Re: Am I right in thinking this is classed as shirk?
^^ May be u have not heard the Hadees Qudsi . Allah said " O Prophet(pbuh), I would have not made this Universe if you had not there "
May be u also forgot the Hadees of Prophet(pbuh) " whoever sends me Durood, I myself listen to it "
There are hundreds of Sufia in isllamic history who used to see, talk, and learn Quran from Prophet(phuh). Sufia of Awaisia Naqsbandi still use to ask any misconception about any hadees from the Soul of Prophet(pbuh)
But ignorant people who have not this ability and status, usually ask questions like these " who is not present ? "
A very disrecpectful and insulting way to say something about Prophet(pbuh) , who is not present, do u know the status of " Who" ?