Ban against Music and Dancing

They’re at it again. No more music and dancing. The government should have no business in these things. People should be free to decide how religious he or she will be. If they don’t want to listen to music or dance, that’s fine, but why impose a law like this on everyone? Some may say, under Islam it is fine for government to impose religious law on people. But, what about the nonmuslim (party peoples) who want to listen to music and dance? Soon, we’ll see religious police running around.

MMA MPA seeks law against music, women’s photos in ads

By Waseem Ahmed

PESHAWAR, Feb 3: An MPA of the ruling Muttahida Majlis-i-Amal on Thursday tabled two private bills in the NWFP Assembly suggesting that music and dance in public places and educational institutions, and using photographs of women in advertisements be declared penal offences punishable by up to five years in prison along with a fine of up to Rs5,000 and Rs10,000, respectively.

The ‘NWFP Prohibition of Dancing and Music Bill, 2005’ and the ‘NWFP Prohibition of Use of Women Photographs Bill, 2005’ were moved by Mian Nadir Shah, the MPA from Mardan. Both offences will be cognizable and non-bailable.

Under rules, the voting on the bills can take place in three days. Opposition members Abdul Akbar Khan of the People’s Party Parliamentarians and Bashir Ahmad Bilour of the Awami National Party opposed the bills.

In their speeches in the house on Thursday, both opposition members said the bills were aimed at Talibanisation of the province. In the first draft law, a public place is a building, house, room, tent, enclosure, road, lane, bridge, square or any other place to which the public is admitted to witness a dance or music performance on payment or otherwise.

The draft law envisages that dance with all its variations shall mean the performance of dance with or without any money consideration or reward. Similarly, music means musical functions with or without any money consideration or reward.

If the law is enacted, dancing and music in a public place or in an educational institution will be considered an offence punishable with imprisonment of up to five years and with fine of up to Rs5,000.

The proposed law empowers a police officer not below the rank of inspector to enter any public place or educational institution and arrest any person who in his opinion has committed, or is committing or is about to commit such offence, including the person who abets the commission of such an offence.

The second bill pertaining to photographs of women reads: “Photograph means a photograph of a woman obtained through camera or hand drawing/painting or portrait, whether factual or artificial, which may amount to any incentive to sensuality or excitement of impure thoughts in the mind of an ordinary man of normal temperament; or tends to corrupt those minds which are open to such immoral influence, or which is deemed to be detrimental to public morals and calculated to produce pernicious effect, in depriving and debauching the minds of person.”

The draft law envisages that no person shall use the photograph in derogation of the dignity of human being or for commercial or advertisement purpose or for any purpose of monetary benefit or gain, including matters ancillary or incidental thereto

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

This is just for political consumption may be even to please some local tribal group. I think that MMA was given an opportunity to serve the masses but up till now they are :( I think MMA should do more to implement all the laws, which are already there on the books rather than creating more laws.

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

ABout time…all this music shuzik..take precious energies away from stoning, honor killings and buying F-16’s. Good going :k:

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

The Provincial Assembly represents the will of the people of the NWFP. If they choose to pass this law, we should accept it as the decision made by the individuals who have been chosen by the NWFP's people to represent them and their will.

If this is passed, frankly it is a testament to the strength of the regional democracies of Pakistan. That the people of a province can pass their own laws to reflect their own values irrespective of what the nation's leader in Islamabad wishes.

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

Maddy, I agree with you, there is no doubt in the democratic representative process. But Jamat with all the brain power behind it should do more than just this. MMA is yet to deliver on its promises.

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

I think, if they (once in their life) invite me to do a little recital in the assembly on some Tintaal, I am sure they will change their minds about music.

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

The people of the NWFP will pass their judgement on the MMA’s delivery at the next provincial assembly.

The system is working :jhanda: :teary1:

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

you mean rectal?

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

all music lovers around the world will change their minds about music once they hear your tabla.

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

haroon2004 - this law in no way dictates to people what to do.

this is a law that governs PUBLIC activities not what people are doing in their homes.

there are similar laws such as prohibition of smoking in public, prohibition of public arms display (in some parts of pak), prohibition of selling food items in Ramzaan during the fast...things like that...

the government has every right to make such laws...and the MMA was chosen by the majority of the people of NWFP thru elections so it is empowered to pass such laws

i'm completely in favor of this law

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

Democractic principles aside, the proposed law (as reported in the first piece) is a case study in How-A-Law-Should-Not-Be-Written. It is so vague. For example read this

[QUOTE]
and arrest any person who in his opinion has committed, or is committing or is about to commit such offence
[/QUOTE]
Just imagine how much the law can be misused by any inspector arguing that the person is about to break out in a dance move.
Also, read

[QUOTE]
that dance with all its variations shall mean the performance of dance with or without any money consideration or reward
[/QUOTE]
Potentially this means, that when some test results are announced, and a student is excited about scoring good marks, just doing an impromptu bhangra move can land him in jail and he can be fined Rs 5,000.

If our court system were reliable, they will strike down such vague laws, right away. Unfortunately we can't always rely on the courts either to do the right thing.

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

mullah ppl just want to appear in cosmetics commercial themselves, all this hoopla for a little glamour..

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

Havent you seen the movie ‘The minority report’? :slight_smile:

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

yea akif we are goin high tech without the tech! we are mind readers

its on of political scoring law. will atleast can acheive these on papers, its just law for public,
no one stopping Mullahs from having private dance parties arranged by "Madam Tahira" if some of your remembers story about One Mullah still in MMA.

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

yeah right! this is sign of regional democracy just like Osama was elected chief terrorist by the terrorists of the world.

If educated people are going to try and rationalize this kind of extremism perhaps Pakistan deserves to be a permanent dictatorship. Like you said, people get what they are.

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

Are they also going to ban smiling? They should, I mean what more unIslamic then happiness? God forbid there should every be any exhibition of joy in Islam.

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

^ Hey what is the punishment for playing the air guitar? :hehe:

Re: Ban against Music and Dancing

air whipping