Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
Musharaf is using excessive force against a handful of students including women,children and men. Intention is to please foreign masters and to get reelected as President of Pakistan again
I was a big supporter of Musharraf uptill now, but....the siege of the mosque..has opened my eyes and I am anti Musharraf now
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
how is he using excessive force. he has not attacked the mosque, he has given a chance to people who want to come out, he has control SSG for not bombing the heck out of the mullah's after their own got murdered. tell me who is stopping those women and children inside from coming out?
what happened to there ninja squad?
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
how is he using excessive force. he has not attacked the mosque, he has given a chance to people who want to come out, he has control SSG for not bombing the heck out of the up mullah's after their own got murdered. tell me who is stopping those women and children inside from coming out? what happened to there ninja squad?
I don't care if there are ninjas inside..or samurais....Masjid is place of worship and house of Allah.....but Musharaf has ordered army to rid the mosque with bullets..plus its not the first time....He has also bombed mosques in NWFP.
Bombing a place of worship is beneath contempt
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
i thought the topic at hand was the VIDEO posted and not a comment that followed it... but again in response, masha Allah kiyaa phool jhaRai haiN zubaan saY... :)
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
You have to be a Muslim to understand the grief we have...for a mosque being attacked by mortars and bullet. Only a Muslim heart can feel it.....
Kasam say if I were in the army and i am being ordered to fire at the mosque....I will put my riffle down....put my uniform down....and spit on them..and will tell them " Sorry Sir...I cant fire on House of Allah"
Its like chosing between Allah and Musharraf
But again...as I said you have to have a muslim heart to understand the feeling.
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
You have to be a Muslim to understand the grief we have...for a mosque being attacked by mortars and bullet. Only a Muslim heart can feel it..... Kasam say if I were in the army and i am being ordered to fire at the mosque....I will put my riffle down....put my uniform down....and spit on them..and will tell them " Sorry Sir...I cant fire on House of Allah" Its like chosing between Allah and Musharraf But again...as I said you have to have a muslim heart to understand the feeling.
That is a noble sentiment but also please enlighten me about one thing. What would you say to the people who use Allah's house to keep children and women hostage and use the place to attack others. Remember they claim to be religious people and yet they have no respect for the sanctity of the mosque. Shouldn't you spit on them as well.
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
You have to be a Muslim to understand the grief we have...for a mosque being attacked by mortars and bullet. Only a Muslim heart can feel it..... Kasam say if I were in the army and i am being ordered to fire at the mosque....I will put my riffle down....put my uniform down....and spit on them..and will tell them " Sorry Sir...I cant fire on House of Allah" Its like chosing between Allah and Musharraf But again...as I said you have to have a muslim heart to understand the feeling.
The Mosque is being "attacked" to set the hostages free, not for the heck of demolishing the Mosque. I think the government has been way too lenient with those people who are holding young boys and girls hostages. The security agencies gave them more than enough time to turn themselves in and surrender but the people inside refuse to surrender. If they were so concerned about the Mosque being disrespected or demolished, they would not have hidden in the Mosque to begin with.
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
That is a noble sentiment but also please enlighten me about one thing. What would you say to the people who use Allah's house to keep children and women hostage and use the place to attack others. Remember they claim to be religious people and yet they have no respect for the sanctity of the mosque. Shouldn't you spit on them as well.
Which hostages? there were no hostages...the students were there to defend their mosque. They fought to death........even the old mother of Molana sahab died as shaheed.
This reminds me of Martydom of Hazrat Osman Raziallah Taaalaa. ...His house was also besieged for days...and was finally killed by agressors
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
Which hostages? there were no hostages...the students were there to defend their mosque. They fought to death........even the old mother of Molana sahab died as shaheed. This reminds me of Martydom of Hazrat Osman Raziallah Taaalaa. ...His house was also besieged for days...and was finally killed by agressors
It is an insult to compare Hazrat Osman to a third rate ghunda and thug who takes women and children hostage.
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
Bitter_reality.....bhai chup ker jao warna tum bhi ban ho jao gay.
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
Pyju ky hawarion ny demolished Masjidy Ameer Hamza first and other thing Do you guys aware, " Jamaya Karachi" ki zameen pr bhi na jaiz qbza ho ahy or ki awoh hasil kar li gai??? Qaidy Azam Ki property in Clifton bhi qabzy ka shikar hy kia os ka hukumat ny kuch kia ju sirf Masajis ki shahadat sy ay aghaz kia hy qabzy churany ka.
Main in ki himayat nahi kr rahi magar jahan tak meri history ki malomat hain “Hasab Bin Sabah” ky Bad “KHimini” ny yeh firqa parasti and Inteha PAsandi ka beej boya hy os ky pyro kar jab Sunnies ka jina on ky apny mulkon main haram karin gy tu yeh hoga.
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
Which hostages? there were no hostages...the students were there to defend their mosque. They fought to death........even the old mother of Molana sahab died as shaheed. This reminds me of Martydom of Hazrat Osman Raziallah Taaalaa. ...His house was also besieged for days...and was finally killed by agressors
.
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
Bitter_reality.....bhai chup ker jao warna tum bhi ban ho jao gay.
Hareem sister......we have to call a spade a spade. The sahabas gave their lives for Islam and if I get banned for Islam..I won't mind it. Its a very small sacrifice.
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
Whatever sacrifices they made, I don't see how it benefited islam and muslims. Jamia Hafsa people might be right but their means(allowing suicide bombing as a last option and abducting people) were wrong and totally against Islam.
They might be Shaheed if they were really fighting for the benefit of Islam.
Allah knows whats in our hearts.
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
me agree with hareeem baji 
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
No one has commented at the actual video yet.
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
u r acting as if u r working for Pak GOVT :halo:
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
Whatever sacrifices they made, I don't see how it benefited islam and muslims. Jamia Hafsa people might be right but their means(allowing suicide bombing as a last option and abducting people) were wrong and totally against Islam.
They might be Shaheed if they were really fighting for the benefit of Islam. Allah knows whats in our hearts.
Even, if we say that their way of doing things was wrong........that does not justify what the army did. The students of this madrasa burnt Porn CD shops...and abducted few prostitutes who were later released. They did not kill anybody in course of their actions.These crimes not that big to have them killed. Do u Agree?
Re: bazicha-e atfaal hai yeh dunya mere agay,
Even, if we say that their way of doing things was wrong........that does not justify what the army did. The students of this madrasa burnt Porn CD shops...and abducted few prostitutes who were later released. They did not kill anybody in course of their actions.These crimes not that big to have them killed. Do u Agree?
Dude, be realistic. When has there not been prostitution or such in this world?
It does not give anybody the right to go after the weak..... Who knows such women are in it of own choice? Why didnt they do the more accurate thing, as giving these women an option? Some could even have married them and saved for more sinful life? But to haress, embares and humiliate them in public.....was that an act of Diin?
Its really tragic! Was it worth getting young students killed for? I think, it became a typical display of ego...."annah". I grief for their deaths and still pray for future of Pakistan. This is a time of turmoil. Any leader of Pakistan will face trouble..... Upper class and top of the cherry, are crying for democrazy and the hardliners.....religious parties want their own person at charge. Who is better choice for Pakistan at end?
Bas Allahjee khair karey.......