Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

http://www.blogcdn.com/www.engadget.com/media/2012/08/samsung-evidence2.jpg As much as Apple would love for Kwon Oh-hyun to turn up at court and tearfully confess to being a copycat, that’s probably not going to happen. Instead, Cupertino’s lawyers are burrowing through Samsung’s history in search of a legal smoking gun, and one of their latest submissions has been presented as just that. It’s a 132-page document written in 2010 by Sammy engineers that directly compares the iPhone against the Galaxy S and makes recommendations about how the latter should be more like the former. The excerpt shown above, which focuses on the aesthetics of icons on the rival handsets, even appears to contain advice about how Samsung should copy Apple without appearing to copy them so much, whereas the full document embedded after the break reveals how all-encompassing the internal guidance was. On the flip-side, Samsung may well argue that any responsible company should compare itself to its competition in this manner, and you can bet there’s an army of lawyers beavering away right now to make that sound convincing.

[Thanks, Alex]
Continue reading Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry
Filed under: Cellphones
Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry originally appeared on Engadget on Wed, 08 Aug 2012 03:04:00 EDT. Please see our terms for use of feeds.
Permalink

http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.engadget.com/media/post_label_VIA.gif

AllThingsD | | Email this | Comments

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

heyyy niksik, look at this :D

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

OMG Queer :mad: I thought u were my fraand! Bunch of politics.

Let me have this moved to the main forum for further discaaashins.

Bottomline is that my S3 is a wonderful product. Let’s focus on the end result, shall we :snooty:.

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

if true, does this mean a samsung S3 fans are actually just iphone fans in denial? :eek:

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

Gross.
S3 > iPewp :snooty:

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

We can start a thread in Philosophy and Spirituality for that :hmmm:!

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

I am on Samsung’s side…I hope they win :stuck_out_tongue:

It is true what the article says…they could very well argue the point that any responsible company would compare to its competition…that is what ALL companies do! All the biggies anyways…

There are so many phones that look like each other these days…I don’t understand what all the fuss is about :snooty:

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

Apple is acknowledging that people realize it's just a brand and are going for quality over being fan boys/ girls :p

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

This is kind of funny and I totally agree with Aaliyah. Isn't that what ALL companies do? Make a product that has all the qualities the competition product has and more. There are companies that don't even hide that fact that they are literally copying a competitions product exactly but will change one minutiae detail so there won't be any legal battles.

Hahaha manno!

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

yes, but one can only add those qualities/features that aren't patent protected.

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

Of course! Let's hope Samsung didn't do that even if they did I ain't losing anything. Might even get a cheaper phone? :D

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

mmm did you hear about what happened to samsung galaxy nexus and the galaxy tab? :p

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

I also thought that the Galaxy is banned in the USA till this legal battle is done....?

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

:smack:

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

So we will soon find out who is the winner…the lawyers have already presented their closing arguments and now we are just awaiting the Jury’s decision on this case…

I actually feel nervous for Samsung :bummer: Paying $3 billion in damages is HUGE!!!

Source :

Epic Samsung-Apple patent battle goes to California jury - The Globe and Mail

Re: Apple seizes on Samsung internal document as proof of mimicry

billion has a lot of zeros.