Being Too Easily Trusting - where do you draw lines?

No matter how hard I try not to do this I think I have a habit of trusting people too easily and assuming they won’t do bad to me or that they are ‘good at heart’. Allah ka shukar hae my trust has never been betrayed in anything big, though there have been some small unexpected incidents which I did learn from.

When such things happen, then too I think, okay this doesn’t mean the other person is just EVIL. I seem to have become more accepting of people who do bad deeds, which to me is highly highly alarming. I’m honestly scared about this as this means my own judgement of right and wrong has become messed up.

Like recently I gave my cell phone number to the laborer working at our house because the land line was unavailable and when I was giving it it didn’t even cross my mind [Yes it really did not!] that the person is going to distribute it among his coworkers and I’m going to get prank calls from them! But this did happen and I’ve certainly learnt my lesson from it.

In the beginning I was really angry but as time passed I just thought, OK this is really retarded but maybe they are just a bunch of adolescents doing this for ‘fun’? Its certainly not acceptable but I feel like I shouldn’t judge them too harshly?

But then where DO you draw the line? Is a murderer, a thief, a person who dishonors, what about the serial killer in Lahore who killed all those innocent children…aren’t these BAD people…? aren’t they EVIL?

I can’t even believe I’m asking this, but shouldn’t I be telling myself YES they are BAD EVIL people…?

My reaction used to be ‘Oh my God, s(he) did THIS? They are BAD!’ Now my reaction is, ‘Oh my God, s(he) did THIS? They are BAD! No wait, how can I judge if they are bad or not? How do I know what’s in their heart?’

Why do I find myself looking for excuses to justify their behavior? Should I just not accept that these are BAD.

Why can’t I accept that there are indeed BAD HELL-BOUND * people in this world…? I mean even in the Prophet (saw)'s time there were BAD EVIL people. And Allah swt has mentioned in the Quran that there are bad people. Subhanallah maybe I am one of them, who knows.

Is a movie actress who has a corrupt personal life, corrupt according to the definition of the standards I’ve been raised by, not a BAD person? Then why am I trying to justify her actions thinking OH but maybe she has good intentions maybe she is not a bad person at heart and I can’t judge?

Everything does not go. There ARE good deeds and bad deeds and I should look at those to base my judgements about people. Should I not?

Meeting all sorts of people plus this whole western line of thinking, ‘acceptance’, ‘tolerance’, ‘diversity’, ‘dont judge’ blah blah blah has messed up my thinking I think.

I seem to be justifying everything and everyone in my brain, telling myself, okay maybe that person had a reason, I shouldn’t JUDGE anyone.

Heck!!!

At some point, based on a person’s actions, don’t you HAVE to step back and judge them and say, This person is BAD. I am not going to have anything to do with this person.

I’m sure I have faults which others can look at too and say, Irem does THIS so I’m not going to keep in touch with her. But we all have to judge for ourselves do we not? How else do we protect ourselves?

When someone does something that harms you, shouldn’t you be smart enough to KNOW they MEANT to harm you, if they did, rather than think, OH I am doubting their intention which is bad…?

If someone cheated me, stole from me, isn’t forgiving them beghairti? But then isn’t Islam about forgiving?

Sometimes I even start thinking maybe that something happenned to me was my own fault, maybe the other person’s INTENTION wasnt bad?

Isn’t this messed up?

I wish I could go back to how I used to think at age 16, when I wasn’t exposed to the whole fuzzy philosophy of ‘don’t judge’, ‘don’t doubt someone’s intention’, ’ a person who does action X which is bad is not necessarily a bad person’…

sigh*

Your struggle with yourself goes on. I begin by saying we are no one to judge others in so far brandishing is concerned...means dont say this yes I know she is bad and I cant believe otherwise..as in that case u are really sitting in judgement which is forbidden..remember what Hazrat Ibraheem was told when he refused to share his food with a munkar!
You judge when u are in a position to do so, for example if u are in judiciary...I dont know which job u are into but your job requires carrying out some responsbilities for which u have to judge and if u dont u are irresponsible so when u are asked to opine if one can give out one's mobile number to a worker, just refuse it as u have had the experience.

Telling you a mysterious happening....Madam Noor Jahan passed away in the month of Ramzan and on 27th Roza!

Damn we mortals.

Thanks for your reply bro...

I should pick up the Quraan Paak and read that when I feel like this rather than post on GS...

