Aid for Sri Lanka a geopolitical game

Seems like Bharati government is lacking necessary expertise to handle this catastrophe.

here is the news:

http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml?type=worldNews&storyID=7218126

Anger Rises as Does Toll in Remote Indian Islands
Sun Jan 2, 2005 11:34 AM ET

By Sanjeev Miglani and Suresh Seshadri
PORT BLAIR, India (Reuters) - Tempers flared over the sluggish pace of aid efforts in India’s remote and restricted Andamans and Nicobars on Sunday as hundreds of bodies lay scattered around the islands a week after the tsunami struck.

Local authorities said a local government officer was manhandled by people angry at not getting relief supplies in Campbell Bay, the main town in the southernmost island of Great Nicobar, where widespread devastation has been reported.

Police had to send reinforcements.

“The situation in Campbell Bay in Great Nicobar is very grim,” a senior island administration official told Reuters in Port Blair, the region’s capital city.

The top army general in the region who is coordinating relief efforts said 400 villagers still remained stranded on a hilltop in the island on the southernmost tip of the archipelago, where they fled to escape the waves.

“I admit that some areas south of Campbell Bay are still marooned but we have now reached all those who are marooned by air dropping food and other supplies and more than 200 people have been evacuated by helicopters,” Lt. Gen. B.S. Thakur said.

The chain of more than 500 islands, most of them uninhabited, lie 800 miles east off the Indian mainland, and have a couple of military airbases located on them.

MISTRUST OF OUTSIDERS

Also home to hundreds of stone age tribespeople, many of the islands are off limits to foreigners and mainland Indians alike.

Mistrust of outsiders by the military and local bureaucracy has compounded the practical difficulties of the aid effort.

Aid workers from foreign relief groups Medicins Sans Frontieres and Oxfam have languished in Port Blair, unable to reach the badly hit southern islands.

Indian Christian groups complain local officials were hindering their attempts to take aid to the tribes, many of whom are Christian.

“We have been sitting here in Port Blair trying to send a 100 volunteers … to Car Nicobar and other badly hit islands,” said Sudipta Roy, program director at the Church of North India, an umbrella organization for churches in northern India.

“But the administration is refusing to allow us access to some regions and this is extremely frustrating.”

Local officials said the question of allowing international aid agencies access to the worst-hit southern islands was a decision that could only be made by the federal government.

Lt. Gen. Thakur said, however, there was no attempt to deny foreign nationals access for reasons of national security.

“There is no such rationale that is stated per se,” he said. “We have taken the foreign media to Car Nicobar even today.”

Authorities in New Delhi say there are 812 confirmed deaths in the entire chain but India’s army chief told reporters that in the worst-hit island of Car Nicobar alone, more than 1,000 corpses lay scattered.

India raised its tsunami toll to 14,488 dead or feared dead on Sunday including 5,421 missing on the islands.

Most islands can only be reached by sea but last Sunday’s monster waves destroyed jetties. Rescue workers have been using small boats to land, but many inland roads are not cleared.

“GHOST VILLAGES”

Authorities say they are getting their act together.

“The momentum is picking up slowly. There are difficulties, bodies have to be spotted, identified,” Army Chief N.C. Vij told reporters. The army is using sniffer dogs to find victims.

Authorities have started vaccinating survivors against cholera, typhoid and tetanus.

“The main concern remains the threat of epidemic and the process of removing bodies continues,” said Brigadier J.M. Devados, the overall relief commander for the Car Nicobar island where thousands are dead or missing.

“Twelve of 15 villages have been washed away. Villages are ghost villages.”

Sitting astride vital trade routes heading west from the straits of Malacca, the islands offer India a vital foothold in southeast Asia and a counter to Chinese influence in the region.

Ruled directly from New Delhi, the islands housed a notorious jail during British colonial rule. Even today, critics say the welfare of locals is low on New Delhi’s priorities.

“Times have changed but not mindsets,” the Indian Express wrote on Sunday.

“The Andaman and Nicobar archipelago is a collective second class citizen. Welcome to India’s in-house colony,” it said.

But amid the palpable grief, there were a few moments of joy.

In the Andamans, a couple and their six-month-old baby lived off coconut water for three days before a military helicopter rescued them.

