Re: Ali a.s or mavia
i have heard that too .... they have the notion that since Ali [as] was the ONLY son-in-law of Prophet [saw] he was the legitimate successor ,these people elevate Fatima to a level greater than Ali and almost to the level of the prophet...some also say she was given a book by Angel gabreial as well....thats the reason partly why some shia scholars have failed to mention the other daughters of the Prophet. why is this such an issue ? didnt the Prophet say that even if Fatima commits theft i will strike off her hand ? who is greater the principles of islam or personalities ?
personally i think being married to Fatima[as] was one of the many merits of Ali but that was WAY down the list .....and certainly not a factor why I personally think he was the successor to the Prophet ...this might be a merit for someone who had little else to his credit ....but i dont care if Ali married one daughter or all 4 ...the man had FAR better reasons to be made a caliph than this .....
When was it abt khilafat .... I have never heared it the way u said, There was no match for Jinab-e-Zehra but Imam Ali a.s ... And she was the first lady who spoke up for Imam. He is not a cliph or Imam coz he Married bibi Fatima s.a, he is caliph or Imam coz ALLAH appointed him, thats a different topic.
Rasool s.a.w daughter is (or in ur case daughters were) syed and sadqa is haram on her ( and in ur case them ) how wud she live with a husband who has sadqa halal on him ? that will lead us to another topic too
Rasool s.a.w Is the most Aadil person u can talk about .... If he had four daughters then how come more love for Fatima s.a and less for others ... Justice wud be if all get same love and Look at Prophet s.a.w when he leaves Fatima s.a is the last person he meets and when come backs she is the first person Rasool s.a.w meets, and then He calls Fatima s.a sons his sons, what abt other grandsons ? and when goes to mobahila only takes Fatima s.a with him wat about other three daughters !
Am sure u have heard the hadith where Rasool s.a.w declares whoever Angers Fatima s.a angers me and who ever angers me angers ALLAH ! i still dont see why only bibi Zehra s.a ?
conclusion is simple >>> she was the only one :)
A son is naimat for parents and daughter is rehmat
Rasool s.a.w is Rehmat ul lil alameen and look at *Bibi Zehra she is Rehmat for Rehmat ul lil alameen *
A wife is half Imaan of man!
am sure at least u wud agree that Imam Ali is kul Iman ...
Imam ali is kul Imaan and his Half Iman is Bi Zehra s.a
Jannat lies under the feet of a Mother
Imam Hassan a.s and Imam Hussain a.s are sardaars of jannah and there jannat lies under feet of Bibi Fatima s.a
The way u talk abt her, u seem to under estimate her.... the Religion i follow leads me to a conclusion u cant be a Imam until you are from Fatima s.a and Ali a.s