amy, i am guessing you don't know arabic.
I like saying ameen during namaz, makes sense, sounds cool, especially in the haram. I don't think allah minds.
No one considers ameen to be a part of the surah. No one considers the kalma's or the niyyat to be part of the Qur'an either. you are confused.
[quote]
Originally posted by amy:
** Let me just clear the things one more time. I don't believe in any thing about the religion written by any human being. After the last sermon of the prophet, all messages from God have ended.
**
[/quote]
But Amy; why are you contradicting yourself. You just said you don't believe in religion (religious books) written by human beings.... then why are you believing in the last sermon which was written down in a number of Hadith by authors other than Allah or the Prophet????? Sheeeesh get your line straigth!
this shows that “amy” is posing as a muslim and hence no need to continue any furthur…
amy......there isn't any fabrication in Quran and Hadit
Actual fabrication is you yourself.
You are not new, we have dealt very well people like you.
Actually you are a fabricated child of your mother.....got it
[quote]
Originally posted by amy:
**Majority of muslims when they recite surah Al-Fatiha, in the end they loudly say " Ameen" Where did this garbage come from? Who added this word to the end of this surah? Another example of contamination of the religion by these dirty, foul smelling, ill-mannered, illiterate and in some cases blind, self proclaimed custodians of Islam.
**
[/quote]
No one has the original content of the last sermon. It has been corrupted by everyone according to their own needs and propaganda. Prophet will not say anything that's against the word of God. So the content of the alst sermon should be left as it is and go back to quran. The original content of the sermon has been changed, just look around and see, you'll find many variations of it around the globe.
Punjabi Kurhi
All those who are making personnal attacks, my email is applicable to you too.
Punjabi Kurhi
What I want to know is that; why is this heretic(amy) still roaming the forums of Gupshup after her dirty, ill-minded, showing her true self emails?
Amy
So you've finally answered the question.
You do not believe that the Last Sermon took place.
Very cunning, as acceptance would of thrown your false stance against A'Hadeeth out of the window.
However, you are not as smart as you think.
Your denial of the Sermon indicates that the Qur'aan is not complete and Prophet PBUH had not finished his 'job' as of yet. Therefore the Qur'aan that you refer to every 10 seconds is not in it's original format.
It's time you made your mind up.
Which side of the fence are you on now!
Finally, which Muslim tribe does the name Amanda Davies derive from!
I have always considered it part of the Sunnah of AnHazoor (saw) and his Sahabas. Do you consider it otherwise?
Do you have a theory of when and where this "Ameen" was added?
Sermon did take place but the copy you posted is corrupt. No one has the original copy.
Punjabi Kurhi
Amy
How do you actually know that the Sermon took place.
Please elaborate.
Oh the pressure, oh the pain.
http://www3.pak.org/gupshup/smilies/hehe.gif
She must have a good answer for this bro!
Let me guess, I know it took place becuase it is in Authentic Ahaadeeth books.
Amy, your engine will soon run out of steam, or it has already?
same way that you know.
Punjabi Kurhi