Your point about Noor Jahan...I was thinking the same thing when I heard that too! subhanallah

remember what Hazrat Ibraheem was told when he refused to
share his food with a munkar!

nope, not aware of this unfortunately...please share....?

no matter how much we keep telling us that we shouldt judge others but we still do .....like myself...i always tell myself n try not to judge ppl but indeed i always end up judging ppl in good or bad way ...
instead of judging n talking abt others we should mind own busniess n if we keep this in mind that everyone is differnt n accepet them as they are than maybe this world will be peacfull n wonderfull place *sigh....

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by irem: *
Thanks for your reply bro...

I should pick up the Quraan Paak and read that when I feel like this rather than post on GS...

Your point about Noor Jahan...I was thinking the same thing when I heard that too! subhanallah

remember what Hazrat Ibraheem was told when he refused to
share his food with a munkar!

nope, not aware of this unfortunately...please share....?
[/QUOTE]

Hazrat Ibraheem (RA) kabhee bhee akele khaana naheen khaate thay...he used to share his food with travellers, passers by or hungry. Once he was waiting for any such person while he was feeling the pangs of hunger.....after so much waiting he found someone aur usko bulaya ke aao mere saath khana khao..woh banda aya..Hazrat Ibraheem (RA) ne usay kaha ke Bismilaah kar ke khana shuroo karo to us ne kaha ke naheen mein to Bismillah naheen karoonga cuz I am not believer in Him....The prophet got annoyed ke yeh kia hai, tum Bismillah karo aur khana khao..magar woh datta raha....tang aake Hazrat Ibraheem (RA) ne usay kaha ke acha theek hai jao agar tum ne Bismillah naheen karnee to theek hai....that person left without eating.
When that person left, Allah mian sent a message to the prophet through Jibraeel ke yeh aap ne kia kia? Jawab diya ke Ya Allah woh aap ka naam tak naheen le raha tha to mein kia karta? Allah mian said ke, "Aye Ibraheem, kia mein naheen jaanta hoon ke yeh shakhs mujh par eemaan naheen rakhta to kia mein ne kabhee uskee rozee tang kee jo aap ne usko bookha jaane diya?"

Thats releveant to the discussion we are having here irem. Hope it conveys something purposeful.

awww thanx for sharing :k:…

wow

jazakallah

SANDLEEN :hug:

May Allah bless you irem and sandleen :flower1:

judge them by their actions, be close only to those who you have known for a long time and have a good track record with you :k:

unless they have islam or sincerity in their hearts then trust them :flower1:

A lil kid was told not to play with fire. The kid kept at it till one day, he got burned. He learned a lesson and judged whats good for him and whats not. Same way all of life is as such, not that much different :)

I have the opposite issue I cant trust people *grin. I have always walked atleast 4 ft away from people. Yeah i will be the most talkative person they would come and talk to me about their life etc but i never trusted them.. There are very very few people i do :~).

Irem- before you get hurt really bad stop doing that. Share them with either your mother or one person who has been honest with you :~).

hey guys...

thanks for ur replies :-)

weekends suck...got nothing better to do than think abt all this stuff...

i love gupshup, there's always someone to say something nice to you...you guys rock :)

Irem .. i've been doing that for agez.. i guess m begining to understand a wee bit now... :-) .... i still dont judge people.. like if i meet sumone people ask how do i like that person.. i still cant tell them if he seems like a good man or not... its just not in my nature to judge any one. ...

all you can do is trust ur heart.

Aleezay baj thanks for the reply :) trust ur heart? is dil ne hi to aaj mujhay barbaad kar rakha hae...i think a person should never listen to their heart.

U kno irem .. sumtimes its hard to actually find any logic in heart matters.. but u kno wut?!? atleast u wont hav a guilt of not going the way u want… its hard to kill ur own khuwahish n do wut is logical… aur abhi to u r young.. everyone learns from their own mistakes… n if u wont mistakes how in the world u’ll find out stuff about life…!!! wesay bhi its boring if u hav aperfect life… its good to hav bumps n bounces on ur way :wink: … n its even better if u r able to get urself together for the new challenge .. that is how life is… n dont worry about making mistakes… everyone does… sum hav them in open.. n sum hav deep dark secrets .. u r no differnt… dont get offended by trivial things… they r just small things that can make u learn valuable lessons of life … stay happy larki … :flower1:

:slight_smile: will do inshallah :flower1:

:flower2::slight_smile:

My dad always says dont be gullible, dont be cynical but be sceptical.
being careful of people doesnt mean your judging them, your just being careful of any mishaps n thats it..

iv had my trust broken majorly 3 times. and i mean not little things but life changing things...
i am so wary now.. almost paranoid.. its a shame we cant trust everyone.. but people who are trusting (like me) we judge people by our own standards..