Baking help! Butter pecan cake

I have a sister who is an amazing baker. She always makes my birthday cakes so this year I decided to return the favor.

Next week is her birthday and I decided to make a butter pecan flavored cake. Problem is…I have no clue where to start!

I know we have quite a few bakers on GS, so does anyone have a good butter pecan cake recipe?

I see so many online but it is all a bit overwhelming. Any other tips or tricks would also be appreciated. I really want to make a yummy cake so please help.

Even a really good white or yellow cake recipe would help.

Thanks :flower1:

Baking help! Butter pecan cake

Sounds yummy! Butter Pecan is my favorite ice cream..I can only imagine how a cake would taste :yummy:

Looking forward to a good recipe

Re: Baking help! Butter pecan cake

Guacy.. I read reviews of recipes just to see how the reviewers thought it turned out and how they tweaked it. I dont bake. Ever. The few rare times I have, it was literally a disaster.

Re: Baking help! Butter pecan cake

Butter pecan ice cream is her favorite! That was where the idea was from :smiley:

But there are soo many reviews…good and bad. I can’t decide on one :confused:

Re: Baking help! Butter pecan cake

WHy don’t you make an ice cream cake? Those are easy and require no baking, you just need a springform pan and some ice cream/candy/fudge/whatever you want.

Baking help! Butter pecan cake

This one sounds amazing…it’s Paula Deen’s, so must be a southern favorite lol

http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/paula-deen/butternut-cake-with-butter-pecan-frosting-recipe.html#!

Re: Baking help! Butter pecan cake

I love baking and wish I could help you

but the closest I could find with the dessert sites I use, was pecan pie :frowning:

I like the ice cream cake idea. You bake a simple sponge cake and cut it half and fill it with her fave butter pecan ice cream. Set it in freezer , I’m thinking even a chocolate cake with butter pecan ice cream would be good :slight_smile:
Do let us know what you ended up doing

Re: Baking help! Butter pecan cake

Hmm maybe an ice cream cake is the best option…

I’m going to make it this week, will definitely let you guys know what I end up doing

Thanks everyone

Re: Baking help! Butter pecan cake

Okay so I thought about using ice cream but then decided against it. Just imagining it melting all over was enough for me to stay away.

I decided to use a random recipe online that had a lot of good reviews. Here is the link: Toasted Butter Pecan Cake Recipe | Taste of Home

I followed it to the T and it came out pretty good thankfully! Baker sis loved it so did my parents.

The only thing I noticed was that when it was first made it was pretty moist however over time (I placed it in the fridge for a day) it became a bit drier. So next time I would just cover it and leave it out at room temp.

Here are some pics:


Restored attachments:

Re: Baking help! Butter pecan cake

awesome guac! gotta try this

Looks lovely

Re: Baking help! Butter pecan cake

Looks great. My mom loves the butter pecan ice cream so I think I will make this for her dawat :slight_smile: