NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Friday issued a fresh notice to a convent school in Madhya Pradesh on a Muslim student’s right to sport a beard.
**A Bench of Justices B N Agrawal and G S Singhvi termed as “ridiculous” the school’s decision to remove the student, Mohd Salim, after he refused to shave his beard on religious grounds.
**](Beard row: SC finds student's removal 'ridiculous' | India News - Times of India)
The apex court notice to Nirmala Convent High School, Madhya Pradesh comes after another Bench recused itself from hearing the matter.
The earlier Bench of Justices R V Raveendran and Markandey Katju had initially dismissed the student’s plea.
**However, Justice Katju at that time made certain controversial observations that the country cannot be Talibanised by insistence on sporting a beard. **
Justice Katju, subsequently in a review petition filed by the student, tendered an apology and recalled the dismissal order, and recommended that the matter be posted for a fresh hearing.
The matter was thus posted before another Bench, which while issuing notice to the school, directed that the student shall be allowed to pursue his studies further until the matter is decided.
....
i think now secularism is turning into extremism............
Nothing to worry about.
FYI. Secular societies do not enforce beard law in general public.
However private schools have every right to enforce policies related to the uniforms, facial appearance and the display of tattoos and other symbols be them religious or not.
Again and again and again
I am really surprised that
time after time after time people who are guilty of
Pakistan bashing and posting messages only to malign Pakistan.
No other objective to give Pakistan a bad name
why is that tolerated??????????? i ask you Pakistani-Forum-Moderators??
I can imagine when someone is critical of Pakistan (even i am most of the time critical of Pakistan and the government of Pakistan) but when someone (specially Indian Nationalist)
are maligning Pakistan on this forum I really feel sad.
They not only malign or INSULT Pakistan it they make fun and laugh about it how this can be tolerated.
Please just tell me how this is possible.???!!!!
I am sure the moderators of this group are not blind and they can see what is being written
continuesly and time after time by some of the memebers. U cannot be ignorant of the fact that they sole purpose is to send negative post on this forum. Just check it please just read it.
Only few people who are Hindu Nationalist are dumping Anti Pakistani and Anti Islam messages on this Pakistani forum, well at least i thought it is Pakistani forum if i am wrong please tell me that at least then i know where i stand.
Just read they post that they are dumping here nothing but Pakistan hatred.
no punjabee its not that
nothing to do with india
anything that is anti pakistani
does not and should not belong on this forum.
to criticise pakistan and its policies i do not mind but only to go after Pakistan and do nothing else and only talk negative about Pakistan this should not be tolerated wether u are indian or TURK
Its you who is paranoid because you have nothing else to say then talk negative about Pakistani on Pakistani forum. Is that all you do and think of? my goodness you must have misserable life i pity you.
Oye genius ! First read what is being discussed before jumping into pass judgement. This thread talks about India. So if at all, this thread is anti-India not anti-Pak.
Go to WA and see how many threads started by Pakistanis are anti-India. Makes you wonder if Pakistanis have anything else to do besides India bashing.
you seem to forget dude this is Pakistani forum not INDIAN forum.
U really think on indian forum they would tolerate the nonsense you are sending there if it was against india? dream on!!
Again and again and again
I am really surprised that
time after time after time people who are guilty of
Pakistan bashing and posting messages only to malign Pakistan.
No other objective to give Pakistan a bad name
why is that tolerated??????????? i ask you Pakistani-Forum-Moderators??
I can imagine when someone is critical of Pakistan (even i am most of the time critical of Pakistan and the government of Pakistan) but when someone (specially Indian Nationalist)
are maligning Pakistan on this forum I really feel sad.
They not only malign or INSULT Pakistan it they make fun and laugh about it how this can be tolerated.
Please just tell me how this is possible.???!!!!
I am sure the moderators of this group are not blind and they can see what is being written
continuesly and time after time by some of the memebers. U cannot be ignorant of the fact that they sole purpose is to send negative post on this forum. Just check it please just read it.
I dont know how this is related to the topic. This is an India bashing thread if you cared to read the post..
Also please know that Gupshup has a feedback area where you can post your genuine feedback.
May be not related to this thread in strict sense but your point is very valid and need attention.
At least you see Indians acknowledging that the issue is related to criticism of India and a foolish men appointed as a Justice brought in to light serious lack of logical or sensible thinking even in many ‘elites’ of India.
(And many guppies from India on this BB)
Glad that the appeal was accepted. But the poor guy now has to go for third bench.
Do they not have right bench from the beginning??
Again I remind OP that this issue has been discussed in recent past extensively.
Back then Indians were bending backward to support removal of the student or it was a great decision from those stupid judges!
LOL…
I am pretty sure Indians now jump up and down again to hail this decision.
*Nothing to worry about.
*
*FYI. Secular societies do not enforce beard law in general public.
*
However private schools have every right to enforce policies related to the uniforms, facial appearance and the display of tattoos and other symbols be them religious or not.
And this is what you said earlier on March 30th.
*Good rule. Pakistan too should ban beard-ism in schools, colleges and madrasahs. *
Otherwise we'll continue to die at the hands of Islamists. Our mosques, schools, and offices are no longer safe, because we have given too much freedom to the terrorists and terroristic ideals all in the name of Islam.
So what happened since March 30th till now? Why change of heart dude?
Don't you want to see Pakistan Not enforcing beard law in general public now?
The case is hardly about general public or not,... mind you..before you jump in to answer.
You supported the decision then and you supported the decision now.
I don’t flip flop on issues like you. I still stand by my earlier comments. Judges have the right to pass judgement based on their sensibilities. Just the fact that the two benches had opposite views means that not everyone buys into this extremist mindset.
India is not an religious state and educated Indians will never support attempts to make it a fundamentalist/extremist state.
Care to mention where you might have seen me flip flopping?
Do I need to remind you your earlier delusional thoughts?
I still stand by my earlier comments. Judges have the right to pass judgement based on their sensibilities. Just the fact that the two benches had opposite views means that not everyone buys into this extremist mindset.
So you agree with this decision too. You have just been mentioned about your position earlier and now you are making statement on complete confidence on other decision. This is flip flopping on your part.
I alread predicted your response in my earlier post. Thanks for validating it!
Being die hard fan of India does not mean you must agree with every dumb and stupid Chief Justice in India. Have your own thought sometime for a change. But do I really have to give you so much credit?
India is not an religious state and educated Indians will never support attempts to make it a fundamentalist/extremist state.
'Educated' Indians? Those who's decision is now considered ridiculuos and those who were bending backward to support the original decision? LOL
I am pretty sure in trying to support India blindly you dont even care your own credibility is on the line here....;-)
And this is besides the point of discussion, India is a Hindu state. Please wake up.
