Banning Non Muslims in Makkah

[Med911]

Re: Banning Non Muslims in Makkah

@psyah

Sorry MuNiYa … These pictures were not posted in justification for the banning of non-Muslims from Makkah, they were posted as evidence that others are doing the same.

And it appears you don’t follow them because they are not our teachers, however, when it comes to our teachers … Do you accept their verdicts? Apparently not if you believe this verdict is wrong.

Our teachers are those who earn respect and our obedience through their deeds and by the logic of and veracity of their teachings. People who’s teaching dont stand up to the scrutiny of logic and reason, as those who would try to convince us that Non-Muslims are not allowed to enter Mecca despite it all rational arguments against it, are perhaps not the best teachers to be guiding us. This ban, seems to contradict the teaching of Islam as a whole, and they just run in the face of logic. Why try to prop up such a clear and obvious discriminatory policy?!?!

I mean really, there are so many things in Islam which might have worked 1000 years ago, but dont work today. The Saudis still practice beheading for example, which most people would consider barbaric, even among Muslims today.