All time Asian XI (a cricinfo survey)

CricInfo announces star-stuffed line up for BT-sponsored All Time Asian XI
Ralph Dellor reports

Users of the world’s number one cricket web site, CricInfo, have been voting in their thousands to select an All Time Asian XI in a survey sponsored by BT Talk and Surf Together.

What an array of talent was available for selection! Just imagine being a selector and having the opportunity to pick a side containing some of the great names of world cricket.

That was the mouth-watering prospect for entrants in the survey who have come up with the following selection:

**

  1. Sunil Gavaskar,
  2. Saeed Anwar,
  3. Sachin Tendulkar,
  4. Javed Miandad,
  5. Aravinda de Silva,
  6. Imran Khan,
  7. Wasim Akram,
  8. Kapil Dev,
  9. Wasim Bari,
  10. Waqar Younis,
  11. Muttiah Muralitharan
    **

The selection transcends national boundaries in that those who completed the survey did not simply chose players of their own nationality. They appreciated cricketing ability whatever country they came from. That is how there are six Pakistanis, three Indians and two Sri Lankans in the final eleven.

When it came to Bangladeshis, Aminul Islam was considered by CricInfo users to be closest of the current Bangladesh side to making the team.

It is difficult to fault the judgement of CricInfo’s users. Sunil Gavaskar is one of the all time greats of the game - technical perfection and limitless concentration in a small but mighty package. As an opening partner, Saeed Anwar has the ability to play a match-winning innings against any opposition.

There is no denying the number three spot to Sachin Tendulkar, while Javed Miandad has a wonderful record and Aravinda de Silva is still adding to his. Imagine the strokes from this middle-order trio following on from the openers!

It does not stop there. Wasim Bari’s wicket-keeping was peerless. Rated by his colleagues as the best, that assessment came from fellow wicket-keepers of the first rank.

In Wasim Akram and Imran Khan you have two of the finest all-rounders to grace the game. Both have had the added responsibility of captaincy and have shown that they can handle it, unlike some of the other outstanding players of their time.

The same could be said for Kapil Dev who is chosen primarily as a bowler, but one who could wield the bat with devastating effect. The same might not be said of Waqar Younis, about whom there can be no doubts about his right to be in the final team.

The record of Muttiah Muralitharan speaks for itself. There are some who have questioned the legality of his action, and some who still do, but he has overcome all those problems to emerge as one of the great wicket-takers in the game and still has plenty of time to establish himself at the very top of the list.

If there is any doubt about the quality of the selected eleven, just look at some of the names that could not make it. Men like Majid Khan, Ravi Shastri, Inzamam-ul-Haq, Zaheer Abbas, Hanif Mohammad, Farokh Engineer, Abdul Qadir, Bishen Bedi, Javagal Srinath, Bhagwat Chandrasekhar and Chaminda Vaas could not make the team.

Come to think of it, that is not a bad alternative eleven to take on the chosen side!

Is your team a bit different ??
Can Asian All time “B” team beat Asian all time “A” ??

quite right:)

An Asian B side excluding the players pciked would be far weaker-the batting may be excellent still, but the bowlers really would not match up to those in the first team.

Asian B team:

1) Amanarth
2) Majid Khan
3) Hanif Mohammed
4) Dravid
5) Inzamam
6) Viswanath
7) Kirmani+
8) Chaminda Vass
9) Abdul Qadir
10) Sami
11) Shoaib Akhtar

Or something to that effect, maybe a tad different, its far far weaker then the 1st side. The A team too doesnt meet entirely the one I'd pick-I'd drop Aravinda for Inzi firstly, and likely scrap Dev for another spinner or out and out batsman-Dravid for instance.

Who is this Karim as your Wicket Keeper ?

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Asif_k: *
Who is this Karim as your Wicket Keeper ?
[/QUOTE]

Probably, he meant Saba Karim, Indian Wicket Keeper.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by mo_best: *
An Asian B side excluding the players pciked would be far weaker-the batting may be excellent still, but the bowlers really would not match up to those in the first team.

Asian B team:

1) Amanarth
2) Majid Khan
3) Hanif Mohammed
4) Dravid
5) Inzamam
6) Viswanath
7) Karim+
8) Chaminda Vass
9) Abdul Qadir
10) Sami
11) Shoaib Akhtar

Or something to that effect, maybe a tad different, its far far weaker then the 1st side. The A team too doesnt meet entirely the one I'd pick-I'd drop Aravinda for Inzi firstly, and likely scrap Dev for another spinner or out and out batsman-Dravid for instance.
[/QUOTE]

Amarnath as opener,
Karim in 2nd best Asian teaml ahead of Kirmani,moin.latif,mongia,kalu

Sami & Shoib as bowlers in ASIA B team when they arent sure in there playing eleven...

Hummmmmmmmmmm ..makes me wonder if you really know cricket.

but hey..its your choice...you can have Imran Nazir and Deep Dasgupta as your opener.

That karim is a typo-I meant Kirmani of India, I am sure I typed that-obviously not. I dont rate India’s new crop of wkt kprs-not an atoms worth.

As for the bowlers, who do you suggest-Srinath and Chetan Sharma? :hehe:

Shoaib is a auto-pick for the 2nd X1-he’s a match winning opening fast bowler, he can run through a side-same with Sami. I picked them as they have real pace-and with the 3 great Asian pacemen already picked, it makes it very hard to find a match winning seamer outside Shoaib and another Pakistani quick-pick any one who want!

Do you duggest we pack the side with Saqlian, Kumble and Bedi, and play a 4 man spin attack-idiot-the 2nd X1 indicates the lack of depth in Asian bowling historically, bar Pakistan the other teams have and are continuing to produce pea-shooters.

Good to see half of the team consist of Pakistanies :k: :k: :k:

Your Honour !! I want the Pappu Chakkar from my Jhopadpatti to be picked in the B team too. He is the fastest I have ever seen. He starts his run up from the Boundry line and throws his ball at speed no human can imagine.
Of course he over steps, bowls wides at least 5 times in one over.

**Like ppl care what you want :hehe: **

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Asif_k: *
Your Honour !! I want the Pappu Chakkar from my Jhopadpatti to be picked in the B team too. He is the fastest I have ever seen. He starts his run up from the Boundry line and throws his ball at speed no human can imagine.
Of course he over steps, bowls wides at least 5 times in one over.
[/QUOTE]

Last time I saw Pappu Chakkar he went outside the stadium to start his run up. Hasn't been seen since. :)

Of course the B side is 6/11 Pakistanis, even the A team is so heavily tilted towards Pakistani players. We are without the only Asian team to be a cricketing power of sorts historically.

I mean the players that consistitute India and SRL alltime sides, bowling side, are not worthy to play test cricket in most sides, and to even contemplate putting them in an Asian X1 of any fiscription (bar Asia's X1 biggest jokers to play tests) in embarresing.

Lets keep the discussion to the thread and not to B and C sides.

This XI was picked long time ago by cricinfo users.