Ali a.s or mavia

[aqeel123]

Re: Ali a.s or mavia

@AllahkaBanda

bro aqeel, i wan to thank you for bringing up your argument, over and over again, that when two fight one has to be wrong. alhamdulillah, while i was trying to find an answer for you i came up with an example which i’ll use to debunk Islamic haters’ arguments. anyhow

Your argument does not work in all the cases and hence it falls under the rhetorical logical fallacies: hasty conclusion & stereotyping.
Here is an example for you to understand this better

Person A: That glass of water is half empty
Person B: That glass of water is half full

Are they both wrong? The answer is no because the glass is half full and half empty and if either one says one, they both are correct and neither their statements contradict each other.

I hope you get what i’m trying to say here

lol … both of them are saying same thing. its a differnt way of giving same answer! … my fathers youngest kid’s name is XYZ … my youngest brothers name is XYZ…
If my younger bro and my young cousin are arguing abt it .. i wud be able to stop them and tell them … Guys u r sayin the same thing ! and u r tellin me the guy with the most knowledge after Rasool s.a.w didnt know other person was saying same thing in a different way ! thats where sunni shia aqeeda changes … You Forget greatness of Ali
And if the people we r following were dumb enough to have 72 wars for something thats not even worth discussing … then in the case where both are rite and both are wrong none shld be followed
and if one is rite other is wrong ,then u guys can decide