Aziz to World Bank - Chattha as PM?

Interesting article. Seems a lot of conjecture baked in with some facts (typical journalistic traditions). Anyway, what do you guys think about it? Any chance of it panning out.

I knew Chattha’s son from his Aitchison days. Nice guy, but the family doesn’t seem to be upright honest patriotic citizens. They are most like your traditional politicians who’d turn in any direction that allows them more power. Plus, I kinda like Aziz. Atleast he is educated and can talk the talk. Real power, ofcourse, lies with the President, anyway.

Aziz May Join World Bank: Hamid Chattha Emerging Consensus Leader

WASHINGTON/KARACHI, July 29: The World Bank corridors in Washington are humming with whispered expectations and corporate speculations that Pakistan’s Prime Minister, Citibanker Shaukat Aziz, a long time buddy of WB President Paul Wolfowitz, is soon going to join the world body as Managing Director.

Wolfowitz is understood to have offered Aziz the top job because the World Bank needs to fill in one of the two vacancies of MDs, the one from Asia. The other MD comes from Africa. Wolfowitz believes Aziz would be the right candidate as big Asian players including China and India will not have any serious objection to Aziz, who has lived in the US for 30 years before joining the Musharraf team as Finance Minister in 1999 and later getting a promotion as Prime Minister.

But since Musharraf has not allowed any real powers to the Parliament or the PM, Aziz wants to get out of the Pakistan mess with his honor and image intact and the WB job may be the best chance he could get.

According to a well informed Islamabad analyst, Nusrat Javeed of “The News”, the sudden cancellation of the Aziz visit to the White House and the way the Pakistan Foreign Office dismissed the cancellation as of no importance, hurt Aziz deeply as he was expecting some glory in the world limelight as a guest of President Bush.

Nusrat wrote recently: “The spokesperson of our Foreign Office has not helped either by spinning the story that the US visit of Shaukat Aziz was never “finalized.”

It is a laughable excuse, only helping the doomsayers, who keep insisting that prime ministers working under the praetorian wings always ask for trouble with their desire of getting ‘direct’ with American leaders and decision makers.”

“Mir Zafarullah Khan Jamali began rushing to his fall by publicly asking for the pat on our back during his call on President Bush. The flight of Shaukat Aziz in the same context could not be allowed as well,” Nusrat wrote.

This news circulating in the World Bank coincides with behind the scene maneuvers in Islamabad to break the political logjam to induct the mainstream liberal political parties in the system and isolate the radical religious right which is now becoming a threat not only to the country but to the Army itself.

General Musharraf met Shaukat Aziz, one on one, for the second time within a week on Wednesday, July 27, for what was publicly presented as a routine meeting with one briefing the other about his foreign trips and a general discussion on the country’s political and security situation. But analysts say these meetings may be more than what meets the eye. The two leaders may be discussing their future association.

These backdoor moves involve a longtime Benazir Bhutto ally and politically trusted leader Hamid Nasir Chattha who has been actively meeting the various relevant players in and outside Pakistan. Chattha is currently in the PML-Q and Chairman of the Kashmir Committee, enjoying a Minister’s status. Interestingly in all Kashmir Committee meetings, PPP parliamentarians including Makhdoom Amin Faheem, are regular participants and they go along well with Chattha.

With this background, Chattha is being tipped as the head of a National Government in which both Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif, or their nominees and parties, are substantial stakeholders.

In a moment when he revealed more than he should have, PPP’s top ranking leader Makhdoom Amin Faheem was heard saying that such a deal under Chattha was possible and people were working on it.

Even in his recent analysis, Nusrat Javeed posed the all-important question: “Where is Hamid Nasir Chattha these days and does he really have anything to do with the grand government of national reconciliation, many people in Islamabad have been waiting for since months?”

Under the proposed arrangement the basic concessions to Benazir and Nawaz Sharif would be the withdrawal of the Swiss cases and end of exile, or a time table to end the exile, much shorter than the stipulated 10 years.

But to many political analysts and observers, all these possibilities and proposals appear to be part of the pattern of psy-op games which the Pakistan Army has now become quite good at playing.

