Any Shia ppl on gs.

Bro I know but thats your scholars and their works, but Hisham b Hakam is during the time of 5th and 6th imams.He is much earlier than these scholars.

I think u r misunderstanding me as if the ideology of 12ers was formulated in the safavi times , that is not the case and I didnt mean to say that but the 12er becoming a state religion and its legal/political ramifications was formulated during this time.Esp the role of clergy in 12er shiaism and thats what the author talks about.