Are we gullible?

A student won first prize at one of the college when he was attempting to
show how conditioned we have become to alarmists practicing junk
science and spreading fear of everything in our environment.

In his project he urged people to sign a petition demanding
strict control or total elimination of the chemical “dihydrogen
monoxide.”
And for plenty of good reasons, since it can:

  1. Cause excessive sweating and vomiting
  2. It is a major component in acid rain
  3. It can cause severe burns in its gaseous state
  4. Accidental inhalation can kill you
  5. It contributes to erosion
  6. It decreases effectiveness of automobile brakes
  7. It has been found in tumors of terminal cancer patients

He asked 50 people if they supported a ban of the chemical.
Forty-three said yes, six were undecided, and only one knew that
the chemical was water.

Re: Are we gullible?

I can be quite gullible.

Interesting.

Re: Are we gullible?

most of the 'science' around us falls in this category. Perhaps not only science, most of all information around us falls in this category.

Re: Are we gullible?

^ True.

Re: Are we gullible?

i wouldve said that too.. i mean in favor of banning this chemical..i've heard h2O as water.but not dihydrogen monooxide..although if u c its the same thing!
Human r gullible..dont know a lot of basic stuff!

Re: Are we gullible?

Knowledge does make difference to some extent but presentation of the information makes a huge difference.

Media can control mind of a large number of people..even the 'educated and intelligent' people.

Re: Are we gullible?

deedawar do u have a link, as 5-6 years ago those two dudes on tv did the same thing, and they fool alot of people, so this dude was merely copying them i guess.

Re: Are we gullible?

http://www.snopes.com/science/dhmo.asp

I think I had a different source a while ago but found this similar one now. It may very well be a hoax.

At any rate, the message is more important than source or origin of the story. If you know what I mean.

Re: Are we gullible?

nice deewar

Re: Are we gullible?

^ Thank you

Re: Are we gullible?

gullible? :party: i think we’re all just UN-informed!:halo:

Re: Are we gullible?

Its hard to accept but anyone CAN be gullible sometimes.

Re: Are we gullible?

**zainab **dihydrogen monoxide is different having a different structure bur chemicallyy reacts somewat similar .

deedawar i always wondered that being gullible and making others gullible
will end up the life circle one day . but then god has created soo many creatures .

Re: Are we gullible?

yep, just tried with few of my friends without mentioning its water half of them said it should be banned. the rest recognized. 50-50.

Re: Are we gullible?

What a dumb way to argue that humans are gullible. What a frickin' dumb way. First of all, I recognize this joke from about five years ago. Secondly, it's not a question of gullibility, it's one of deception. You can't state that it's "dihydrogen monoxide" and expect the regular Joe to understand that type of scientific terminology. When you're conforting people about these issues, you've got to be honest. You got to tell people the facts, or use a simpler word if there is one. By the way, that list is also deceptive. If you're just focusing on the negative, of course people will have a negative response!

It's kind of like if I told you of a disease in latin words or another language and you freaked out only to discover that I was talking about the common cold. Or like I told you of all the bad things that could happen to you while breathing and you tried to go to Congress to ban breathing.

Re: Are we gullible?

^stewie, first of all welcome to GS

secondly, I know reading threads in S&P can get emotional at times, but please refrain from attacking the poster/post instead of replying to it (e.g. the usage of the word 'dumb')

thirdly, the examples you are giving about what will be the reaction if you give jargon to the layman, is exactly the point deedawar is trying to make ;--)

Re: Are we gullible?

excellent point deedawar......and great post.
goes to show you how many will jump on a bandwagon without even asking where it's headed.

Re: Are we gullible?

not all people are gullible. some know all too well, how to play mind games.

some beat others on them, to escape gullibility.

logic it out.