Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

“Peace is not unity in similarity but unity in diversity, in the comparison and conciliation of differences.”

As world celebrates diversity, Pakistan dishonours it – The Express Tribune

ISLAMABAD: ** **
While Pakistan crumbles bit-by-bit under the burden of sectarian violence and blatant disregard for minorities, the rest of the world celebrates the World Day for Cultural Diversity.

The celebration goes back to 2001, when UNESCO adopted the Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity. The following year, a UN General Assembly resolution declared May 21 to be the World Day for Cultural Diversity and Dialogue and Development.

The World Day for Cultural Diversity and Development has yet to be ratified by the Pakistani Government. Although UNESCO has been working for ratifying the convention for safeguarding intangible cultural heritage, there is no denying that much has to be done to promote tolerance for cultural diversity by the government and private institutions.

The 2012 campaign, by encouraging people and organisations from around the world to take concrete action to support diversity, aims to raise awareness worldwide about the importance of intercultural dialogue, diversity and inclusion, to build a world community of individuals committed to support diversity, and to combat polarisation and stereotypes to improve understanding and cooperation among people from different cultures.

**Pakistan, being home to some of the great civilisations would be expected to be a hub of cultural tolerance and dialogue. Unfortunately, while each province boasts rich ethnic heritage, the mesh of colours and cultures into one proud statement still seems eons away.
**

As poet and author Harris Khalique aptly states, “What food and water are to the human body, personal dignity and cultural identity are to the soul. Pakistan has not done enough to appreciate, promote or cherish its cultural and linguistic diversity. Our local cultures are hybrid offshoots of the Indo-Gangetic, Central Asian and Indo-Persian civilisations. This makes us akin to a fragrant bouquet of flowers. We must celebrate that.”

Cultural diversity and its meaning vary according to personal perceptions. While the popular and soft belief is that a variety of traditions and ethnic entities come together to create cultural diversity; there are some that take the more hard line approach. Intellectual and writer Ashfaq Saleem Mirza is among those that connect diversity with economics. “Cultural diversity is actually economic disparity; take the example of Europe during the 18th and 19th centuries, when nation states were being created, the various cultures merged into each other as a result of economic development.”

Coming closer to home, Mirza points out that economic disparity creates unwanted diversity, citing the example of people from the Thar desert. “These people use different tools and have different working systems from the rest of Pakistan because of economic disparity. It is tradition for the women to walk miles to fetch water, but if a tap was provided, that ‘cultural tradition’ would end and they would manage the routine just like everyone else in the country who has access to a tap,” states Mirza. Hence the more developed the nation, the less diversity there will probably be.

Cultural diversity may or may not have economics roots, but the effect diversity has on the arts is unmistakable. Just looking at different styles of craft across the country is sufficient enough, as peace activist and art curator Nageen Hayat points out. “When you look at diversity in Pakistan, there are vast differences in various areas, but what we lack is a proper structure to support the provinces. It’s very important to interact and work together.”

When asked how a country can pursue tolerance for cultural diversity, Khalid Javaid, the director of Lok Virsa, which works year-round to educate people about local cultures, said, “Cultural Diversity can be used to our advantage, but what we need to understand is that the sum of all these cultures becomes a Pakistani culture. There is no lack of diversity…in the northern areas alone, 50 indigenous languages are spoken. It’s not enough to have a cultural museum in the capital city; exhibitions and cultural museums should exist at all district levels where people can come together regularly to exhibit and learn. Antiquity of our ancient culture and its continuity is the key”.

Re: Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

Cultural diversity is accepted only if by and large the society is tolerant. In India we have seen the tolerance go up in certain cases like intercaste marriages (atleast in the south and cities) but religious tolerance is decreasing.

Re: Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

Inter-caste marriages taboo is rapidly disappearing in Pakistani society as well, but religious tolerance including harmony amongst different sects is at stake.

Re: Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

I think the issues we have in Pakistan can be solved through democracy, good governance, education and economic stability. Most of these things are dependant on the others.

Re: Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

you mean to say that people will not tolerate if they are made to believe that they were exploited by other group

Re: Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

If I see India of the 90s, it was more fractured along ethnic lines where as Pakistan was more stable. The only difference was economy, during this period Indian economy has grown (cementing their nationhood) where as we have got fractured. If all are economically well and treated equally by the law, I believe the country would unite again.

Re: Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

India has proved that even democracy, laws and education cannot change things if the mind set of the society does not change. That is why we have people who are highly educated and in good jobs and even rich arrested for disgusting things like rape and dowry.

Re: Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

but aren't such people an exception?

Re: Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

Cultural diversity is a new concept in the civilised world, where as in the subcontinent this has been taking place for thousands of years. The people forming Pakistan are very diverse, it's strange to see the places which have been historically very tolerant to become intolerant during the past few decades.

Re: Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

who is responsible for that? Do you think that bifurcation / division in the name of religion promoted cultural divisions?

Re: Are Pakistani afraid of Cultural Diversity?

I personally think martial laws, foreign policies (resulting in spread of religious intolerance), composition of military and over centralisation of resources/government systems are responsible for these divisions.

I believe Pakistan can move forward as a democracy where each and every person has the same rights. Federation should devolve their powers to the provinces and then to local council level (work has begun by previous government but more needs to be done). The military needs to be more representative, in simple the image that goes out that Pakistan = Punjab needs to go. When every one has equal stakes things will start improving. I hope at a certain stage even the political parties have democracy in them, why can't PMLN have a Sindhi or Baloch president? The same goes for PPP as well.

For the next few decades I believe the focus of development should be more on the impoverished areas to bring them at par with the more developed ones.