These games grow in intensity whenever there is some pressure on the Generals, either because of their double games on terrorism, or their secret alliance with the Mullas who always do something to bail out the Army, though apparently it may appear that they are in opposition, or if the pressure from the West to induct mainstream political parties in power sharing increases.

As part of this pattern, political analysts recall, the highly disruptive talk of “national reconciliation” was coined and feelers were thrown in that Army was talking to the PPP and Benazir Bhutto through Asif Ali Zardari. The PPP got caught in that trap and started believing that the Generals were sincere in a deal.

Thus the PPP took a very soft line when Asif Zardari returned to Lahore amid unprecedented enthusiasm and excitement not seen for years in the PPP cadre. But the return of Zardari, instead of building up on that momentum, defused the situation through some soft statements of Mr Zardari himself as well as admission by the PPP that secret negotiations were going on. Nothing however came out as the Army was playing its games and the moment pressure was off, all talk of concessions or a deal was off the table.

Likewise these psy-ops games have also played havoc with the Sharif family when through calculated moves the impression was created that Shahbaz Sharif was moving away from his elder brother and was being preferred as a possible option under a re-united Muslim league. Nawaz Sharif, however, understood the games much better and stood his ground.

Then the passport issue of Nawaz Sharif was used to create further confusion in the Opposition ranks when suddenly PPP was forced to seek clarifications from the Sharifs on what was going on. That issue also created some confusion but failed to make a serious dent in Opposition unity.

The latest move of the Mulla-military alliance is the Hasba Act which was thrown into the political arena by the MMA at a critical time when all main Opposition parties, including the PPP, PML-N and MMA were about to reach a consensus and announce a joint strategy against the Army rule.

The Hasba Act derailed the Opposition talks and both PPP and PML-N started criticizing the MMA for something which took the focus off their joint target. It helped the Army in a way no friend could have helped.

In such a situation and with the Local Bodies polls round the corner, the talk of a National Government is, to many analysts, one more ploy of the Army to divert attention and confuse the players.

Re: Aziz to World Bank - Chattha as PM?

Hmm Chattha is about at the same level as Jamali or a bit higher politically to be honest..his family is influential in it's own area ( i think his son is district nazim?) ..losing another PM..would be farcial though and just reemphasise the toothlessness of the Mushy League

Re: Aziz to World Bank - Chattha as PM?

Short cut Aziz sud take this offer, its a respectable exit for a decent chap.

Hamid Nasir Chatta belongs to Punjab and has been around for quite some time, only problem one cud foresee is the Caudhries who may not want to share Punjab with anyone else.

Re: Aziz to World Bank - Chattha as PM?

[quote=“Faisal”]
… Anyway, what do you guys think about it? Any chance of it panning out.
…**[

Proves my point about Shaheen being biased. Only a dim whit could deny the need for a National government. Off course BB will be the first one to suggest a “Long Long March” against everything but Army. Examples of simply basket case poly-ticks.](“http://www.satribune.com/archives/200507/P1_mas2.htm”)

Re: Aziz to World Bank - Chattha as PM?

*He has not shown any leadership within the country either. The issues of Baluchistan, or Hisbah got more attention via Gujrat's Chaudhries. No body stopped Aziz to get the political dialogue going with Baloch or Pashtoons. *

You make it sound like the faujis wanted an assertive PM? The Chorys prefer a non political (or politically irrelevant politician) in the top perch because they don't want to lose party control..the Faujis don't want a person with backbone (a la Junejo or Nawaz Sharif) talking back to Mush...I agree though Sehbai has a habit of making castles in the air..

Re: Aziz to World Bank - Chattha as PM?

Back to Balochistan and Hisba bill. Aziz showed no creativity. Pakistan has many issues that have to be solved by a creative person and not some lose canon a la assertive PM. Punjab needs to build bridges with disenfranchised sections of the country. Shujaat is doing much better job in that respect (even though I am no fan of the Gujratis).

Fauj (army) and Faujis (Generals) want to see a country that is pro-Army and stable (in that order). There is nothing wrong with that approach. Every major nation in the world is pro-Army and stable (in that order). Military-industrial complex of the West, Military-Silk complex of China, or Military-IT complex of Bharat are prime examples of the “right priorities”.

