Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

Who is the good actor between, Amitabh Bachan, Shahrukh Khan & Nana Patekar.

I would say Nana Patekar. He is the best. He can really act. :slight_smile:

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

Nana is awesome.

He fits his roles like gloves despite whatever it is he is potraying as a character.

Amitabh is versatile too but I dont see him playing Nana in Taxi 9211

You forgot Naseeruddin Shah.

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

You forgot Aamir Khan if it is the poll of best actors.

Out of these three,
Amitabh, SRK, Nana

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

SRK is only a superstar he cannt be a actor.

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

You must only choose from those three. :D

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

LB is right. Nana is great.
But I don't see Nana in a leading role as a romantic hero.

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

nana patekar.
sorry sharukh khan is so plastic sometimes. and if i watch another movie with mr bachan in it i will scream.

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

I like Nana Patekar along with Naseeruddin Shah and Atul Kulkarni.

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

there are only three "actors" in bollywood:

Amitabh
Nana Patekar
Naseerudin shah

it is difficult to rank them, as they have unique styles. i would say the one who i have most frequently paused to think "man, this guy is an incredible actor" would be Nana.

it is a crime to include the likes of Shahrukh Khan in this list.

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

10/10 ....

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

:chai:
waiting

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

:chai:
waiting
n
waiting

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

He will still end up being one of the best in the history of Bollywood, i don't know how many people will remember Naseerudin and Nana after 5-10 years (i m not saying they are bad actors) unlike Amitabh and SRK.

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

of course he will be remembered in the future, but he will never be remembered as a good actor.

shahrukh will be remembered as a superstar who dominated bollywood for more than a decade…but definitely not for acting abilities.

neither nana patekar nor naseerudin shah are stars…but they are known specifically for acting abilities.

amitabh is both a superstar and a good actor…but then again, he is the one and only amitabh bachchan.

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

I am a bit confused here, how did SRK become a star without being a good actor??? don't tell me because of his looks because he is just OK, he is not there because of his contacts or parents either so how can anyone walk in and become a star like SRK????

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

I agree with u :k: & how could he become the king of bollywood if he cant act? :snooty:

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

u make all the right moves. marry a hindu, make friends with those that sponsor award shows, steer clear of major scandals and affairs, have a very humble yet energetic personality and choose your commercial films well.

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

because he has been a very likeable entertainer and showman…people think he has a lot of charisma and star quality.

like i said, there is no necessary correlation between these attributes and acting abilities…even hollywood has plenty of examples of crappy actors that are well-known stars.

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

Nana pathekar can only do villan type of roles..

shahrukh and amitaab... best... both are great...

amir has done great work as well... its funny how few years ago no one bothered asking who he was

anil kapoor was good in his times.. but not anymore..

Re: Amitabh vs Nana Patekar vs Shahrukh

Naseerudin shah is best.. out of these 3’s :emmy: