RC -- Please reply to my post in this thread.
OK
Following is from closed thread.
You look mature but you are acting like children. Every Muslim knows that Prophet SAW is the most dearest to Allah. Now please explain your stand on Quranic verses presented.
Glad to know you agree with the FACT that:
Rasool Allah Mohammad (SA, PBUH) Allah kay mehboob hein aur Aaj tak koi insaan (prophet or not, including Mirza saab) aisa paida nahi hua jo Rasool Allah Mohammad (SA,PBUH) kay jooton ki khaak kay barabar bhi ho...
I thought I present Tafseer of the Ayat as well so you dont have any ambugity left at all.
Recite VerseOpen in new windowGo to quran page { فَإِذَاقَضَيْتُمْمَّنَاسِكَكُمْفَٱذْكُرُواْٱللَّهَكَذِكْرِكُمْآبَآءَكُمْأَوْأَشَدَّذِكْراًفَمِنَٱلنَّاسِمَنيَقُولُرَبَّنَآآتِنَافِيٱلدُّنْيَاوَمَالَهُفِيٱلآخِرَةِمِنْخَلاَقٍ } (And when ye have completed your devotions) upon finishing the rites of your pilgrimage, (then remember Allah) say: O Allah! (as ye remember your fathers) as you say: father! It is also said that this means: remember Allah for the blessings He showered on you as you used to remember the kindness of your fathers in the pre-Islamic era (or with a more lively remembrance) remember Him more than you used to remember your fathers. (But of mankind is he who saith) on the standing site: (“Our Lord! Give unto us in the world,) camels, cows, sheep, male and female slaves and wealth” (and he hath no portion in the Hereafter) of Paradise by performing the pilgrimage. Source: Altafsir.com - The Tafsirs - ÇáÊÝÇÓíÑ
First off, everyone can write a book of Tafseer (it has become a business now-a-days) based on whatever beliefs/knowledge he/she has. There are no qualifying standards for authoring this kind of material. I don't know (and don't want to know) who this tafseer is from, what is his background etc.
Secondly, there are authenticity issues of any writing coming from an Ahmadi because it's a universally known fact that Jammat-e-Ahmadiya has in the past changed/altered Ahadees and Quran and their interpretation to cover-up Mirza saab's blunders of his dream world...
Thirdly, even if what you presented above is authentic, I know with certainty that none of us on this forum is qualified or trained or have deep enough knowledge of Quran to intelligently discuss this issue without unknowingly disrespecting Quran etc.
I know as an Ahmadi, you are allowed by your Jammat and you don't care to say anything be it against Quran and Ahadees to defend aimlessly Mirza saab's 'dimaghi ikhtra' but as a Muslim, I am scared of Allah of saying something that may go against the teaching of Prophet Mohammad (SA, PBUH)
You or anyone can't justify what Mirza saab professed and still stay within the bounds of Islam.
You have spent too much time on the first fact (you call it allegation), lets move on to others that I presented in other thread unless you need me to list them all in this thread again ...
RC