands of votes. In many cases, they were many times higher than the votes obtained by their closest competitor. If the elections were close, then yes, even a few bogus votes could make a difference. But what Fatima Bhutto is claiming is interior Sindh. Ok, so a few people who were not on the list, and who did not had ID card, cast their votes - big deal! Would it change the results of the elections? Most likely, no. These small instances will have no impact on the eventual result. All candidates do these kinds of dirty tricks. Some more some less. Lets not be naive about it.

Elections are done and over. Move on to the next step. In some ways, elections were the easy part, forming the government and then tackling some of the vexing issues facing our nation are much harder tasks.

Re: Bhutto's party guilty of 'blatant fraud', claims niece

Yes, that's what I think too. I really don't think rigging was done at such a high level that PPP won by such big margins in so many different places.

Re: Bhutto's party guilty of 'blatant fraud', claims niece

i think she just wanted ghanva bhutto to win that's it

Re: Bhutto's party guilty of 'blatant fraud', claims niece

I guess on larger scale elections were fair (atleast on polling stations monitored by media/foreign-observers). From Dawn.com, a quick glance of difference in registered voters from 2002 to 2008 was quite high. In many constituencies the number of registered voters jumped to addtional 50%, I can't see how the numbers went so high in just 6 years.

Re: Bhutto's party guilty of 'blatant fraud', claims niece

I expect more from Fatima.