Baagh-e-Fidak. The one that was taken away from H.Fatima (R.A) by H.Omer (R.A)

[SalmanNY]

Re: Baagh-e-Fidak. The one that was taken away from H.Fatima (R.A) by H.Omer (R.A)

@Sharaabi

That rule might apply to weaklings like us, but to associate the Prophet (sas) with a such a low-life rule would be a crime.

No one is above the Shariah…period; and their are plenty of ahadith to prove this point, so lets not forget the qawaids of this Deen in the height of our emotions.

Sharrabi bhai, in my opinion disrespecting the Rasool :saw: daugther should be a crime. His saying’s are the shariah right? Are you suggesting nawoozbillah Hazarat Fatima r.a wasn’t following shariah or didn’t know her own father’s teachings ? Are you suggesting that she purposely tried to disobey Rasool-ull-Allah’s Shariah by asking the land of FidaK from Hazrat Abu-Bakar r.a. ? By no means I am disrespecting any of the Sahaba, and laanat oh mairaye per if I am doing that; But I am saying that on one side we so strongly believe that no body should be above the Shariah, but quiet convienently we are forgetting that this is the very daughter of that person on which this whole shariah based upon. As somebody said here on this thread, some one was wrong and someone was right in this issue. We will only know on the day of Qiyamat. And as you said, The people at whom some of us are pointing their fingers are far too high for our reach". I agree with that statement and lets end it right here.
-Salman