(For more news about emergency relief visit Reuters AlertNet http://www.alertnet.org email: [email protected]; +44 207 542 2432)

(Additional reporting by Kamil Zaheer in New Delhi)

India’s decision not to accept aid now hailed

India’s decision not to accept aid now hailed

By Vaiju Naravane

PARIS JAN. 3. India’s decision not to accept international aid, initially criticised as being “false or misplaced pride,” is now being grudgingly saluted by the press and the international community.

The French right wing daily Le Figaro in its Monday edition wrote: “Overall, India has managed the crisis well. … Better, India has used the catastrophe to affirm its status as a regional superpower. Candidate for a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council, India has proved that it is not dependant on international aid, which India has refused, politely but firmly. Better still, India will, on January 6 in Jakarta, sit at the donors’ table in the company of the USA, Japan and Australia.”

The communist daily l’Humanite also criticised India’s decision to refuse aid and sought explanations from India’s ambassador to France, Dilip Lahiri. In substance, the Indian Ambassador thanked French citizens for their generosity but said the country was strong enough to look after its own. “If we find there are inadequacies, we shall not hesitate to call on the international community for help,” Mr. Lahiri said. For the moment, he added, not only was India facing up to the crisis but also helping its neighbours, Sri Lanka and the Maldives.

India’s decision to belong to the four-nation “core group” led by the United States has also given rise to speculation that India had been co-opted into an “aid coalition” that attempted to usurp the leadership role of the United Nations in disaster relief in favour of the U.S. That sense of outrage has now somewhat faded, with the U.S. Navy pressing actively into service in Indonesia and elsewhere. In the race to be among the most generous, the French who have now been bypassed by Sweden are, however, consoling themselves with their role as the European Union’s aid coordinator. The bitterness generated by the Iraq war between France and the U.S. persists and has spilled over into who should lead the reconstruction battle in Asia.

http://www.hindu.com/2005/01/04/stories/2005010411391300.htm

Re: Anger against Bharati govt. Rises as Does Toll in Remote Indian Islands

aik to loog aisay he free ho jatay hain

Re: Anger against Bharati govt. Rises as Does Toll in Remote Indian Islands

kon say log…

Re: Anger against Bharati govt. Rises as Does Toll in Remote Indian Islands

oh bhai aik khaber char dafa par ker maza ah gya

India’s tasteless fears over perceived US global designs

US-India struggle for control in disaster zone
Colombo, Jan. 3 (Reuters): Sri Lanka’s tsunami devastation has drawn a huge international aid response, but a geopolitical game of influence between India and the US is playing not too subtly in the background, analysts said today.

**“Are the Marines going to stay in Sri Lanka? Is this part of the US global design? Is this an opportunity for US President George W. Bush to get a foothold in Sri Lanka?” he asked rhetorically, adding: “Humanitarian (aid) is not purely humanitarian.” **

http://www.telegraphindia.com/1050104/asp/nation/story_4209890.asp

Really, should the Indian government be hindering aid in this manner at a time like this, it’s diabolical! The Indians need a reality check no one is after their prized lungis!

Re: Anger against Bharati govt. Rises as Does Toll in Remote Indian Islands

achhha bahiyaa naraz kiyon hottay hann…let me so do something about it…

Re: India's tasteless fears over percieved US global designs

"raising an eyebrow" is considered "diabolical hindering of aid"?

the questions you quoted are those being posed by Sri Lankans themselves, not just New Delhi.

from the same article and same person you quoted...

“India has always been helpful,” he said. “It does have the capacity and it is most natural for them to help us.”

Both Uyangoda and Kethesh Loganathan, an analyst at the Centre for Policy Alternatives, an independent think tank, said it was natural for India, with its huge resources and regional ambitions, to come to the aid of its smaller neighbours.

Close to 1,000 Indian military personnel, five navy vessels, including a hospital ship, a field hospital, and six MI-17 air force helicopters have been deployed to Sri Lanka by its giant northern neighbour.

not to forget the $25 million monetary donation

what aid has India diabolically diverted or withheld from Sri Lanka?

its pretty shameful for you to concoct the most non-existent of conspiracies just for a cheap anti-India thrill

Re: India’s tasteless fears over percieved US global designs

The anger mounts in these most sensitive of times:

India Accused of Blocking Tsunami Aid

PORT BLAIR, India - India’s refusal to allow access to the remote Andaman and Nicobar islands is preventing aid from reaching the most desperate survivors of last week’s tsunamis, international aid groups said Monday, as the country’s death toll was expected to top 15,000.

http://www.abc2news.com/news/new-site/05-01-03-tsunami-aid.shtml

Re: India’s tasteless fears over percieved US global designs

India’s decision not to accept aid now hailed

By Vaiju Naravane

PARIS JAN. 3. India’s decision not to accept international aid, initially criticised as being “false or misplaced pride,” is now being grudgingly saluted by the press and the international community.

