Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

Hmm! Bharati Punditos are learning fast from Pak’s MAToos from across the border. Hindu goddesses are beautiful so it is possible for an old chap like Snil to get aroused by the her. Isn’t it the definition / role of goddess anyway (to “take control” of men)?

This is simply nutz. Bharati court system is equally responsible. The court should have thrown this case out to begin with.


Trial of poet for ‘defiling idol’
By Subir Bhaumik
BBC News, Calcutta

An Indian court has ordered a leading Bengali poet to stand trial on charges of defiling a Hindu goddess.

The court in India’s West Bengal state was ruling on a lawsuit filed against Sunil Gangopadhyay by an ex-policeman.

In an article in Bengal’s biggest newspaper this year, Mr Gangopadhyay was quoted as saying he was “sexually aroused” by an idol of Saraswati.

Retired policeman Bhibhuti Bhusan Nandy filed a lawsuit saying the comments had hurt his religious sentiments.

Additional chief judicial magistrate in Calcutta’s Alipore court, Manjit Singh, ordered Mr Gangopadhyay to appear in court on 3 December.

The court also ordered legal proceedings against three others - Aveek Kumar Sarkar, editor of the Anandabazar Patrika newspaper, its publisher Bijit Kumar Basu, and chief executive Subir Mitra.

‘Zealots’

Mr Gangopadhyay, 71, was quoted in Anandabazar as saying he had kissed an idol of Saraswati, the Hindu goddess of learning, to satisfy his desire.

Mr Nandy, who has retired as the chief of the paramilitary Indo-Tibetan Border Police, filed a formal complaint with the police against the author.

“I am delighted the court has started appropriate legal proceedings,” Mr Nandy said.

Mr Gangopadhyay told the BBC on Monday that he was not taking the case seriously.

“Some religious zealots are playing this up - mine was a light-hearted remark on Goddess Saraswati. Her idol did not evoke devotion in me when I was young. I found her very attractive and that is what I said,” said Mr Gangopadhyay.

“In Bengal, Hindus are known to crack jokes at the expense of their gods and goddesses and that’s what I did,” he said.

“I have done no wrong but the zealots are trying to attack me because I am so critical of them. I am not afraid of them - as a writer I have the freedom to say such things and I and my publisher will fight it out in court.”

Controversy Mr Gangopadhyay is West Bengal’s best known living poet and novelist with more than 250 books to his name.

But he is no stranger to controversy.

Two years ago, there were protests outside a newspaper office in Calcutta after he wrote about the sex life of Indian spiritual leader, Ramakrishna Paramhansa.

He also described Kali, the Hindu goddess of power, as a “tribal whore”, triggering protests by Santhal tribes people and Hindus.

Last year, the Bangladesh government banned an issue of an Indian magazine which carried a story by Mr Gangopadhyay in which he wrote about the sex life of the Prophet Mohammad.
Story from BBC NEWS:

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

antibol you are taking your anti-india stance too far. What kind of a pervert is a person who goes a kisses a statue and goes to town harping on it. Religion is an extremely emotive issue and it is time that these people understood that it is better not to play with fire.

antibol do you really think before posting these articles. If some slanderer used bad language about the prophet (pbuh) wouldnt you be the first person to scream.

With freedom of speech comes a responsibility to not hurt the religious sentiments of people.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

Another non ssense thread. I think he wants Hindus to issue a Fatwa against this 71 year old sexually disturbed as per la Islamic style.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for ‘defiling a Hindu goddess’

This is what MAToos babble and scream. Religion is “emotive-uncontrolled-locomotive”. My foot!

What kind of? The kind who loves goddesses and their statues. Only nut cases would defend Bharati court system and this $stupid guy who filed the case. The court should have thrown out this case in 30 seconds.

Down with Bharati Punditos-MAToos! The killers of 2000+ Gujarat minorities.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for ‘defiling a Hindu goddess’

agree

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for ‘defiling a Hindu goddess’

Yeap! The same MAToo fever has swept through Bharat. There was no need to drag a 71 years old artist through Bharati court system.

O Punditos MAToos, Hindu godesses were considered to be sexy. There is nothing wrong with what the old artist said. Wake up and smell the hateful $hite of Bharati cows.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

Yes, now it is well seen that some people are very conscious for degrading Gupshup forums.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

^^huh! Running out of answers now? There is no need to put these one liner Bharati musings. If you want to say something say it aloud. GS is free. Call a Bharati pundito what he is: another MAToo.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

Idiot......the court system can call a person who is insulting anything related to any religion in India...(and I think the same law exists in many countries), but no Hindu will issue a Fatwa as per your La Islamic style.

Do you want to discuss if your threads are non sense???

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for ‘defiling a Hindu goddess’

You may not call it a fatwa when a 71 years old is being dragged through Bharati court system. If it smells like a fatwa, talks like a fatwa, attacks people in the name of religion like a fatwa,

then baboo! It is a fatwa (in this case issued by Bharati Punditoo instead of a MAToo). It is the same $hite.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

it might seem strange to a pakistani, but filing a complaint in a court system is the civilized way of resolving dispute. :)

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

^^We in Pakistan know very well what filing a trashy paper (what you call a complaint) in court means. We are struggling to repeal blasphemy law and fighting the MAToos. It is sad that Bharat and Bharati Punditoos are quickly becoming MAToos. There was no reason to honor that complaint. The judge should have thrown out that piece of crap MAToo Punditoo.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

maybe that would be the way it works in pakistan. but in india, we like to follow legal channels. :) now loosen that suicide belt and go milk your majj.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for ‘defiling a Hindu goddess’

Crucifying an old artist is bad, but the defenders of Bharati Punditoos are worse. As these bumble bees are nothing but pipsqueaks trying to hush up the matter.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

where is he crucified? it is a lawsuit, hello. why are you so upset aunty?

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for ‘defiling a Hindu goddess’

Queer, he is not upset, he is an idiot.

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for 'defiling a Hindu goddess'

//Crucifying an old artist is bad, but the defenders of Bharati Punditoos are worse.//

Crucifying an old artist who has gone bonkers and has no qualms in trying to get publicity is the worst possible method is not bad...

anti can you please answer my question...
"If some slanderer used bad language about the prophet (pbuh) wouldnt you be the first person to scream. "

Here in India we dont stone that idiot we just filed a case against him....

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for ‘defiling a Hindu goddess’

La Ilahi…Salman Rashdie…poor guy, living incognito for last 27 years???

Re: Bharati Pundits go nuts: Trial of poet for ‘defiling a Hindu goddess’

If only others living incognito can find a wife like Padma Lakshmi :slight_smile: