Answer to Modernism

[USResident]

Re: Answer to Modernism

@Fraudz

I dunno, I looked and found this info, it has the names and background of the ulema who drafted that Fatwa, and it does have Mr. Thanwi included in that

http://wahabi.8m.net/

the leading Imams and Jurists of Islam had no hesitation in declaring them as Kaffir, and warned in no uncertain terms that “ANY PERSONS WHO DOUBTS THE KUFR OF THESE PEOPLE WILL THEMSELVES BECOME KAFFIR”.
The names of the Ulama of Makka and Medina who issued the kufr fatwa on the Ulema of Deoband in 1320AH(1900 AD) are listed below. And for a detailed explanation of the fatwa read TAMHEED-E-IMAAN and MUSTATAAB HISAAM-UL-HARAMAIN ALAA MANHER-UL-KUFR WAL MAIN

ULAMA OF MAKKAH SHAREEF

1. Ustaad-e-Haram - Mufti Muhammad Saeed Shafe
   2 Sayedul Ulama - Moulana Mufti Sheikh Ahmed Abul Khair Mirdad
   3 Mufti Hanafia - Allama Sheihk Saleh Kamaal
2. Mufti - Sheikh Ali bin Siddiq Kamaal
3. Sheikud Dalail - Mufti Muhammed Abdul Haq Al-Mujahir Al-Llabadi
4. Mufti Sayed Ismail Khaleel - Librarian of Mecca
   7 Allama Mufti - Saeed Abul Hoosen Al-Marzuki

8 Mufti Sheikh Abid bin Husain Maaliki
9 Mufti Ali bin Husain Maaliki
10 Mufti Muhammed Jamaal bin Muhhamed Husain
11 Mufti Sheikh Asad bin Ahmed Daha -Teacher Haram Shareef Makkah
12 Mufti Sheikh Abdur Rahman Dahan
13 Mufti Sheikh Muhammed Yusuf Afghani
14 Mufti Sheikh Ahmed Al-Maaliki Al-Imdadi - Brother in Tariqat of Ashraf Ali Thanwi, Rashid Ahmed Gangohi and Khalil Ahmed Ambhetwi
15 Mufti Muhammed Yusuf Al-Khayaat
16 Sheikh Muhammed Saleh bin Muhammed Ba-fazal
17 Sheikh Abdul Karim Naji Dagistani
18 Sheikh Muhammed Saeed bin Muhhamed Al-Yamani
19. Mufti Sheikh Haamid Muhammed Al-Jadawi

ULAMA OF MEDINA SHAREEF
20 Mufti Hanafia - Tajuddin Liyas
21 Mufti of Madina - Allama Osman bin Abdus Salaam Dadistani
22 Sheikh-e-Maalikia - Mufti Sayed Ahmed of Algeria
23 Mufti Khaleel bin Ibrahim Karbooti
24 Shaikhud Dalail - Mufti Sayed Muhammed Saeed
25 Mufti Sheikh Mehmood bin Ahmed Omari
26 Shaikhud Dalail - Mufti Sayed Abbas bin Sayed Jaleel
27 Mufti Skeikh Omar bin Hamdaan Al-Maharasee
28 Mufti Sayed Hakeem Muhammed bin Muhaamed Madani
29 Mufti Sheikh Muhammed Kiyan - teacher Haram Shareef Madina
30 Mufti Shafaeiya - Allama Sayed Shareef Ahmed Barzanji
31 Mufti Muhammed Aziz Maaliki - of Tunisia
32 Mufti Sheikh Abdul Qader Taufeeq - Teacher Masjid-e-Nabawi Shareef

another link

This Page Was Not Found - raza.co.za

Well him too then. However it seems that South Asian scholars always seem to make the list of Kaafirs declared by Arab scholars. Never see that happening from South Asian scholars happening to Arab scholars.