The French right wing daily Le Figaro in its Monday edition wrote: “Overall, India has managed the crisis well. … Better, India has used the catastrophe to affirm its status as a regional superpower. Candidate for a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council, India has proved that it is not dependant on international aid, which India has refused, politely but firmly. Better still, India will, on January 6 in Jakarta, sit at the donors’ table in the company of the USA, Japan and Australia.”

The communist daily l’Humanite also criticised India’s decision to refuse aid and sought explanations from India’s ambassador to France, Dilip Lahiri. In substance, the Indian Ambassador thanked French citizens for their generosity but said the country was strong enough to look after its own. “If we find there are inadequacies, we shall not hesitate to call on the international community for help,” Mr. Lahiri said. For the moment, he added, not only was India facing up to the crisis but also helping its neighbours, Sri Lanka and the Maldives.

India’s decision to belong to the four-nation “core group” led by the United States has also given rise to speculation that India had been co-opted into an “aid coalition” that attempted to usurp the leadership role of the United Nations in disaster relief in favour of the U.S. That sense of outrage has now somewhat faded, with the U.S. Navy pressing actively into service in Indonesia and elsewhere. In the race to be among the most generous, the French who have now been bypassed by Sweden are, however, consoling themselves with their role as the European Union’s aid coordinator. The bitterness generated by the Iraq war between France and the U.S. persists and has spilled over into who should lead the reconstruction battle in Asia.

http://www.hindu.com/2005/01/04/stories/2005010411391300.htm

Re: Anger against Bharati govt. Rises as Does Toll in Remote Indian Islands

http://www.hindu.com/2005/01/04/stories/2005010411391300.htm

Re: India's tasteless fears over percieved US global designs

Playing politcs while people die is never a good thing.

Re: India’s tasteless fears over percieved US global designs

Lanka’s invitation to US Marines irks India: Tamil paper

The decision of the Sri Lankan government to accept 1,500 US Marines as part of the American contribution to tsunami relief work in the island, without taking India into confidence, has “greatly angered” India, says the Tamil daily Sudar Oli.

The Colombo-based paper, which is believed to reflect the LTTE’s view, said in a front page story on Monday, that India was very angry that Sri Lanka had disregarded India’s regional power status. Still, it went ahead and invited US troops into its backyard, without giving prior information or getting its nod first.

The paper pointed that India had rushed to Sri Lanka’s aid on the very first day of the disaster, even though the tsunami had ravaged India itself in a big way. India had sent five ships and six helicopters. INS Sandayak and INS Sukanya were in Trincomalee and INS Sarada and INS Sutlej were in Galle. INS Jamuna, with a 45 bed hospital had also been sent, the paper noted.

Sudar Oli further said that about 1,000 Indian personnel were doing relief work in the island. India had also come forward to give a financial assistance of SLRs 260 crores.

“It is said that India sent its relief workers to Sri Lanka, even before it started helping its own tsunami-stricken people, because it did not want other powers to get a foothold in its backyard,” the paper observed.

http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/181_1180615,001301540003.htm

This is from the Sri Lankan’s themselves and not the US or Indian politicians! Now tell me is this disgusting or not!?

Aid for Sri Lanka a geopolitical game

Aid for Sri Lanka a geopolitical game

CHAITANYA KALBAG
SYNDICATED COLUMNIST

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/opinion/206356_kalbag04.html

COLOMBO, Sri Lanka – Sri Lanka’s tsunami devastation has drawn a huge international aid response, but a geopolitical game of influence between India and the United States is playing not too subtly in the background.

“There is no innocence in the politics of humanitarian assistance,” said Jayadeva Uyangoda, head of the department of political science at Colombo University.

Uyangoda said Washington’s decision to send as many as 1,500 Marines and an amphibious assault ship to Sri Lanka was seen in New Delhi as not “merely humanitarian.”

