Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

This is an interview on USA Today with Mahmud Ali Durrani, Pakistan’s ambassador to the United States.
The whole interview can be found at the link below. But I mostly wanted to know the views of you all to this question below in bold. Some other interesting points are also pasted here.

Q: Is democracy dead in Pakistan? President Musharraf has promised to relinquish his role as general. Will he?
**A: He will take off his uniform at an appropriate stage. Democracy is not dead in Pakistan. Some democratic institutions have been improved. Musharraf has developed a system of basic democracies, a devolution plan. People have been empowered at that level to make their own decisions, including financial. Despite all the criticism, the press is more free than ever. There is a robust opposition in the Parliament. Our democracy has never been better. **

http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/2007-05-22-oplede_N.htm?csp=34

In the wake of the 9/11 terrorist attacks, Pakistan became a crucial ally in the U.S. global war on terror, providing essential support in battling the Taliban in Afghanistan and targeting Islamic extremists in the region. In return, the United States has provided $10 billion in aid as well as expanded relations afforded to the closest allies. Nonetheless, Osama bin Laden — believed to be hiding along the Pakistan-Afghanistan border — is still at large while the Taliban has seen a resurgence. Pakistan has thousands of madrassas — Islamic schools that often teach extremist, anti-Western messages. And opinion polls show that many Pakistanis sympathize with terrorists such as bin Laden. The extremist strain is all the more troubling because Pakistan owns nuclear weapons, has a vulnerable government and a history of letting its nuclear secrets fall into the wrong hands. The instability has been on display in the past few weeks, as suicide attacks and violent protests followed the controversial firing of the country’s top judge. Mahmud Ali Durrani, Pakistan’s ambassador to the United States, discussed these and other issues with USA TODAY’s editorial board. His comments were edited for length and clarity.

Q: Pakistan and India are very similar countries, but India is powering ahead economically. Do you see a similar future possible for Pakistan?
A: Is India modern in a way? Yes. Even in Pakistan, they make these comparisons. They say India is a role model in many ways. In democracy, it’s a role model. In economic development, it is a role model. As a secular state, it has fallen off and is not a role model. But we hope that some day Pakistan will beat them in both of these things.

Q: What is Khan’s status?
A: He is under house arrest.

Q: Literally?
A: Oh, absolutely, totally, completely. He can’t run around. There’s no way. We do keep getting some information from here and there, and we’ve shared almost every bit of information (with the United States).

Q: Has there been a U.S. interrogation of Khan?
A: No direct, no direct (interrogation) because (Khan) is unfortunately a national hero. Otherwise, we would have strung him from the tallest tree.

Q: What has been the effect of nuclear weapons on India and Pakistan relations broadly?
A: Very fundamental. There is almost zero possibility for war between Pakistan and India. No. 2, the major overtures toward peace between Pakistan and India are because of nuclear weapons. Leadership in both countries has realized that if we go to war that is going to destroy us.

Re: A 'worrisome' time in Pakistan

Worrisome time indeed.

Is India a role model for Pakistan?

India has come in for praise from an unexpected quarter. Pakistan’s envoy to the US has described India as “modern” and a “role model” in democracy and economic development.

In an interview to USA Today, Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani, a retired Major General , also said had disgraced Pakistani nuclear scientist A Q Khan not been “a national hero”, “we would have strung him from the tallest tree”.

Conceding that people of Pakistan saw India differently, he said: “Is India modern in a way? Yes. Even in Pakistan, they make these comparisons… In democracy, it (India) is a role model. In economic development, it is a role model. As a secular state, it has fallen off and is not a role model. But we hope that some day Pakistan will beat them in both of these things.”

Told that India and Pakistan were similar countries, Durrani had a ready explanation of “two fatal flaws” that brought his country down.

Pakistan, he said, did not have a political leadership as “well-developed” as India’s in 1947. India also had the “good fortune of having a narrow family leadership guiding that country for 30 years,” he said. If Pakistan had had that kind of leadership, “we would have been the same because we are very similar people”.

On the violence in Karachi and concern that this could mark the beginning of a period of political instability, Durrani admitted it was “worrisome”.

“I’m concerned this could unhinge a lot of the progress that we’ve made in our economy. Even that it could undermine democracy,” he said.

Q: Pakistan and India are very similar countries, but India is powering ahead economically. Do you see a similar future possible for Pakistan?

A: Is India modern in a way? Yes. Even in Pakistan, they make these comparisons. They say India is a role model in many ways. In democracy, it’s a role model. In economic development, it is a role model. As a secular state, it has fallen off and is not a role model. But we hope that some day Pakistan will beat them in both of these things.

http://blogs.usatoday.com/oped/2007/05/a_worrisome_tim.html

Re: Is India a role model for Pakistan?

so?

we accept India is a democracy and a surging economy. we are happy for them.

Re: Is India a role model for Pakistan?

Danada, pehle kuchch banne do Indoa ko, then go around throwing your weight. A country where one third of the population lives below the poverty line can be a role model for no one. Certainly not Pakistan!

Re: Is India a role model for Pakistan?

In total 80% of Indians live under a $2 a day. 33% under $1...absolute poverty as per UN.

Re: Is India a role model for Pakistan?

I don't know who these fools want to inspire with this kind of rhetorics...

No-one should be above the law, neither the ex-ministers nor the current rulers and nor the so-called national heroes. And nobody wanted to hang him on the tallest tree, only the punishment that is given for such a crime according to the pakistani law would 've been enough...

And what the retired MG didn't say in this interview is that in India the army doesn't interfere in the politics and never derailed the evolving democratic process and this is the main reason for India's political and economic stability.

Re: Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

The Mushy government cannot punish AQ Khan is that they can't, because if they did the real truth about the General would come out.

Re: Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

You can keep counting the numbers. In the mean time India will improve more and then it will become impossible for Pakistan to catch up.
I agree with shawaiz_K's statement "And what the retired MG didn't say in this interview is that in India the army doesn't interfere in the politics and never derailed the evolving democratic process and this is the main reason for India's political and economic stability."

Re: Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

What audacity…:mad:
The nura kushti that Pakistan played in making AQ Khan the scapegoat was pathetic and now this slime is saying he would have been hanged.

Plus on the main question, what do expect from a military pet.

Re: Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

Yeah we can wait until the cows come home or until then, I'd suggest you speak for now right at this moment, And for that I can provide year 2006 World Bank report if you interested.

We know the paradise please keep it to yourself we are happy with our hell or whatever that is.

Re: Is India a role model for Pakistan?

then check with durrani

Re: Is India a role model for Pakistan?

which century you are living in, come out of your stone age period live in reality

Re: Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

:yawn:…these kinda threads will only lead to one thing:D

Re: Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

First of all...Thanks to Allah...

Seond of all...has anybody seen the massive T-top, unibrow on that iligitimate child of Mush...Durrani the Ambassador...if anything, this numbnut should be strung by his unibrow...

Re: Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

Bhai itne khafa kyon ho...

Re: Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

Not khafa but extremly jealous!!! happy now :)

Re: Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

My happiness is not dependent on you being jealous, because if it was, then it would be temporary or rather fake happiness.
I would never want you to be khafa or jealous.

Re: Ambassador Mahmud Ali Durrani (merged)

^ what ever makes you happy! happy now :)

Re: Is India a role model for Pakistan?

Clown, those are IMF stats. The list with source in on wiki.