Authenticity of Haadith

[firenze]

Re: Authenticity of Haadith

@psyah

Peace firenze

If you are of the opinion that a hadith can either be fabricated or authentic and nothing else then I’m afraid I can’t help you … I already said that it is not fabricated … Which means the majority of scholars who have commented on this hadith have called it “sound” - which means that it cannot be proven to be fabricated, but it’s transmission is not strong enough to be called authentic.

Peace psyah

I didn’t said that anywhere.
What do you mean by scholars, when something can’t be found in all of 6 major haadith books. Neither their is in any reference after 1000 years of Prophet (PBUH) death. How can be it considered a haadith or let alone weak one. I still didn’t get what do you mean by sound, so by this definition any words or proverbs can be called as haadith" if majorioty of scholars are on one page.

Draw a line somewhere.