“It is a symbolic intrusion into India’s sphere of influence,” he said.

Nearly 30,000 Sri Lankans were killed by the Dec. 26 tsunami and nearly a million have been made homeless.

India, determined not to be seen as just a victim after losing more than 15,000 people in the disaster, moved quickly to send help to Sri Lanka and others.

Close to 1,000 Indian military personnel, five Navy vessels including a hospital ship, a field hospital and six MI-17 Indian Air Force helicopters have been deployed to Sri Lanka by its giant northern neighbor.

The ships were moored off Trincomalee on the east coast and Galle in the south, said Nagma Mallick, spokeswoman at India’s High Commission (embassy) in Colombo.

Both Uyangoda and Kethesh Loganathan, an analyst at the Center for Policy Alternatives, an independent think tank, said it was natural for India, with its huge resources and regional ambitions, to come to the aid of its smaller neighbors.

Loganathan noted that in May 2003, when Sri Lanka’s south was hit by heavy rain and flash flooding that displaced a quarter of a million people, India sent military personnel to help in the recovery effort. “Over the past decade there has been a sea change in Indo-Lankan relations,” he said.

India was seen as a party to the island’s civil war when it exploded in 1983, he said. Egged on by its own Tamil population, India provided the rebel Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eeelam, often called Tamil Tigers, with training and materiel.

But an Indian “peace-keeping” foray into Sri Lanka’s Tamil-held areas in 1987 quickly turned into open war with the Tamil Tigers until a humiliating Indian pullout in March 1990.

That debacle also helped restore India’s credibility in the eyes of Sri Lanka’s Sinhalese majority, Loganathan said.

“India has always been helpful,” he said. “It does have the capacity and it is most natural for them to help us.”

The United States has termed the Tamil Tigers a terrorist organization and the Marines – a few dozen of whom have already arrived by air – are likely to stay well away from the north and east where the Tigers control large swathes of territory.

“Both New Delhi and Kilinochchi (the Tiger stronghold) might view the U.S. presence uncomfortably,” Uyangoda said.

But Uyangoda said the U.S. offer of assistance would certainly have “raised eyebrows” in New Delhi.

“Are the Marines going to stay in Sri Lanka? Is this part of the U.S. global design? Is this an opportunity for (U.S. President) Bush to get a foothold in Sri Lanka?” he asked rhetorically, adding: “Humanitarian is not purely humanitarian.”

“India Furious!” said a banner headline in yesterday’s issue of the Sudar Oli (Beacon Light), a Tamil-language newspaper considered sympathetic to the Tigers published from Colombo.

The newspaper said India was upset that Sri Lanka had not given it proper warning that it would be welcoming U.S. Marines into its “neighborhood.”

But G. Parthasarthy, a former Indian ambassador to Pakistan, told Reuters by telephone from New Delhi that too much ado was being made of the aid effort.

“They love conspiracy theories in Colombo,” he said.

Parthasarthy said it was clear the United States had got into the aid race rather late “after stringent domestic and international criticism.”

For the present, he said – "and please underline ‘for the present’ " – the aid seemed to be just what it was, humanitarian and with no strings attached.

In contrast, India’s polite refusal to accept any foreign aid recognized that “foreigners could come in the way of our own relief efforts,” Parthasarthy said.

“Ten foreigners come and work two hours a day and the world’s media think they’ve sorted out our problems tickety-boo,” he said.

“We have the resources to manage our own situation.”

Re: Aid for Sri Lanka a geopolitical game

Well, we are opening too many threads about the same topic "tsunami politics". I am going to merge them together. Please make sure that we do not open any new thread about the same topic. Thanks a bunch

Re: Aid for Sri Lanka a geopolitical game

.

Re: Aid for Sri Lanka a geopolitical game

Singapore to be UN regional relief centre

Today, PM Lee and Defence Minister Teo visit disaster areas in Aceh
By Chua Mui Hoong
Senior Political Correspondent

** SINGAPORE will be a regional coordination centre for international relief operations to countries hit by the tsunami disaster. **

In its biggest ever humanitarian response effort, Singapore has sent 10 helicopters, two landing ships and more than 800 military, police, civil defence and medical personnel, mainly to Thailand and Indonesia (above). -- MOHD ISHAK, MINDEF

Singapore can 'help release some of the logjams', said Mr Tan.

