Re: An educational thread on the differences between Pakistanis and neighbouring popu
roadrunner:
What a joke. All the maps such as Guha and Eickelstadt (which I’ve posted, but you’ve evidently failed to see), point to the majority of India being Graziloindide or some other Dravidian group. There’s plenty more maps like them around. They all show what we already know. That India is prdominatly Dravidian. The maps on Pakistan all point to the majroty being Nordindide which is basically an Aryan group. They are two seperate populations, different people, different ancestries.
Pakistan has between 35-45% R1a1. India does not have 15% R1a1 (r12a is?). R1a1 is present in India perhaps in about 10% of the population (though this is probably an overestimate as nothing conclusive has been produced for India, except the map on the first page), the majority of India is H, J2 or R2. Arabs do not contain R1a1 either. Do try and follow what’s going on. R1a1 does not go straight West of Pakistan in any big numbers.
The amount of yellow in the India map doesnt look anything near like the amount of yellow as in Pakistan and the id & proportions of the haplogroups are completely different to Pakistan’s also.
Pakistan
India
It’s been proven that Pakistan has 45% R1a1, India has around 10% maybe (nothing conclusive on this). Most likely Azerbaijan has more R1a1 than India. The upper castes in India do seem to have more R1a1 but nothing conclusive here either.
This looks like a mess. Can’t follow this.
Did not quote any MtDNA. All is Y-chromosomal.
But I’ll come onto MtDNA..Indian MtDNA is very Indian, and is different from Pakistani MtDNA.
The Dravidian genes are spread all over India. People migrate all over. The NorthWest of India is the most Aryan part of India, which is predominantly Dravidian, especially in the South.
mt dna analaysis is in your referances that you gave. The numbers I quote are also in the references that i gave. The map that you showed is in German and I have no idea what it is you are talking about. besides you are comparing apples and oranges. On one hand you are analysing a dna which has markers for time in memorial and other case you are talking about the tribal populations in these places.