Jonejo or Jamali were gentlemen, and Aziz is a suited booted munshi. Instead Pakistan needs more agressive, pesky dogs of PM who can push the army budget up to $10 billion and bring some dough to Balochistan and Frontier. Just listen to Achakzai. He says he needs a $1 billion water works project for Pashtunkhwah. For 150 million country, this is a small change if we have a creative PM and Aziz or for that matter even Chattha is won’t fit the bill.

Re: Aziz to World Bank - Chattha as PM?

Humayun Akhter is a major player for the top post (PM) and past speculation has always mentioned his name aspiring for this position. Infact, Shaukat Aziz was the compromise candidate cause the Generals wanted Akhter as PM while the Gujrati brothers opposed and prevailed.

Mr Aziz has certainly redeemed himself as the Finance Minister and probably still is performing the same duties with change of positions.

As long as we have the Faujis+Chaudhries in alliance, its difficult to expect any assertive PM in the forseeable future. Chaudhries have always played alongwith the establishment and are well versed with rules of the game. They also realized how important it is to stay in power to perpetuate their existing support. Politics in Pakistan centers around power and the Chaudhries know that thus their reluctance to share Punjab.

Faujis are quite comfortable with this arrangement cause it serves their interest and to be fair Chaudhries have delivered whenever required ie LFO, political stability, support to the Faujis (Mush) and an effective resistence to the Sharifs.
Therefore, its my guess not much changes with a any shuffling of the PM position which has been effectively reduced to a ceremonial post with power resting with the Fauji President.

Re: Aziz to World Bank - Chattha as PM?

^^ agreed , Mushy will not prefer a PM with a political Backbone, and chatha doens fit there he will bite back as Mian Azhar of Lahore. meaning transferring power to a well versed politician will weaken his own position and grip on Power.

Re: Aziz to World Bank - Chattha as PM?

You must be a freakin bhindian loser…cause nobody save the the nerdy NRIs, who have nothing better to do at work, except surf the web and overcompensate for their inferiority complexes, deluded to the core regarding the collossal failure and burden that is the Indian defence industry would glorify it.

Military-IT complex…never heard of that…Bhindia’s domestic industries contribute zilch to its defence needs, leave alone any contribution by the coolie call center establisment…all the equipment is bought from foreign suppliers…with Russia and Israel leading the pack in selling one overhyped system after another…Indian call center crew would be better off staying as far as as possible from the DRDO or more commonly known as DODO…

Re: Aziz to World Bank - Chattha as PM?

Personal attacks aside (not that i shy away from them. MAToos know very well!). Your are mistaken to expect Bharati IT to contribute “directly” to the military. However Bharati IT industry has brought a much needed “buzz” to the country. In the short run this “buzz” has brought in $$$ in the tune of $10-15 billion and help add FDIs to several non-IT projects. Bangalore is a safe place for the Western visitors and they bring in $$$.

The cash my friend is king and that goes straight to feeding the army of Bharat hungry for new weapons. Similarly the same cash from Chinese “mistry” (manufacturing) industry helps China buy IBM or Unocol and feed the resulting cash to the military.

Too bad that in Pakistan we just sit at home and wait for others to come in and pay cash for doing small time jobs. We lost many opportunities to go out and get cash for ourselves. Mistakes to get cash are a plenty in Pakistan.

Thanks to Bhaato MAToo (Islamic-Socialist or Mullahtic-communist) we killed our industry. So no $$ from there. Then we get an opportunity to get “Maal-e-Ghaneemat” form Gulf War-I and the stupido generala Aslam Begum killed that opportunity.

Now our MuMA group and leftie Urdu papers are keeping us from getting cash $$$ form Gulf War-II. Sure we may lose 2000+ soliders but countries don’t raise military to sit at home and f@rt around. They are supposed to go out and bring home the “Maal-e-Ghaneemat” just like the armies of Siddiq, Farooq, and Ali (Razi-Allah cubed).

So we need a new PM who uses his “back-bone” to bring home the dough and not in any event create a “bone” of contention with smaller provinces or the army.

Kapeesh!