In its biggest ever humanitarian response effort, Singapore has sent 10 helicopters, two landing ships and more than 800 military, police, civil defence and medical personnel, mainly to Thailand and Indonesia. They will be made available to help UN relief operations.

Singapore's helicopter landing ship RSS Endurance achieved a breakthrough yesterday when it established a landing site at Meulaboh in western Sumatra, which had become inaccessible except by helicopter.

Ships can now offload vehicles, supplies and heavy engineering equipment to clear roads and debris.

Singapore also played a pivotal part in initiating Thursday's summit of world leaders to coordinate international responses to the disaster. It will be held in Jakarta, with Malaysia and Myanmar the latest to confirm they would attend.

The offer to the UN is the latest in Singapore's response.

Asked how much the effort would cost Singapore, Mr Tan said it would be 'significant', far exceeding the $5 million pledged by the government.

But what was important now, he said, was getting the aid to those affected, and reaching Singaporeans who need to be contacted.

As at 5 pm yesterday, there were 51 Singaporeans still uncontactable, down from 81. The number missing was 12, and those confirmed dead remained at nine.

Re: India’s tasteless fears over percieved US global designs

Ivan, do you understand who or what the LTTE is? They would be terribly annoyed by your ‘Sri Lankans themselves’ statement.

The LTTE would be terribly happy if it could pit India and Sri Lanka against each other (remember the I-SL defence agreement? it is primarily aimed against the LTTE). The LTTE is even more pissed because the calamity happened in Tamil dominated areas and international aid is being routed through the government at Colombo.

If the Indian (or the US or even the Pakistani, offered by the Pak government) army or navy reaches the coast, the LTTE should be worried. The LTTE has a poor reputation in Muslim dominated areas because of atrocities in the past

Re: Aid for Sri Lanka a geopolitical game

both us and india are co-operation in in sri lanka and maldives

The US yesterday sought to dispel any impression that it was a diplomatic rival of India in the South Asia region, asserting that New Delhi was taking the leadership role in relief efforts in tsunami-hit neighbours such as Sri Lanka and the Maldives.

Re: Aid for Sri Lanka a geopolitical game

Carrying on about the LTTE’s agenda wrt relief measures, here’s an article from today’s Daily Times about their new statements:
http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=story_6-1-2005_pg4_18

Tamil Tigers accuse American Marines of spying

  • US Embassy spokesman says change of plan was function of allocating right resources

COLOMBO: Two ships full of Marines and heavy equipment steaming towards Sri Lanka were diverted due to reduced need for aid, officials said, and instead bolstered the US task force off western Sumatra, the area hardest-hit by last week’s tsunami.

But the highly sensitive nature of the US relief mission in southern Asia was highlighted when a spokesman for Sri Lanka’s rebels, the Tamil Tigers - considered a terrorist organisation by Washington - said on Tuesday that the troops were being sent as spies to help put down their insurgency.

US officials insisted that the diversion of two ships had nothing to do with the Tamil Tigers’ allegations, and that rerouting the USS Bonhomme Richard and the USS Duluth followed the Sri Lankan government scaling down its request for help.

The ships will join the aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln and its battle group off the Indonesian island of Sumatra, where Navy helicopters have flown dozens of relief and evacuation missions.

The USS Mount Rushmore, carrying a smaller contingent of Marines, will travel on to Sri Lanka alone. It was expected to cross the Indian Ocean by the weekend.

US Embassy spokesman Philip Frayne said the change of plans was “purely a function of allocating the right resources in the right place.”

“The military presence is strictly for humanitarian purposes,” Frayne said. “The military will be operating in the south of the country to clear rubble and rebuild infrastructure and help Sri Lankans to recover from the tragedy.”

But a Tamil rebel leader claimed that American troops, and those from neighbouring India, being sent to help in the relief effort might use the operation as a cover to spy on the rebels, handing over intelligence to the government to help it fight the insurgents.

“The attempt by the American and Indian troops to land in Sri Lanka … is totally based on their political and military interests,” Nallathamby Srikantha told Voice of Tigers radio, the official rebel mouthpiece.

The United States and India both officially consider the Tamil Tigers, which control a large portion of Sri Lanka’s north and east, to be a terrorist group. ap