AJ, you don’t have to surrender NIC when you apply for NICOP, you just have to send the copy of NIC with the application. Oh and if you don’t have a valid pakistani passport, you can just send the copy of your US passport. The instruction on the actual form are accurate and updated.
I just got my NICOP, it took them almost 3 months. It kind of looks like ghista pita version of green card…lol…(ok, from pakistani perspective it isn’t too bad)…anyway it is good for 10 years, so for 10 years you don’t have worry about getting visa or renewing your paki passport…and all this in $15.00…