Re: Are these Ahadeeth authentic and if so why do they contradict?
So you’re saying one of the Ahadeeth is authentic whilst the other is not (either because the transmitters had a bad memeory or they liked to forge things)? Bare in mind these Ahadeeth are from Bukhari and Muslim, our (so called) most authentic Ahadeeth collections.
Or are they both authentic and it’s perfectly acceptable for things attributed to the Prophet :saw: to contradict each other?
I’m confused, blind faith was so much nicer when I believed everything my Ustaad Ji (Mullah), dad, mom and the Deobandi/Tableeghi Jamaat books they gave me said but I don’t think I’ll ever be able to go back to blind following any sect or religion again.