Baagh-e-Fidak. The one that was taken away from H.Fatima (R.A) by H.Omer (R.A)

[Ma_Mooli]

@Kaleem

Ma Mooli, it is easy to see the difference. Muhammad:saw: was a different person than Ali or Fatima. They (Ali and Fatima) are responsible for their own deeds and actions and cannot be the same as Muhammad:saw:, no matter what you repeat here. If i go with your logic, why do you hold so much contempt against Ayesha? She will be a part of so called synonymous Ahl-ul-bayt right? or do you have different rules when it comes to wives of the prophet?

kaleem, let me quote what i said earlier:

Picking up on what AQ was saying, the sunnah and the ahl ul bayt are not two different enitities. The sunnah is the way of the prophet, and you will get an authentic version from the Ahl ul bayt (as), as opposed to other ‘personalities’.

now which part of that assumes that they are the one and the same person and not responsible for thier own deeds?

The point here is, the Prophet (saw) did not contradict himself by stating ‘hold on to the Quran and sunnah’ and ‘hold on to the Quran and Ahl ul Bayt’. Thats all im saying here.

[Kaka-Manna]

Re: Baagh-e-Fidak. The one that was taken away from H.Fatima (R.A) by H.Omer (R.A)

1400 saal sai is baat par lar lar kar mar gai hai, kisi ko koi faida nai hua, jiyo aur jeenai dau , mukhlisana mashwara hai kai sub log Lassi ka aik aik glass piyo aur chill maro.

[Kaka-Manna]

Re: Baagh-e-Fidak. The one that was taken away from H.Fatima (R.A) by H.Omer (R.A)

daikhai mujhai jau deeda-i-ibrat nigah hau !

http://ravi.lums.edu.pk/sabieh/shaheed.pdf](http://ravi.lums.edu.pk/sabieh/shaheed.pdf)

[jishah]

Salam!

1400 saal say lar lar kay mar gaye.................gham or khushee dono kee alamat hay meray payaray bhai/behan..............jab bhee koiee kisee ko samjahany kee justajoo kartaa hay us kay peechay:

1) woh apnaa time lagataa hay
2) apnee resources istimal kartaa hay
3) woh jis rastay pay chal rahaa hotaa hay uss kee taraf tumay bulataa hay ( uss kay khial may sahee or behtar rastaa)
4) aap kay achay or buray jawaabaat bee suntaa/partaa hay
5) or kabhee kabhee to badnamee bhee mol laitaa hay

Yeh sub uss kee
"AAP SAY MOHABAT OR IKHLASS HAY"
THEREFORE APPRECIATE HIM/HER PLEASE FOR THE EFFORTS

Thanks
Topic pay kal baat karoo ghaa ............