Another attempt at NWFP name change..

[Saifullah_1]

Re: Another attempt at NWFP name change..

@PaKpatriot1

I live in America, and even though I came from Pakistan, I would still perfer to live in America. Just because you came from someplace doesnt mean you want to go back to that place. I mean there was a reason you left to begin with..
But emotions and sentiment aside, given the state of Afghaistan today, do you really think Pashtuns want to join Afghanistan?
But then you also have to recall that Pashtuns weren’t forced to join Pakistan, they choose to do so.
Honestly, I think Pakistan has been good to Pashtuns in general. Pakistan gave them refuge from the war, supported them to get rid of the Russians, and have provided Pashtuns the oppurtunities that they wouldnt have gotten otherwise had they been in Afghanistan.

Firstly i would like to say what LOGO said is brilliant and he gave a good explanation of everything.

Now migration to a foreign country has nothing to do with the issue we are talking about. did anybody tell you america should join Pakistan? so how is that the same as saying NWFP should join afghanistan? i dont know why you confuse things. NWFP is full of pashtuns (being majority), it is their land…it is not a foreign land. if Pashtuns decide to join Afghanistan, it wont be that they migrate all to afghanistan, but the land like NWFP along with it. Leaving a place, doesnt mean people have the right to grab your land. you telling me when you left Pakistan, a person in Pakistan takes half of your land, and grabs it…you say ok i am happy i am in america i dont care?

Pashtuns were not asked to join Afghanistan or Pakistan, they were asked to join India or Pakistan!!! The durrand line wasnt signed by pashtun people being asked, so its all illegal!

Pakistan has done good to Pashtuns? they gained a lot from the afghan war, by stealing what was destined for the poor country Afghanistan, they stole their weapons, the generals gained billions of dollars, they gained a lot from the misery of others…yet they will always say oh well we gave refuge to Afghans?? Afghans around 1-2 million died fighting russians (may Allah grant them paradise), and this meant russia was not on the borders of Pakistan. Pakistan should be grateful for what Afghans did…and who were the main supporters against the russians??? it ended up being NWFP once again, pashtun areas (not to be against other non-pashtuns, may Allah grant them reward for their efforts in anything good they did)…and yes no doubt normal Pakistanis a lot of them have done good, treated people well, etc…but on the other hand you cannot deny the bad, such as exploiting people, not helping for the sake of Allah but ‘for personal interest’…a true friend is not one who cares about himself (selfishness), but does good to you for sake of Allah. We read what the intention of Pakistan was during soviet era, and most it was for strategic interests, that russia dont come to Pakistan, they didnt care if afghans were butchered, they wanted a foothold in Afghanistan, once again not caring about afghans, but ONLY themselves…so dont tell me Pakistan was so kind they loved Afghans, and did everything for them. we saw their true colours after 9/11.

Pakistan never made taliban, and Pakistan never destroyed taliban..it destroyed itself!!! Pakistan is dreaming if it could make a movement, they were so scared when america came to them, yet if taliban were made by Pakistan they would have also been scared like their ‘creator’…but no they were not..

Also study the taliban movement, and you will see that really it wasnt made up of all pashtuns, there was many ethnic minorities involved with them.