Salam.Last time i was here qadiani dicussion was banned.I have seen a couple of threads on the sad terrorist attacks in lahore so i though i should proceed and start my thread too.
I want to ask that do qadianis deserve a minority status or not, let alone muslim.
I will give u a scenario and then u judge.
Lets suppose qadianis were not declared non muslims.
A guy named Mirza Tom liari shows up in 1950’s and he says that mirza ghulam came in his dream and told him that i am you so u now declare your self mahdi and messiah since the law in your country allows every tom,dick and harry to claim prophethood.Now this guy mirza Tom liari prays five time,recites kalima but he also calls for jugga tax.He says since Jugga tax dident existed when islam came so its allowed.So his follower collect jugga tax by all means killing and looting.
Now in 1960’s a guy name mirza dick peshawari shows up.He gathers his family members and claims that he is mahdi and challenges status of mirza ghulam qadiani and mirza tom liari.
This guy mirza dick peshawari knows that in Pakistan there are no blasphemy laws so any lay man can claim to be a mahdi and messiah.
This man Mirza dick peshawari prays five times,recites kalima,but promotes sodomy.He makes up his own interpretation and tells his followers sodomy is allowed and good for health.
Now the year is 1970 a guy Mirza Harry hyderabadi shows up.He too gathers his family members.He says he believes in all five pillars of islam but he asks his followers to join israeli defence forces and kill palestinians.He asks his followers not to protest incidents like freedom floatilla.He asks his followers to support terrorist activities and to never let go of any opportunity to tarnish the image of Pakistan on world stage.
Now what i wanna know is that if every tom dick and harry is allowed to claim prophethood and call him self mahdi and messiah and krishan and there is no law to place a check on them then what scene would we paint of ourselves.
If all the sects of islam have unanimously declared qadianis, non muslims and in the form 2/3 majority its present in the constitution representing the will of the majority of Pakistani then whats the harm in it.
Dont u think if this matter goes to the court or comes for debate in the parliament qadianis can loose their minority status too and might end up as a cult.